TAMPA, Fla. — Erik Karlsson maintained a safe distance, read the play and refrained from doing anything silly. It was a lot like how the three-time Norris Trophy winner has conducted himself during a resurgent season with the Penguins.
The topic was this version of Karlsson, the setting Wednesday after practice at UPMC Lemieux Complex, the question a simple one: What has led to what we’re seeing out of you this season compared to the past two?
Karlsson could’ve cited the coaching change, a new system or different deployment under Dan Muse. A number of things, really. The colorful and articulate Swede kept his answer professional and inward focused.
“I’ve been feeling great for quite some time now,” Karlsson said. “I’ve been healthy. I feel good. I feel like I’m moving well and seeing the game the way that I want to. Collectively, as a group, we’ve been playing some good hockey. That’s the main reason for anyone’s success.”
Karlsson is entitled to his opinion, but I’m not buying it. He’s playing better because the system is different, because a bunch of guys have bought into what Muse has been doing compared to Mike Sullivan — a terrific coach, mind you, who simply reached his expiration date in Pittsburgh.
Just a few examples to quantify the stark contrast in Karlsson’s play:
Read More
• Should it continue, his goals-for percentage during 5-on-5 play (56.3) would represent the best of Karlsson’s career when he has played at least 50 games.
• Same deal for his goals-against per 60 minutes of 5-on-5 ice time (1.85). For additional context, Karlsson’s GA/60 a season ago was 3.18.
• Prior to Thursday, Karlsson and partner Parker Wotherspoon had been on the ice for just 10 goals against 5-on-5, tied for fifth fewest among defense pairs that have logged at least 275 minutes together.
Not bad for someone who previously was considered a defensive liability or whose game in Pittsburgh had featured some offensive splash but not enough to overcome the miscues or justify his sizable contract.
It’s a different discussion now.
Karlsson has been an elite facilitator on the NHL’s deadliest power play. He’s also been a stable defender and swift skater capable of generating offense in ways that separate him from his peers.
You know, why Penguins president of hockey operations Kyle Dubas originally traded for Karlsson.
“He’s playing hard at both ends of the ice,” Penguins coach Dan Muse said. “He skates so well. That plays such a big role on the defensive side of it. Even sometimes as teams are trying to come out of the zone, the way he’s able to gap and surf and end plays there early on. Then closing, too, using his legs and taking away time and space in the defensive zone.”
‘Defending really hard’
Most impressive might be that Karlsson has been better and more responsible defensively while not sacrificing offense. He’s averaging 1.77 points per 60 in all situations, which represents the high-water mark for his time in Pittsburgh and eighth best among the 16 seasons where he has played at least half of his team’s games.
Put another way, Karlsson isn’t getting scored on less because he’s playing an overly cautious game. He’s just making better risk-reward decisions and seemingly has bought into what Muse wants out of his defensemen.
“He’s playing the game really hard,” Tristan Jarry said of Karlsson. “He’s playing a hard game down low. He’s defending really hard, and I think that’s leading to a lot of good chances at the other end. But first and foremost, he’s taking care of the defensive zone, and it has shown. He’s been very good.”
The whole thing has changed the calculus for Dubas in a way. While Karlsson didn’t exactly have a robust market this summer, Dubas likely could move the defenseman now if he wanted to. But why would you want to trade one of the best players of his generation who’s suddenly performing like it again?
This version of Karlsson has been fun to watch and extremely beneficial for the team. Even if the arrival was later than expected.
For one recent example, take the play he made Thursday on Ben Kindel’s power-play goal. Karlsson knew exactly what he was doing, delivering a hard, shot-pass that stuck close to the ice, setting up Kindel for an easy deflection.
It’s one of countless playmaking moments we’ve seen from Karlsson, along with his absurd zone entry Monday in Philadelphia that set up another power-play goal. But watch Karlsson without the puck, and you’ll see what Jarry referenced — a player taking care of his own zone first, rarely finding himself out of position.
“He’s been awesome for us,” Jarry added. “He’s been one of the key guys for us this year.”
Underlying data
Along with the better and more responsible decision-making, there’s also the skating, another part of Karlsson’s game that can be better appreciated with numbers.
According to NHL Edge data, Karlsson this season registered a max skating speed (Oct. 11 vs. Rangers) of 23.39 mph that puts him in the 99th percentile league-wide. For context, it’s not all that different from what known speedsters such as Connor McDavid (24.61), Logan Cooley (24.38) or Cale Makar (23.68) have done.
Karlsson has registered 48 speed bursts of 20 mph or more, which puts him in the 97th percentile. The average for a defenseman, meanwhile, is just 12.5.
Those numbers translated: At 35, Karlsson still can move. And he’s not using that superpower to skate himself out of a play.
“I don’t think there’s one specific reason for [the change in play],” Karlsson said. “There are a lot of things. It’s hard to pinpoint what those things are. But in general I’ve been feeling good since Day 1. Talking to everyone around here, I think everyone would say the same. I don’t think there’s one specific reason for it.”
Also among the signature traits that have not left Karlsson and have been enhanced with better decision-making — his shot.
Karlsson cranked one 96.64 mph Nov. 3 at Toronto, putting him in the 94th percentile league-wide for hardest shot. His average shot speed this season sits at 71.74 mph (87th percentile).
Combine that with knowing how to use it, having the puck in the offensive zone a bunch (44.4%, 85th percentile) and Karlsson being surrounded by guys who can score, yeah, it adds up to a solid season.
“He’s confident,” Bryan Rust said of Karlsson. “He’s playing his game, the game that makes him successful and playing off his instincts. When you get a guy who’s that skilled, who’s that good, the more he can use his instincts and not overthink things, the better he’s going to be.”
Bigger goals ahead
The easy narrative with Karlsson continues to be the Sullivan factor, the elephant in the room, the topic Karlsson kept his space with a few days ago.
Nothing wrong with that. Karlsson wouldn’t be the first player to respond better to a new coach, nor will he be the last. It’s also highly doubtful Sullivan — a two-time Stanley Cup winner who has forgotten more about hockey than most of us will ever know — suddenly took stupid pills.
Whatever the case, it’s working now. As Muse said, the Penguins aren’t concerned about the past. Karlsson has been good in his own zone and has expanded his role to killing penalties, and the Penguins have been better off because of it.
Much like their top defenseman, the Penguins were aware of external expectations prior to the start of the season. Not in an arrogant way, but they’ve taken plenty of pride in proving their doubters wrong. Nobody has had more to say on that front, at least with his play on the ice, than Karlsson.
“I’ve had a bunch of coaches,” Karlsson said. “I don’t read too much into stuff like that.
“In general, as a group, since I’ve gotten here we haven’t accomplished the goals that we set out to accomplish. It’s been a rough couple of years collectively. This year, we got off to a good start. Winning a few games and being in the mix has helped not only me but everybody else as well. It makes everything a little bit easier.”
Around the boards
The Penguins on Friday placed Joona Koppanen on waivers. The move could mean a couple things. There could be a promotion from Wilkes-Barre/Scranton coming. Or Noel Acciari, Justin Brazeau or both could be ahead of schedule in their returns from upper-body injuries. Acciari and Brazeau are fully cleared and have been practicing with the team this week. But Penguins president of hockey operations Kyle Dubas said on Wednesday they were likely still 7-10 days from returning. The Penguins practice Saturday outside of Dallas.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.