To count down the days until the start of Penguins training camp on Sept. 18, beat reporter Matt Vensel and other Post-Gazette staffers will look at a different aspect of the team each weekday. Today, we will look at the defensemen on the roster.

Coming into last season, a new core of defensemen brought excitement and renewed vigor to the Penguins’ hopes of returning to the postseason.

Now, those same players enter 2024-25 with a chip on their shoulder, looking to reach any semblance of the potential they carried into Pittsburgh.

On the first day of free agency in the 2023 offseason, Penguins president of hockey operations Kyle Dubas signed big-bodied defenseman Ryan Graves to a six-year deal with an average annual value of $4.5 million.

Advertise with us

A month later, Dubas somehow finagled a blockbuster trade to wrangle three-time Norris Trophy winner Erik Karlsson away from the Sharks — and while they were brought in to fulfill entirely different roles, each disappointed in their first season in the black and gold.

Karlsson, an offensive-minded maestro who in 2022-23 became only the sixth blueliner in NHL history and first in 31 years to record a 100-point season, didn’t reach nearly those heights in his first go ‘round with the Penguins. The 33-year-old Swede was still the highest-scoring Pittsburgh defenseman, tallying 11 goals and 45 assists for 56 points, five more than second-place Kris Letang.

Those 56 points, however, were Karlsson’s lowest total since 2017-18 and by far his worst points tally in a season in which he played all 82 games — and his debut season in the black and gold resulted in a rate of 1.7 points per 60 minutes of ice time, fourth worst in his career.

Karlsson has never been known as a stout, brick-wall defender, but in most seasons, his dazzling play in the offensive zone made up for those shortcomings. That wasn’t the case last season, as he still made some questionable, porous defensive decisions and often was frustratingly passive while quarterbacking the Penguins’ paltry power play.

Karlsson’s the headliner of this unit. As he goes, so, too, might the team’s dreams of returning to NHL prominence.

Advertise with us

While Karlsson seemingly made some strides as the season progressed, the same can’t really be said for Graves, who struggled mightily in his first Penguins campaign. Dubas admitted as much after the season.

“There’s no dancing around it,” Dubas said of Graves’ performance. “Did I expect it to go the full year? No. I think part of that is on us as an organization, and it’s as much on Ryan to push and find his way through the summer. It’s a massive summer for him. ... I fully expect him to come back in next year and have a great year.”

Graves was brought in to be a steadying force next to either Karlsson or Kris Letang on the first or second pairing to add a defensive counterweight to their more offensive sensibilities. Graves’ average time on ice declined gradually throughout the season, and there were even talks in early January of the Penguins making him a healthy scratch before injuries to other blueliners afforded him another chance.

But Graves didn’t improve, and now, he’s got a clear directive — perhaps even a callout — from his bosses. If Graves comes into training camp refreshed and can provide the level of play he was accustomed to before arriving here, it could buoy the Penguins blue line massively.

Letang’s still at it

Letang enters his 19th season in the NHL coming off of an interesting campaign.

Advertise with us

The two-time Stanley Cup winner played all 82 games for just the second time in his career but was slowed significantly by multiple injuries that nagged him throughout the year. He had surgery to repair a broken finger on his left hand on May 10. But after the season, coach Mike Sullivan called Letang a “warrior” and said that the 37-year-old had been “dealing with a myriad of injuries for a long time,” so it’s safe to assume the finger wasn’t the only thing bugging him.

With all those injuries in mind, though, Letang still played to a reasonably productive campaign last season, with 10 goals and 41 assists for 51 points and a plus-13 rating. More statistical output like that from Letang is reasonable to expect, but is that level of durability?

No one can question Letang’s toughness and resiliency after dealing with two strokes and Sullivan’s descriptive “myriad of injuries.” Whether the 2022-23 Masterton Trophy winner can still suit up for 82 games in a season is a question the Penguins brass will soon have to answer.

What to do with Pettersson?

Marcus Pettersson has quietly developed into maybe the Penguins’ best pure defender since being acquired from the Anaheim Ducks in 2018. But whether he’ll remain with the team beyond this season is still to be determined.

Pettersson, who turned just 28 years old on May 8, is in the final season of a five-year, $20,125,875 contract and can become an unrestricted free agent next offseason. Karlsson and Letang’s offensive exploits are valuable to a team, but only if they have an anchor next to them on the blue line to shoulder more of the defensive load. Pettersson is far from a flashy player, but he’s provided that value over the past couple of seasons, even logging a career-best 30 points last year.

Advertise with us

At his age, Pettersson stands to command a sizable payday next summer if his level of play stays high. So how will Dubas play it? An extension seems unlikely this far into the offseason but remains a possibility. Could Dubas dangle Pettersson to a defense-hungry contender for future assets to supplement the Penguins’ retooling? And if so, what would the Penguins, who allegedly still see themselves as playoff contenders, do in his stead? It’s a fascinating dilemma and one to watch as training camp and the season get underway.

Who replaces POJ?

The Penguins’ stated goal this offseason was to retool and get younger while still fielding a winning team in the present. This made it a little surprising that Dubas and the team let 25-year-old Pierre-Olivier Joseph walk over the offseason.

Joseph signed a one-year, $950,000 contract with St. Louis over the offseason for an opportunity to play with his brother, Mathieu, and now the Penguins will have to find someone to scoop up those minutes of ice time. Luckily, Dubas brought in a few choices.

Free-agent additions Sebastian Aho and Matt Grzelcyk would appear to have pole position. Aho, 28, and Grzelcyk, 30, come to the Penguins with multiple years of experience for playoff teams under their belts, the former with the Islanders and the latter with the Bruins. But each is coming off of his worst statistical season, so they aren’t sure bets to provide the value Dubas is looking for.

Beyond them, Jack St. Ivany is back after surprising some with a solid rookie cameo last year. Ryan Shea and John Ludvig are, too. There will be ample competition for that third pairing heading into training camp, and it will be interesting to see how Sullivan and staff divvy it up on opening night.