Jason Mackey: Hello, everyone. Welcome to my ... wait a second, Penguins chat. Ha. The old days!
Anyway, feel free to ask Pirates stuff as well. We'll handle both. You know the drill. Start around noon. Fire away now.
Jason Mackey: Also and related: The way we do things here is a little different. I answer anything and everything, as long as it's in good taste. Don't be shy.
Kris P.: Jason, realizing that there will always be someone injured, but if we ever get to the point where that is only maybe one forward hurt, then who are the 13 guys up front for you? I mean when Rakell, Brazeau and Acciari return, who gets sent back to WB?
Jason Mackey: Yes, I get your question. It's a good one. I would keep Kindel here, first off. It probably looks like this:
Rakell-Crosby-Rust
Read More
Brazeau-Malkin-Mantha
Dewar-Kindel-Koivunen
Hayes-Lizotte-Broz
Novak
This would send Heinen & Koppanen back.
I also don't love some of the lines here. I might get Koivunen with Malkin. I wouldn't mind more size on the third line.
Broz probably isn't best deployed as a 4RW, and I don't like scratching Novak.
But I'm pretty sure those are my 13. For now.
Kris P.: I'm still trying to confirm but everything I've read so far says that a player on conditioning assignment still counts towards the teams 23 man roster. If that is so, can we really afford to try and play with just 21 guys in Pittsburgh for 2 weeks? I get Brunicke's situation, but what don't they just waive St. Ivany back to WB and add a roster spot to the big club now?
Jason Mackey: You make a fine point on St. Ivany. With Brunicke, I'm OK with the in-between. I would leave the door open for him, at least for under 14 days. He may be one of their six best defensemen. I don't think St. Ivany is, at least not right now.
You are correct, by the way, based on what I've seen.
Kris P.: Murashov back to Wilkes Barre I guess, right?
Jason Mackey: Certainly the feel, yes.
Brad: On a a scale of 1 to 10, how much do you believe the Pirates will actually make a bigger splash than last year in FA or trades this offseason?
Jason Mackey: This is tricky, Brad. I hope I articulate this well enough.
A splash? Yes. If you think about still waters, which is what the Pirates have been in FA, hard to not make a splash, right?
Do I think they're gonna sign Schwarber, Polanco, O'Hearn or someone of that ilk? Highly doubtful. Heck no on Schwarber.
Now, do I think they can get guys below the aforementioned who can actually help the team -- Cedrick Mullins is someone I really like in this vein -- yes, I do. You can overpay slightly, sign him for multiple years, and there's a solid chance he bounces back here.
I do think they can have an offseason that changes the tenor around the team. But it's not gonna be by signing Kyle Schwarber or someone like that. What incentive does he have to come here?
Eric: Sorry Jason, I have a Pirates question. My question is, do you think they give out a contract that breaks the Liriano deal in both years (3) and in total salary ($39 million) this off season?
Jason Mackey: Don't be sorry. It's a weird time for yours truly. Fun as heck, don't get me wrong. But I went from columnist to Pirates to Penguins in a short period of time. Ask anything, I won't be offended. Anyway, no, I don't. I would love to be wrong, believe me. Like I said earlier, though, anyone with those kind of options, hard to fathom why that player would come here.
I do think they'll sign someone for multiple years, but that isn't what you asked. Could see them giving Mullins or someone else two as an overpay.
Matt: Ketel Marte seems to be available. If Pirates management can’t convince big-time free agents to come to Pittsburgh, seems like trading for them might be the best option. What would be a fair return for Marte? Would you do it?
Jason Mackey: I'm not in those discussions and thus somewhat unqualified to predict what a team would be willing to give up. That said, what I've read on Marte, it wouldn't be small. They have every right to ask for a bunch. Which in Pirates terms would have to mean Ashcraft or Chandler, right? Kind of feel like the Pirates could get some version of that production another way without giving up the tonage of prospects it might take.
Mr Ed: Just curious Jason, if you don’t mind a personal question, why you chose to leave the columnist position to return to covering Pirates full time. From a distance, being a columnist where you can go where the stories merit and have a great diversity, to a day to day grind covering one team. I would imagine the beat reporter job would also be a little harder on family time?
