DALLAS — A valid argument could be made for the Penguins to feel good about themselves after taking five of six points on a difficult road trip. They simply came up one short Sunday when the Stars scored with under two minutes to go in the third period, then finished off a 3-2 victory in the shootout.

One problem: That’s not a line of thinking most players inside the Penguins dressing room at American Airlines Center were willing to accept.

Five of six might be nice. A better defensive effort was welcomed. But this group, its expectations raised, wanted that final point.

“A little disappointing,” Tristan Jarry said. “We were right there.”

Advertise with us

Jarry, who stopped 21 of 23 shots and again delivered a stellar performance, had every right to feel that way.

With the goalie pulled, the Stars hemmed the Penguins (14-7-6) in their own zone for nearly two minutes before defenseman Miro Heiskanen got the game-tying goal from 54 feet at 18:11.

Same thing when right winger Mikko Rantanen notched the only goal in the shootout, tucking a shot inside the post to Jarry’s right.

This could’ve been so much more, a sizable statement on where the Penguins are at and how they’re not what everyone expected in September.

Instead, it was another late lead lost and more struggles when games extend beyond regulation.

Advertise with us

“You walk away disappointed based on the result,” Penguins coach Dan Muse said. “I thought the overall game that we played, we want to come away with two points on that.

“When we get a little removed from it, I think we will see there was a lot of positives. But, still, it’s a fine line. Those points are important. There are things that obviously we could have done to secured [both] points.”

It’s refreshing that the Penguins aren’t in this for moral victories or participation trophies. There’s no more cute belief that they’ve surprised people for a couple weeks. There’s frustration when they screw up.

Which they did Saturday.

At the same time, you can’t deny the trajectory of this team right now. Among the many examples from this road trip:

Advertise with us

• The Penguins weren’t happy with how they played defensively against the Lightning, and they had ample evidence to feel that way. It was much better against the Stars.

Aside from a 5-1 Dallas edge in odd-man rushes, the Penguins didn’t afford the offensively gifted Stars much. Pittsburgh led in shots on goal (29-23) and shot attempts (69-55).

“We played a lot in their zone,” Jarry said. “We were putting pucks on net. We were hemming them in. I thought we had a lot of offensive zone time.”

• More big picture, but it speaks to how far beyond the Penguins are when it comes to the belief stage. They have elite special teams, strong goaltending and a solid amount of scoring depth.

There are issues protecting leads and playing past regulation. However, take Bryan Rust’s answer when it comes to whether there’s been some belief building: “Belief was never missing.”

Advertise with us

• Their third line continues to look like a keeper. There’s chemistry between Ben Kindel, Rutger McGroarty and Ville Koivunen. The road trip saw Koivunen score his first NHL goal and Kindel catch a second wind. The 18-year-old’s ability has been especially evident on the power play.

• Jarry was terrific on the trip, continuing the season trend. His skaters hung him out to dry on Jamie Benn’s two-on-one goal early in the second, and it’s hard to stop what you can’t see with Heiskanen. The only doubt with Jarry at this point should be whether he’ll still be a Penguin in a couple weeks.

• Their fourth line could be solid. Noel Acciari returned Sunday and helped set up Connor Dewar. Those two flanking Blake Lizotte clicked earlier this year and once again showed cohesion against the Stars.

• Sidney Crosby has been Sidney Crosby. Rust continues to show toughness and scoring touch, and Tommy Novak — who put the Penguins ahead, 2-1, with his tip of Kris Letang’s shot at 5:56 of the second — has six points in his past five games.

There’s been far more good than bad. Just don’t try to tell that to Letang or other leaders.

Advertise with us

“We were in a good spot,” Letang said. “To let that second point go is hard. We’re still learning. We’re still trying to improve our game.”

Sunday was a tough test. The Stars were 7-1-2 in their past 10 and had a measly two regulation losses over the past six weeks. Only the Colorado Avalanche had more points, while only three NHL teams averaged more goals per game.

The Penguins held that group in check, in the second period accounting for 11 of 14 shots on goal and 27 of 37 attempts. They showed they could go toe-to-toe with anyone.

However, those lessons are probably best saved for another day.

“Overall, it was a good display of hockey,” Letang said. “But at the end of the day, it’s frustrating when you’re in the position like we were.”

Advertise with us

It was over when …

Letang couldn't score to extend the shootout. Rantanen was the only one with a goal, as the Penguins fell to 0-4 in shootouts this season.

Stat of the game

20: The Penguins have points in 20 of their 27 games. However, if they could’ve prevented half of their overtime/shootout losses (6), they’d be in second place in the Metropolitan Division.

Around the boards

• Before the game, the Penguins announced Evgeni Malkin would sit out with an upper-body injury. Muse said afterward his status remains day-to-day. The team activated Justin Brazeau and Acciari from injured reserved.

• The Penguins also reassigned Boko Imama to Wilkes-Barre/Scranton and recalled Harrison Brunicke and Jack St. Ivany from their conditioning stints with the organization’s American Hockey League affiliate.

Brunicke was part of the 23-man roster. St. Ivany, who was injured during the preseason, still carries an injured non-roster designation — where he doesn’t count against the 23-player limit.

Advertise with us

• Connor Clifton was the Penguins’ only healthy scratch.

• The Penguins lost Rust for the second period with what looked like a right arm or hand injury. He was replaced for 20 minutes by McGroarty but returned for the third. Rust has had a few injury scares recently. However, he refuses to make excuses or feel sorry for himself. “Hockey’s a man’s game,” Rust said.

• With Malkin sidelined, Rust took his place as an alternate captain along with Letang.

Up next

The Penguins are scheduled to practice at noon Monday at UPMC Lemieux Sports Complex. They’ll host the Ducks on Tuesday night at PPG Paints Arena.