“Watch this.”
On his way to a postgame press conference 20 years ago, then-Penguins coach Michel Therrien wanted to make sure the communications staff was paying attention.
He’d had enough. Hired to replace Eddie Olczyk in mid-December after an awful start for the Penguins, the Montreal native had witnessed the losses continue to pile up. But that wasn’t what bothered him most.
“The attitude of the players, I didn’t like it,” Therrien told the Post-Gazette earlier this week. “I knew we were going in the wrong direction. … I wanted to attack the integrity of the players because their attitude was, winning or losing, they didn’t care. They were the same.”
Meanwhile, he was “torturing” himself in his office after losses. So he hatched a plan — he would air his grievances in the media, sending his team a public message they couldn’t ignore.
He waited a few days for the right moment to deliver it. The opportunity came in the form of a 3-1 home loss to Edmonton on Jan. 10, 2006. Therrien gave the communications staff that brief heads-up then stepped inside the Mellon Arena media room.
Read More
What transpired next lives on as perhaps the most memorable moment of a 2005-06 season filled with landmarks. But his rant wasn’t just a viral moment. It served as a turning point for the organization.
“He wanted to send us a message,” Sidney Crosby said this week. “And it was sent. We got the point.”
The ‘pivot point’
Therrien doesn’t remember the question or who asked it, but generations of Penguins fans remember his response.
At that postgame press conference, he proceeded to call the performance “pathetic,” the defensemen “soft” and suggested that the team take half their salaries because they played only half the game.
Therrien was not yelling. He spoke slowly in his French Canadian accent, making sure reporters heard every word.
Saturday marks 20 years since that press conference, perhaps the most iconic in franchise history.
This was not a “raving-lunatic rant,” as former Penguins vice president of communications Tom McMillan put it. It was calculated — and was “going to take a while to sink in.”
But it eventually did. The Penguins emerged from years of futility to reach the playoffs in 2007. Therrien took them to the Stanley Cup Final in 2008. They would win it the next year, though Therrien was fired in February and watched Dan Bylsma lead the team to the 2009 Cup.
The 2005-06 season was Crosby’s rookie year. It was Mario Lemieux’s last. But somehow, a press conference in the middle of January might be the lasting memory of that campaign.
“That, to me, was a pivot point,” said McMillan, who spent 25 years as the Penguins’ VP of communications and before that covered the team for the Post-Gazette. “We’re not doing it this way anymore. The culture is going to change. Everything’s changing tomorrow morning, and it did.
“He was a structured, defensive-minded, hard-ass coach … Mike wasn’t there [in 2009], when we actually won the Cup. But he, in many ways, had a hand on the Cup.”
The lead-up
Colby Armstrong was not surprised by the rant. A Penguins rookie at the time, he had seen it before while playing under Therrien in Wilkes-Barre/Scranton.
Therrien would criticize players in the media there, as well, but the relative obscurity of the American Hockey League prevented those instances from going viral.
“From our perspective as players, it was kind of funny because we knew him by then,” Armstrong, now a broadcaster for SportsNet Pittsburgh and other outlets, said this week. “We knew he was hard on us for certain reasons. He wanted to get the most out of us. He actually cared about us.
“At the time, when you’re in it, you’re like, ‘Oh, man, this guy hates me.’ But by the time I’d gotten to the NHL, when that great, legendary postgame press conference happened, I was accustomed to it.”
Therrien led the Baby Pens to a 21-1-2-1 start before his promotion to Pittsburgh.
He took over a Penguins team in turmoil. The Penguins were 8-17-6, with Crosby racking up points as an 18-year-old but the team’s mix of young players and veterans otherwise struggling mightily.
Therrien’s first game on Dec. 16 would be Lemieux’s last. The team and league were still recovering from the lockout the season before. It was far from certain the Penguins would remain in Pittsburgh.
The 42-year-old coach saw immediately that it would be an uphill battle.
“First of all, they were out of shape,” Therrien said. “... Our first practice, the guys were dying on the ice, so we’re looking at each other — we knew right away that we were in trouble.”
Another worrisome sign came in Atlanta on Jan. 6. The Thrashers’ Ilya Kovalchuk scored a power-play goal off a Crosby penalty and taunted the rookie by pointing at him in the box. Therrien did not see the Penguins stick up for their young teammate and added that to the list of complaints in his Jan. 10 rant.
“There’s not one guy [who] was close to [doing] something,” Therrien said during it. “Maybe Maxime Talbot at the end, with one second left. He’s about 5 foot 8. Did they think that, as a coach, I got the feeling that [the] team cares for each other? Wow.”
Crosby wasn’t as offended as his coach was about what transpired in Atlanta.
“I was more mad at myself for taking the penalty and putting my team down and them scoring,” the Penguins’ captain said. “But you don’t like to get singled out like that, especially after a goal, so probably wanted to get back.”
But that moment irked Therrien so much because it went against his fundamental understanding of what playing hockey is all about.
“You got to fight for your teammates. You got to battle for your teammates. And this is what I didn’t see,” he said this week.