Jason Mackey: Someone asked it! Of course. Happy to expound:
Because I missed the grind. So did my family.
I missed traveling. I missed going to the rink or field every day -- things that weren't required as a columnist. I missed reporting: building relationships, obtaining information, telling stories, that sort of thing. Putting my opinion on a page did little for me. I didn't feel accomplished. I didn't feel creative. I missed that feeling of working a locker/dressing room and feeling like I did something that nobody else did.
Furthermore, think about this in your own life. My family was calibrated to beat life for 10 years. That's how we learned how to live. We're intentional with time. They sometimes travel with me. My wife also likes the freedom to run our house as she sees fit.
The only thing stopping me was ego. So to quote Sturgill Simpson, I woke up one day and decided to kill it. I'm run on a better temperature as a beat writer.
Bill: Great to seed you on this "beat," even though it might be temporary.
Jason Mackey: Me as well, Bill! If nothing else -- I genuinely don't know what the future holds -- it has been an amazing creative palate cleanser. Big proponent of changing variables to spur creativity. And this helps the paper in the short term.
Bill: Will Murashov stay when Jarry comes back?
Jason Mackey: Nothing is official, but I don't think so.
Matt: Red Sox probably off the table for Keller trade. Who should the Pirates be looking to now? Orioles for Mayo or Beavers a possibility? Maybe just take prospects back from someone and use the savings on a FA.
Jason Mackey: I would be fine with either option, Matt. The Orioles still make sense to me. I like Westburg a lot. No issue with those you mentioned. Or if you had a chance to get a bunch of prospects and spend that money differently, I wouldn't have an issue doing that either. As long as you spent the money.
Matt: Are the Pirates actually engaged with Schwarber? According to some outlets he’s going to get 5/$30 million per. Would think the pirates would have to go 6 years or 5 for $35. Should they?
Jason Mackey: I think it's all moot, honestly. I don't doubt they're checking in. Actively, too. Monitoring the market and all of that. But if Kyle Schwarber signs a five-year deal, why would he tether himself to the Pirates? Based on what belief? That's why I'm saying the actually engaged thing is a misnomer. They can be engaged without there being any threat of him signing here.
Jeff: The national media baseball writers reporting the Pirates will spend money this winter. Is this just speculation on their part or is someone inside the front office feeding these rumors?
Jason Mackey: No sane national baseball writer -- or baseball writer period -- would consider it good business to predict or speculate that the Pirates will spend money. Ha.
I think you're seeing the organization work aggressively to get a story out there. Leaking it.
Now, I do think they'll be active this offseason, more than they have been, in large part because they have to. If NOW isn't the time to spend more or go for it, dear Lord just end it and run something else.
They get that. They need to spend. I just don't expect them to go much higher than $100 million, if they eclipse that number at all.
Stanley Cup Legacy: So we see on social media all the time "Tomlin won a Super Bowl with Cowher's players" as if the players stumbled out on the field and coached themselves. Using that line of reasoning couldn't the same have been said for Mike Sullivan ? That he won with Mike Johnston's or Dan Byslma's players ?
Jason Mackey: Ha. I suppose we could, yes. Although Mike Johnston was here for 5 minutes. I think they're different scenarios.
Murray, Rust, Sheary, Kuhnhackl, Dumoulin, Wilson, etc.? Young guys. Are they ... Sullivan's? Johnston? Bylsma? Daley was Sullivan. Ian Cole Johnston. Hainsey Sully. I'm just randomly naming people. Cullen Sully. Sid, Geno, Letang ... Therrien? Kessel Sully. Hornqvist Johnston?
Ryan: Jason what do you think about the play of Bryan Rust this year i think he has due for a big game tonight Happy Thanksgiving Let’s go pens
Jason Mackey: Hi Ryan. Just finished chatting with Bryan Rust, actually. Same as ever, honestly. Consistent. Hard-working. Great on the forecheck. Great blend of skill sets.
Matt: So you don’t think even Polanco or O’Hearn would come here? I know the history, but this a promising team, with the pitching staff and Griffin coming up. And they’d likely be assured full-time roles here.
