From the outside, it looked as if the timing was perfect for Brian Boucher in 2000.

You probably remember that incredible run. At 23, the former Flyers first-round pick took over Philly’s net down the stretch that year and was the talk of the NHL as he helped the Flyers reach Game 7 of the Eastern Conference Finals.

His efforts earned him Calder Trophy votes and the No. 1 gig the following season.

Looking back on it now, Boucher believes his breakthrough moment was maybe the worst thing that could have happened to him at that stage in his young pro career.

Advertise with us

“I should have spent another year or two in the minors, truthfully,” he lamented.

Boucher went on to have a solid NHL career and is now a top analyst for TNT, but he sees his story as a cautionary tale about giving a goalie too much too soon.

“To me, that’s why I feel like there are very few who can skip steps — necessary steps — and be who they want to be in the end,” Boucher said. “Yeah, you might be able to get to the NHL and play some games. But can you be that guy? That is the thing.”

So far, the Penguins have resisted the urge to skip steps with goalie prospect Sergei Murashov, who was just named the American Hockey League’s Player of the Week.

The 21-year-old started this season 5-1-0 with a .935 save percentage, and dating back to 2024-25, the Russian has won 17 of his 22 starts for Wilkes-Barre/Scranton.

Advertise with us

The calls to promote Murashov to the NHL have quieted in Pittsburgh with Tristan Jarry and Arturs Silovs playing well amid the Penguins’ surprising 7-2-2 start. And that’s a relief to the front office, which has no plans to call up Murashov any time soon.

“You’re just trying to stress test him [in the minors], and making sure he gets good experience and making the most of his time,” assistant GM Jason Spezza recently told the Penguins Radio Network. “He’s a young goaltender. There’s going to be ups and downs. But we want to make sure we’re doing the best job developing him.”

Why do the Penguins and the hockey world at large believe goalies, with a few exceptions, require more patience than prospects who play other positions?

The Post-Gazette spoke with three former NHL goalies, one of whom is the director of goaltending for an NHL organization, about why teams generally are not in a rush to throw young goalies into the fire. They pointed to reasons why development can stagnate in the NHL and warned that lost confidence can be difficult to recapture.

“There’s always going to be the special ones,” said Bill Ranford, a two-time Stanley Cup champion. “But if you look at the history of the position, it will take some time.”

Advertise with us

A tale of two goaltenders

The Penguins have two prospects who project as future NHL goalies. Joel Blomqvist has been beset by injuries this year, but the 23-year-old Finn holds promise, too.

Ranford and the Los Angeles Kings had to navigate a similar situation two decades ago after they picked Jonathan Quick and Jonathan Bernier in back-to-back drafts.

Quick, a 2005 third-round pick, was already in the organization when Dean Lombardi took over as GM in 2006 then hired Ranford just before that year’s draft. After he offered Ranford the job, Lombardi asked him to name the best goalie in the class.

“I said Bernier. So that was the first time I met Dean. The second time was after we drafted Bernier. He phoned me at home and basically said, ‘We just took your guy. Don’t screw it up,’ ” Ranford chuckled. “So that was my welcome to the L.A. Kings.”

Under Ranford, the Kings groomed a future Conn Smythe winner. It wasn’t Bernier.

Advertise with us

Like Marc-Andre Fleury here in Pittsburgh, Bernier was a teenager when he got his first taste of the NHL but was sent back to junior because the club was in a rebuild. By the time Bernier turned pro, he was in a position where he had to chase Quick.

Quick first cut his teeth at the ECHL level, something the Penguins asked Murashov to do last season. Quick then put up strong numbers in the AHL, as well. And when he got an opportunity at the NHL level in 2008, he seized it and never looked back.

Ranford gave all the credit to the athletic and competitive Quick, saying all he had to do as the NHL goalie coach was introduce a little more structure to his game. He is also a big believer that goalie prospects need to play often to develop properly.

“That’s the only way you’re going to get better and learn,” Ranford said. “Guys are going to develop at different speeds, and you have to utilize [the ECHL and AHL].”

Ranford said he and Lombardi agreed a goalie had to begin in the minors “and work your way to the top.” In their second year, they would hopefully earn the No. 1 gig in the AHL. Then the Kings wanted to see another year or two of dominance there.

Advertise with us

Bernier dutifully followed that path and eventually became Quick’s backup, then a starter elsewhere. He played more than 400 games before retiring two years ago.

“You don’t want to get in that situation where they are up, down, up, down. Dean wanted them to come up and be ready to play,” said Ranford, who moved into his current role in 2023. “That was the tough part for me. You don’t know until you know.”

