In the fourth rendition of this five-part potential picks series, we took our first dive into the well of forwards that could be available for general manager Kyle Dubas and the Penguins at picks 11 and 12. And in this piece, we’re going to stay put, focusing on a forward who could be an offensive machine at the NHL level.
Justin Carbonneau, the 6-foot-1, 192-pound right winger for the Blainville-Boisbriand Armada in the Quebec Major Junior Hockey League (QMJHL) hails from Levis, Quebec, Canada. Unlike the last couple of prospects we’ve looked at, Carbonneau’s rankings among public scouts are relatively consistent. There is only one group that places him in the top 10 and two that place him outside the top 20, while the rest have him somewhere in the middle, with an average ranking between 15 and 16.
But while the 15-16 mark might be a little lower than some folks want to see, there are still plenty of reasons to be excited about Carbonneau’s game if the Penguins decide to select him with one of their two picks in the first round. He fits a player mold any fan could fall in love with if he ends up within their organization.
By the numbers
As mentioned, Carbonneau plays for the Blainville-Boisbriand Armada in the QMJHL and has since the 2022-23 season. The team finished eighth in the standings, putting them in the playoffs but around the middle of the pack. Their 34-21-7-2 record was primarily due to the contributions from Carbonneau.
Many knew Carbonneau would become a top prospect after his impressive season in 2023-24, when he put up almost a point per game (59 points in 68 games, including 31 goals) and six points in seven playoff games, and he proved everyone right.
In 62 games played this season, Carbonneau finished with 46 goals and 43 assists for 89 points, a regular season total that placed him first on the team in scoring. He was eight points ahead of the next player on the leaderboard with two fewer games played and, more impressively, he was 22 points ahead of the third-highest scorer on the team in five more games played. He also scored three goals in five playoff games last season.
Read More
Relative to his peers in the QMJHL, Carbonneau ended second in league scoring, only behind 21-year-old Jonathan Fauchon, who will be attending Providence College next season, which speaks all the more to Carbonneau’s game. He also finished tied for second in the league in goals, four behind the leader.
Game blend
Carbonneau is one of the most fascinating forwards in this draft for a lot of reasons but mainly because he brings a unique skill set to the table along with his frame.
The first piece of his game that stands out is his stick-handling ability. To say Carbonneau is the best stick handler in this draft class wouldn’t be an overstatement. The kid can flat out play with the puck in his possession. He generates tons of offense through his ability to weave in and out of opponents, manipulating the puck almost as if it’s on an invisible string. He uses his frame well to shield the puck in the offensive and neutral zones and when he’s able to find open ice, he has the room to make defenders look foolish.
There were plenty of times across this season when Carbonneau used that stick-handling ability to set himself up for a clutch goal or set his teammate up for a tally. He’s able to create plenty of lanes around the ice with a simple toe drag or push of the puck to space, drawing a defender with him. He’s a creative player who uses this ability to the fullest advantage.
But even with the excellent stick handling, it doesn’t take away from the other facets of Carbonneau’s game that make him a lethal scorer. His skating and ability to score from everywhere and every which way on the ice — around the net, mid-range, long range, off the rush, during offensive-zone possession — makes him an exceptionally lethal player. Carbonneau hardly ever stops moving his feet and plays with above-average pace, giving him time and space to create for himself and his teammates. His multifaceted approach to offense makes him one of the most dynamic players at the top end of this draft.
There are, of course, going to be some negatives, as there are with any prospect. Carbonneau can sometimes find himself stick handling into trouble or instead making the decision to stick handle in traffic and eventually turning the puck over as a result. However, there are also times when Carbonneau is able to make a play out of nowhere, stick handling through multiple defenders and finding a teammate with a beautiful pass or tickling the twine. There are more times when his best ability can be a catalyst for offense than not, but the NHL is a different league and very few opportunities to stick handle through a crowd present themselves like they do in the QMJHL.
EliteProspects’ evaluation
“Although he’s not a power forward in the purest sense, he can hit, retrieve pucks, protect them, and drive them right to the cage. Operating away from the puck, Carbonneau displays a honed ability to create space for himself and receive pucks. Adapting his speed to stay in passing lanes, circling behind defenders, and popping in pockets at just the right time, he catches and rifles pucks easily past the goalie, his deep skating posture and puck control adding power and precision to his shot.”
Final thoughts
Although the Penguins likely aren’t looking at the wing as a “position of need” for the draft (at least at this moment), Carbonneau is a player who could certainly be worth taking, especially now that the No. 12 pick is in the picture. His ability to create offense is among the best in this draft, and he’s one of the most exciting and dynamic players to watch who is in the range of possibilities for Pittsburgh.
Carbonneau doesn’t come without his flaws, but scoring 46 goals as an 18-year-old in the QMJHL primarily due to your ability to generate on your own (the key here), it could mean excellent things for a future career in the NHL. He has the stick handling, the skating and the shot. Now it’s just about honing all of those skills and continuing to develop them to an NHL caliber.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.