Jason Mackey: No, I don't. They'd have regular roles, yes. But there's concern from the outside -- I know I'm not breaking any news here -- when it comes to the Pirates' financial commitment to winning.
The way you change that, of course, is to win. Then guys wanna come here. More fans come. Payroll goes up. Repeat process. But they haven't gotten it off the ground.
We're essentially expecting players to skip ahead to step 4 without the first three happening.
Which is it ?: Were the Pirates in on Naylor or not ? Seems like conflicting stories although knowing this owner, I'm more likely to believe they were NOT
Jason Mackey: Another hard-to-define term, so I'll tell you what I know or what I've heard:
The amount of money wasn't an issue for the Pirates.
Technically, yeah, I guess you could say they were in because they spent time on it.
Whether they offered or not is muddy. I heard both that they didn't and it came late and wasn't anything to make Naylor reconsider. I'm not sure it matters.
I think we can confidently say they weren't a serious option in the Naylor sweepstakes. For a few reasons. One being I'm not sure he ever wanted to leave Seattle.
Jeff: Looking at Mullins stats the last few years, seems like he is in decline. Is there no one better out there that will take Pirates offer?
Jason Mackey: I'm not holding up Cedric Mullins as the one and only option. I'm trying to answer a lot of questions quickly, and he's the first that popped into my head.
But I do think they're gonna have to be realistic here. Think of a 1-100 scale. They're not overpaying the 90th percentile guys. They have better options. The Pirates are still the Pirates. But you can overpay someone in the 70th percentile, especially if you can predict their performance to bounce back.
Mullins is just one example of a guy with previous production ... but who might benefit from a lot of playing time. Would put Kepler, Conforto, Bader and a few others in that same bucket.
Why ?: Why would anyone in their right mind actually believe the Pirates are going to spend money this off-season ? And why would ANY even marginally decent free agent come to this city ? This is Baseball Hell. As Mike Lange would say about the Pirates claim that "I've seen that fish before". Its all a lie
Jason Mackey: They're gonna have to explain the pitching staff, explain the plan, maybe build out the bullpen first and overpay. I think people will come here. Just not the top of the market.
Tom: What would you think of Kindle centering Koivunen and MCGroarty? Is it to big of a risk being all young for a third line or do you bite the bullet and say this is our line of the future and get them playing together now?
Jason Mackey: For now, no. I would spread the wealth. If McGroarty is up, I might play him with Sid while Rakell is out. Ideally, I'd like Koivunen with Malkin. But I also have kind of liked Geno's line recently. Kindel will be a scratch tonight.
Jim: Happy Thanksgiving Jason, Is it Nutting's PR Guy that is "leaking" this info about the miser opening his wallet to sell a few season tickets?
Jason Mackey: I don't know who's leaking it. But I do think it's funny how every national writer has taken a trip down the slide.
Tom: Lots of injuries derailed a promising start but this also might be who the Pens really are, ok but not very good. Do you start thinking about the future developement of players and lines yet and worry less about wins?
Jason Mackey: I don't see why I have to pick, Tom. I'm gonna play my first group each night. I get what they're doing with Kindel. No issue there. But when McGroarty is ready, he'll be here. Broz is here now. You have some vets you're gonna play. They've actually been pretty good.
I think it's entirely possible they're OK, a fringe playoff team, but I don't think I need to decide if they're really good or they stink right now. They only have so many options.
Matt: Seems like the ship has sailed on a Skenes extension. Most logical next option would be extend Griffin. But what about Bubba? I would like to see them do both. But Bubba could lead the rotation when it’s time to inevitably trade Skenes.
Jason Mackey: Griffin is a no-brainer for me. Best money they could spend this offseason.
Chandler ... I don't know. I'm not against it. Depends on the number. I do worry about arm injuries. If you study those extensions, they're pretty much exclusive to position players.
Obviously Paul is a special case. And Bubba might be, too. But I would need to know a number.
demosthenes98: I know this is a ways off and not Pirates-specific, but...are there expected to be any issues in the MLB CBA negotiations that don't pertain to player pay? Are there any baseball matters up for debate?