The rant
The Penguins lost to Atlanta again the next night. Then on Jan. 10, Shawn Horcoff — the father of current Penguins prospect Will Horcoff — scored his only career hat trick as the Oilers won 3-1 at Mellon Arena. That loss afforded Therrien a chance to lay into his team.
Therrien’s ensuing presser is one of the more famous ones in NHL history. Among the gems from that night were:
• “It’s a pathetic performance. Half of the team doesn’t care.”
• “What those guys will say if we take … 50% of their salary because they only play for 50% of the time? That’s enough.”
• “That defensive squad, I really start to believe their goal is to be the worst defensive squad in the league. And they’re doing such a great job to be the worst defensive squad in the league.”
• “They’re soft. I’ve never seen a bunch of defenseman soft like this.”
The team became aware of Therrien’s comments almost immediately, Armstrong said, and it was quickly picked up by outlets across the country.
“I don’t know if the veteran guys took it like the young guys,” he said. “Us young guys, we were like, ‘Oh man.’ Like, we were kind of giggling, like, ‘Oh, that’s bad.’
“And I think the old guys were more offended … [That was] just the way it was, just the state of our organization and team at the time, and he was driving hard to change it. And he did.”
Therrien gave Armstrong his first NHL opportunity, bringing the player he’d coached for years in Wilkes-Barre to Pittsburgh a couple of weeks after he was named the Penguins’ coach.
What Therrien shared with the media he would say to players, as well.
Armstrong, then 23, had a meeting with Therrien around the time of the famous press conference where the tough-minded coach demanded more from him.
“Looking back on it now, I don’t know if I could have been the player I ended up being or having the career, if I didn’t have him milking everything out of me,” Armstrong said.
The aftermath
After leaving the room full of stunned reporters, Therrien turned to the communications staff again and provided another reminder that this was not an emotional response to an ugly loss — it was part of a bigger plan.
“How was that?” he asked them.
“I think we were all too startled to say anything,” McMillan said.
But with the benefit of hindsight, the longtime communications VP — who has deep institutional knowledge of the Penguins — called it a “transformative moment for the organization.”
“It’s more important in retrospect than it was in the moment,” McMillan said. “You wouldn’t have known that at the time. You couldn’t have imagined the Penguins would become what they became.”
Therrien’s rant, for all the national attention it drew, did not trigger some instant turnaround. The Penguins gave up a goal 10 seconds into their game the next day at Columbus. It only got worse from there.
“Oh my God, we got shelled the next day,” Armstrong said. “Like, really bad. I remember that.”
The Penguins fell 6-1 and proceeded to lose 13 of the next 14 games.
Yet the press conference after the Blue Jackets loss was the moment McMillan realized Therrien could really coach. Rather than tearing into his team again, he praised them for the one small positive from the game.
They started fighting for each other.
So much that six different Penguins dropped the gloves — including Ryan Malone, who took a beating from Mike Rupp.
“It didn’t go our way, but I definitely think that the message of competing was sent to us,” Crosby said.
That was all Therrien needed to see. He knew improving the team on the ice would take a while. He had to build the culture first.
“The guys start caring about each other,” Therrien said. “We start building a team. The result was not important. It was not about the result. It was about caring for each other. This is what I was able to accomplish, and when you start to accomplish that, when they show some pride, when they show some emotion, you could start to go forward.”
After starting 12-34-11 that season, the Penguins rallied to go 10-12-3 down the stretch. That catapulted them into a 2007 season where Crosby won the Hart Trophy as league MVP, Evgeni Malkin took home the Calder Trophy as top rookie and Pittsburgh returned to the playoffs for the first time since 2001.

The legacy
The impact of Therrien’s rant, and his hard-nosed coaching style throughout his Penguins tenure, became clear as the team reached two straight Stanley Cup Finals in 2008 and 2009.
“It was a message to the young players,” McMillan said. “He knew there were some young players there. He didn’t want to lose them … He thought some of the older players just didn’t care. They were going through the motions, they weren’t his concern …
“He was trying to send a message to the young players that things are going to change here. If you look at the roster, there were some guys who were around for some pretty good times.”
Players such as Crosby, Armstrong, Talbot, Malone, Marc-Andre Fleury, Ryan Whitney and Sergei Gonchar were in the lineup for that miserable game versus Edmonton and would go on to accomplish big things in Pittsburgh and elsewhere.
“This is where I’m the most proud,” Therrien said. “Where did I pick them up, and when I left, where they were.”
It is undeniable that he left the Penguins better than he found them. They went from one of the worst teams in the NHL to a Cup contender. After years with thousands of empty sets, the fanbase bought in and launched the 633-game sellout streak in February 2007.
The press conference for which he’s most remembered in Pittsburgh is emblematic of the work Therrien did behind the scenes to turn a crop of talented young players into the backbone of a dynasty.
“He was integral at changing the culture, expectation day-to-day,” Armstrong. “He changed a lot of that when he came in. And he had to push a lot of buttons to do it.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.