A clutter of concerns spilled across the desk in manager Clint Hurdle’s office at PNC Park. The smoke and mirrors of a brief winning streak were smashed Sunday afternoon when the Pirates put on an ugly show of baseball, and the Cincinnati Reds ran wild against right-hander Gerrit Cole.
“We’ve played some good Sunday games,” Hurdle said the Pirates’ 7-3 defeat. “Today wasn’t one of them. … I’m taking all the things that didn’t work and putting them on my desk.”
There will be plenty in his pile to leaf through on the off day.
Cole allowed four runs on three hits and three walks in 5⅔ innings, dropping to 0-6 with a 5.44 ERA in eight career starts against the Reds. The visitors stole five bases, four off Cole and starting catcher Eric Fryer. Reds right-hander Dan Straily took a perfect game into the fifth inning. And after being gifted a comeback chance by the combustible Reds bullpen, the Pirates derailed one rally after another, ending with Jordy Mercer being picked off at first base in the ninth.
“That would go right in the box as well,” Hurdle said, adding to the mess on his desk as the Pirates dropped to 55-54, neither power players in the playoff chase nor anywhere near out of it.
The Reds’ head hustler was Billy Hamilton. He was 3 for 4 with a walk, a double and four stolen bases. He scored three times before being caught stealing by Francisco Cervelli in the ninth.
Read More
“You can’t stop him, you can only hold him for a few pitches,” Cole said. “We did neither.”
Hurdle accepted blame for the Pirates’ unpreparedness to slow Hamilton, who has 43 steals, but compared him to all-time greats Rickey Henderson, Vince Coleman, Lou Brock and Maury Wills.
“He”s got that ‘go’ button that is continually on,” Hurdle said.
Cole’s day began with a costly mistake: a leadoff walk to Hamilton. The Reds’ spindly legged speedster stole second and third base. On a grounder to third, Hamilton waited out the throw across the diamond before betting again on his legs and beating John Jaso’s wild throw home.
“A walk to start off the game is pretty much a triple within four or five pitches,” Cole said.
In the top of third, Hamilton doubled, stole third and scored on Joey Votto’s sacrifice fly. In the bottom of the inning, he streaked back toward the warning track and dived to steal extra bases from Fryer, a spectacular catch that further solidified Hamilton’s persona as a pesky Pirates killer.
Cole (7-7) found his rhythm and set down 10 batters in a row before he walked Votto in the sixth. After Adam Duvall reached on a fielder’s choice, he stole second and scored when Brandon Phillips dropped a single in front of diving right fielder Matt Joyce. Cole’s outing concluded there.
“Fastball location was poor,” Cole said. “Controlling the running game was poor. Pitch efficiency was poor. You name it.”
The Pirates’ first hit off Straily came in the fifth when Joyce launched a leadoff home run to center field, his 12th homer this season. The next inning, Josh Harrison hit his fourth.
Right-hander Jared Hughes surrendered three singles and a wild pitch in the seventh before Hurdle called on right-hander Curtis Partch to get the final two outs of the inning. Both inherited runners scored before Partch got a double-play grounder, leaving the deficit 7-2.
The Reds bullpen set to work settling the score in the seventh, when right-hander Rasiel Iglesias walked the bases loaded with no outs. Mercer’s groundout knocked in a run, and pinch-hitter Cervelli singled to bring Harrison to the plate with the bases loaded and two outs.
Harrison, representing the tying run, hooked a ball foul in the left-field corner, then struck out.
“I thought it was going to be close,” Harrison said of his grand slam try. “Sure enough, it was close.”
The Pirates put two runners on base with no outs in the eighth against right-hander Michael Lorenzen. The rally died after Joyce and Jaso sandwiched strikeouts around a groundout.
“It was a tough one for us,” Harrison said, “but at the end of the day we won a series. That’s all you can ask for.”
Stephen J. Nesbitt: snesbitt@post-gazette.com and Twitter @stephenjnesbitt.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.