Declan Carlile soared down the right wing and fired a wrister past Montreal goalie Jakub Dobes. The PPG Paints Arena crowd roared as he pumped his fist and celebrated with teammates, including defensive partner Erik Karlsson.

It was a moment even Carlile couldn’t have imagined a few years ago.

He went undrafted and had one college hockey offer. After three years at Merrimack College, he had one official offer to sign an NHL contract.

“I’m kind of a late bloomer in a lot of things,” the 26-year-old Penguins defenseman said Tuesday.

Advertise with us

He toiled in the minors for three seasons as part of the Tampa Bay organization, only getting four NHL games in that span, before he spent most of last season with the Lightning.

“As an undrafted guy, at the end of the day, I’ve had to work everywhere that I’ve been,” Carlile said.

That work has paid off in a tremendous opportunity with the Penguins. Carlile is now playing on their top defensive pair next to a former Norris Trophy winner.

“Me and my fiancee talk about that all the time,” Carlile said. “A year ago today, I was in the American League.”

It’s taken him all of three games to set career highs for goals and points. He’s scored on highlight plays in back-to-back games and added a couple of assists.

Advertise with us

“If he keeps this up for another 80 games, then I’ll say I didn’t [see it coming],” Karlsson said. “But he’s obviously a skilled hockey player. He plays in this league for a reason.”

Carlile’s journey there was far from conventional.

He grew up in Michigan and got into hockey at a young age thanks to his Canadian father. Though he played pretty much every sport, skating on outdoor ice in the winter sold him on hockey.

He played in Detroit until he was 14, when he went to prep school in Indiana. From there, he spent a year with the Wellington Dukes of the Ontario Junior Hockey League, living in his father’s hometown.

When another player suffered a concussion the night before the Canadian Junior Hockey League Prospects Game, it opened the door for Carlile to play in the game. He scored twice.

Advertise with us

His performance caught the Merrimack staff’s attention.

“Merrimack was my first offer,” Carlile said. “It was my only offer.”

He thought that might be the peak of his hockey career.

“Going into freshman year of college, I kind of just was planning on getting my four-year degree and maybe playing a little pro, dabbling around with that when I was done,” Carlile said.

The Merrimack staff gave him lots of ice time and let him play through mistakes while harping on the importance of competing hard. By his junior year, Merrimack coach Scott Borek suggested he should consider getting an agent.

Advertise with us

In 2022, after his junior year, the Lightning extended Carlile an offer. They were the only team to do so. He was prepared to grind away in the minors for years.

“Being undrafted, I kind of knew that was going to be my path,” Carlile said. “And at the end of the day, I was going to be happy just getting one game at one point in my career. And now I’m here.”

He said his skating held him back for a long time. He credited Jeff Tambellini, then a Lightning college scout, for looking past it. He started working with Tampa Bay skating coach Barbara Underhill, whom he called “phenomenal.”

Carlile’s feet have looked like a strength so far in Pittsburgh.

“He skates really well,” said Kaedan Korczak, another defenseman the Penguins added this offseason. “Kind of works himself out of trouble with his skating.”

Advertise with us

Carlile made his NHL debut in January 2024. He got three more NHL games in 2024-25.

Carlile finally earned an extended opportunity in the NHL last season, though not until after the Lightning put him on waivers at the end of the preseason.

He cleared and spent the first few weeks of the season back in the American Hockey League. Then injuries struck the Tampa Bay blue line. He ended up playing 42 games for the Lightning, recording three points and a plus-5 rating.

“It helped the confidence a lot, being able to get in every night and playing against some of the best guys in the league,” Carlile said. “And I think it’s definitely carried over to this year so far.”

He hit free agency this summer. 

Advertise with us

“When Pittsburgh called, it was hard to say no,” said Carlile, who signed a two-year, $3 million contract.

He appreciated that the Penguins had faith in him and a plan for him. They said there would be opportunity.

“At the end of the day, that’s all I really wanted,” Carlile said.

He showcased his feistiness and willingness to stand up for teammates in Pittsburgh’s second preseason game. Since the regular season began, Carlile has shown that he may be more than a gritty stay-at-home defenseman.

“I knew he was a warrior, blocking shots, making it tough to play against,” defenseman Trevor van Riemsdyk said. “But he’s showing some nice offensive flair.”

Advertise with us

He added: “You just feel extremely happy for a guy like that who plays really hard to make the most of his opportunity.”

Pittsburgh has presented Carlile and his fiancee with an opportunity to be more settled. Rachel wasn’t able to work last year amid their hectic back-and-forth. Now, she’s a nurse on the oncology floor at UPMC Magee-Womens Hospital. Their Cavalier King Charles spaniel, Macie, is loving life here, too.

Carlile is friends with Carolina Hurricanes goaltender Brandon Bussi, a hero at last season’s Stanley Cup Final. Bussi also went undrafted and often uses the phrase “playing with house money.”

Carlile is applying that to his own journey to Pittsburgh’s top defensive pair.

“Everything happens for a reason, and it’s all worked out so far,” he said.