Jason Mackey: Assuming you're talking about on-field rules? Because I'd throw out something like how soon players reach free agency -- service time -- as an obvious one. But you would probably consider that player pay. With ABS, I can't think of any other on-field sticking point. Maybe some clarification or improvement of replay rules? Without getting into too much detail, there are things they could fix.
demosthenes98: How little credit do the Pirates deserve for Paul Skenes winning the NL Cy Young Award?
Jason Mackey: Weird way to ask this. You can be mad about the Pirates. You should be mad about the Pirates.
But ... I don't know, they employed his catcher, they have analytics/infrastructure that has helped him. I know the offense has stunk, but they did play defense behind him. It's not nothing. And they also afford him carte blanche to train and prepare how he wants.
Be mad all you want. You're not wrong. Just not interested in trying to make up a percentage to satiate your frustration.
Matt: Sorry to inundate you with so many questions/statemebt, but back to the Polanco/O’Hearn topic…if they can’t convince even those mid-tier guys to come to Pittsburgh, they won’t be able to crack $100 million even if they wanted to. That would be a PR nightmare after all of these national stories. Talk about shooting yourselves in the foot…
Jason Mackey: Yes, it absolutely would. They have to do something or it's gonna look really bad.
JBird: Did I miss something- are you off the Pirates beat and strictly Penguins now? Appreciate all your Pirates insight!!
Jason Mackey: I'm covering Pens for 2 months. Matt Vensel moved into an editor role, which has been both needed and a career goal of his. You never know when that might come around again -- we're also in our busiest time of the year -- so I agreed to help out on Pens.
More about me: I hate offseasons. They've been a struggle for me for a long time. My family, too. I find it weird that I'm supposed to live one way for eight months, then all of a sudden, whoops, you're not gonna do that anymore. My wife and kids have struggled with that, too.
So, I saw this as a creative change, a way to try something different this winter, something I know and like while also covering a team that's interesting.
I don't know the ending. We'll see how it goes. All I know is I've agreed to cover Pens for 2 months, and we'll revisit in January.
Jeff: I still don’t understand why it seems a given Triolo will play SS or 3b.
Jason Mackey: I don't think it is. I think he'll be on the roster. He should be on the roster. And he might just keep SS warm for Konnor Griffin, which is fine. But they need more offense.
Hoops: How's Westminster hoops this year ? Probably get run over by St Vincent again this year (lol)
Jason Mackey: Man. I've been so busy recently that I haven't looked. Shame on me. I'm a bad Titan.
Matt: Bubba Chandler extension - 8yrs/$80 Million. Would that work for both sides?
Jason Mackey: I haven't discussed it with either one. I'm sorry. Would be unfair to speculate. All I know -- what I said before -- is that those deals are often tough when involving a pitcher, because of the risk involved.
Check please: I assume Bob post dated Skenes bonus check for "February 30, 3199"
Jason Mackey: Yeah. Dumb & Dumber style with a bunch of IOUs in a briefcase.
No, seriously. One, you got a Cy Young winner for peanuts. Nothing to complain about there. Also not entirely sure who pays that money, whether it's Nutting or MLB. Would have to double-check.
Jeff: Suwinski last stand. Any hope he can do it Jason?
Jason Mackey: Not a ton, Jeff. I think he needed a change of scenery, a new hitting coach and more available playing time. They're gonna add to the OF. I don't see how he gets enough playing time to do any damage or find a rhythm. I'm surprised they didn't non-tender him.
Dinner: What's your favorite Thanksgiving dish ? White or dark meat ? Gravy ? Apple or Pumpkin pie ?
Jason Mackey: I actually like a little of both ... but I'd go dark if I had to pick. Gotta have gravy. I'm very traditional. Stuffing. Some veggie. Mashed potatoes. Not super adventurous with Thanksgiving. Slice of each, please. Always double pie. Hence why I'll go for a long run tomorrow morning. Ha.
Jason Mackey: OK, folks. That does it. Thanks so much for adjusting. We should be back to normal next week. I'll actually be doing this post morning skate in Tampa, so may be an hour or so later. Hope you all have a Happy Thanksgiving!




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.