Ready or not, here I come

Former NHL All-Star and Masterton Trophy winner Devan Dubnyk would agree with Ranford’s sentiment based on his own experience as an impatient goalie prospect.

Dubnyk was picked 14th overall by the Edmonton Oilers in 2004, spent two more seasons in junior then started his pro career in the ECHL. He expected nothing less.

“I had a great training camp and preseason when I was 20 years old. I was probably the best goalie there,” Dubnyk said. “But there was never any expectation. I never thought for a second that I was making the NHL team. I knew what the plan was.”

Advertise with us

But when he was still in the minors in his fourth year as a pro, Dubnyk began to get frustrated and started to wonder if there was still a path to the NHL through Edmonton. Then — boom — Oilers starter Nikolai Khabibulin went down with a season-ending injury, and there he was. Dubynk soon found out he wasn’t as ready as he thought.

Thankfully for Dubnyk, those Oilers were the rare NHL team that was willing to see if its young goalies would sink or swim. They were well out of the playoff race, so they told Dubnyk and Jeff Deslauriers the two would rotate starts the rest of the way.

“I feel very lucky that I was able to develop and go through growing pains at the NHL level,” said Dubnyk, who lost his first 10 starts but finished that season 4-2-0.

The NHL Network analyst noted “it is a completely different game than the AHL.”

Yeah, sure, the net is still 6 feet by 4 feet down there and the puck is the same size, too. But Dubynk said the AHL style of play is “significantly more chaotic,” with poor puck management and other mistakes leading to a lot of the AHL’s scoring chances.

Advertise with us

Dubynk said offense in the NHL is more structured and the scoring chances are often the result of good execution. So, in a way, the action can be more predictable. However, the skill is off the charts and NHL shooters make goalies pay for mistakes.

“It’s a big step up,” said Dubnyk, who had a brief stint in the AHL late in his career.

He shared the net with Khabibulin from 2010-12 then took over as Edmonton’s starter. In his late 20s, Dubnyk became an All-Star and a workhorse for Minnesota.

In hindsight, Dubnyk recognizes his time in the minors set him up for success.

“In the NHL, the coach’s job is to win, so unless management requires them to play a kid, they will try to win games,” he said. “Goalies have to play games to develop, and teams [do not have the luxury] to let a young goalie play through his struggles.”

Advertise with us

That is also a point Ranford made from the perspective of NHL team management.

Why development matters

Doubt. That is what Boucher felt as he headed into the 2000-01 season, his first as the clear-cut No. 1 in Philadelphia. Not excitement nor anxiety. He doubted himself.

He had played a total of only 70 AHL games in his first two pro seasons, in part due to injury. He was called up to the NHL in 1999, then went on that wild playoff run.

“I made All-Rookie team. I played every game in the playoffs. We went to Game 7 in the conference final, one win away from the Cup Finals. Everything looks great, right?” he recalled. “Next year, there was all this pressure to be the No. 1 guy after a rookie season that was phenomenal. And I wasn’t prepared. I was not prepared.”

Boucher wasn’t sure if he could handle 55 or 60 games. After all, he hadn’t done it at the AHL level. As a result of that, he feels he missed invaluable development time.

Advertise with us

“There were different circumstances why my career went sideways — the lockout [in 2004-05], injuries. But at the end of the day, I didn’t develop enough early on in my career and I was chasing my tail,” Boucher said. “I could be a solid No. 2. But I could never be that guy who [handled a large workload] because I just didn’t develop.”

Boucher believes NHL teams are right to try to have their young goalies “overripen” in the minors. It is not just the games, he said. All that practice time is invaluable.

“The NHL schedule comes fast and furious. And once you get past Thanksgiving, a lot of practices get canceled,” he explained. “You get extra practice time in the AHL during the week because the games are primarily on the weekends. You can really have some quality goalie practices and work on your fundamentals and technique.”

He added it is “difficult” for NHL goalies to fix issues in their game on the fly.

“Patience is critical. It really is,” he said. “If you rush them too quick and it goes bad, the confidence loss is so hard to get back. You’re not going to put them back in the fire because it’s not a development league. It’s about wins and losses. And if you can’t win games, you don’t play. And if you don’t play, you’re not going to develop.”

Advertise with us

So, based on his experiences as an NHL goalie — specifically that start — Boucher would advise the Penguins to continue preaching patience with their young goalies, especially if Pittsburgh’s hot start fizzles out and it becomes a losing environment.

“If there are injuries and whatnot, in that case, I think coming up for a cup of coffee and playing a game here and there, that is totally good. You want to reward these kids. You want to dangle the carrot, no question,” Boucher said. “But bringing them up full time, to me, that’s a dicey proposition. It can go bad on a guy pretty quick.”