CALGARY, Alberta — Due to injury, poor performance or roster shuffling, Mike Sullivan from game to game has tweaked his forward lines 12 times in 2024.
Pittsburgh’s coach recently joked that Lars Eller “leads the league in linemates.”
Evgeni Malkin has already had seven of them during this calendar year alone.
Sidney Crosby is currently playing without his two wingers, putting the Penguins one more injury away from the Mark Donk and Buzz Flibbet meme resurfacing.
But despite all that turnover within his forward group, Sullivan has largely kept intact the fourth-line trio of Jansen Harkins, Noel Acciari and Jeff Carter.
Why?
Read More
“We really like the identity of that particular line and the three of them together. And when we utilize them in [defensive] situations, they’ve done a great job for us,” Sullivan said. “They’ve really established a unique identity within the group that we think is really important to helping us play the game we want to play.”
Only three duos of Penguins forwards have played more minutes together than Acciari and Carter. Harkins joined their line after Matt Nieto was lost to injury.
Acciari and Carter have shared the ice at 5-on-5 for about 278 minutes. And in that significant sample, Acciari and Carter were on for just five goals against.
That statistic is even more impressive when considering the caliber of forwards they often face and the frequency with which their shifts start inside the defensive zone. Of the duo’s 297 faceoffs together, 59.9% occurred in Penguins territory.
That partially explains why the Penguins have received so few goals from their fourth line and also why some advanced stats paint the pair quite unfavorably.
“With the analytics and expected stuff like that, it doesn’t [capture their value],” Marcus Pettersson said. “[Stats] are good for some things. But sometimes you can’t compare players who are in different roles. If you just look at the numbers, you don’t see the role that they have and what they bring to the table for us.”
The primary objective for that trio is to win the draw and defend hard when they don’t. They usually do. Carter ranks sixth in the league in success rate on draws in their defensive zone. Acciari is up there, too. He also wins more than 55%.
Once they get the Penguins out of their zone, any offense they get is a bonus.
Think about it this way: That line’s average shift is 40 seconds long. By the time they win the faceoff, clear their zone and lob the puck into the offensive zone to try to get the forecheck going, they have already burned about a third of that.
But, yeah, it would be nice if they did put it in the net occasionally. Acciari and Carter have three even-strength goals apiece. Harkins has zero in 40 games. He came excruciatingly close to ending his drought in Thursday’s 2-0 loss in Seattle.
“Not everybody can score every game. Obviously, we’d like to chip in,” Harkins said. “You go out every game and every shift, and you want to be able to produce for the team. But we take pride in playing in the D zone and being hard to play against and wearing them down. I think it goes a long way with team success.”
Harkins considers it a win if his shift ends with a faceoff inside enemy territory.
“It’s about being responsible and just getting momentum for our team,” he said. “Our top guys are having great years. It’s our job to have shifts that put them in position to wear the other team down or get O-zone draws and stuff like that.”
Their appreciative teammates say it takes a certain level of self-awareness and sacrifice to embrace that kind of role. Eller said those three “have their heart in it every game.” Pettersson added that players “know that they will do everything for the team’s best [interest] in every second of their existence on this team.”
There are few players more respected in their dressing room than Carter, who played his 1,300th career game Thursday in Seattle. He has eight seasons with 25-plus goals, is a two-time All-Star and played a prominent offensive role on a couple Stanley Cup teams. Now he’s bought into playing low-event hockey.
“It’s not an easy thing to do,” Eller said. “I’m guessing that when you’re used to being a top guy and a goalscorer and playing a lot of minutes and being a star, switching into that role ... you still have pride, but you have to let go of your ego. And not everybody can do that. So the way that he’s embraced that is key.”
Eller added: “A lot of guys can learn from that and take something from that.”
Quietly, Carter has been OK this season after a move from center to the wing. It certainly helps that he shares the ice with Acciari, who is a quality defender and is often also deployed alongside a stingy defenseman such as Pettersson.
Sure, it would be swell if Pittsburgh got more scoring and other obvious sparks from the fourth line. Many of the NHL’s top teams do so with some regularity. But Sullivan seems quite content with how that trio is performing in its specific role.
“How we deploy them and utilize them, they’ve done a really good job in that aspect of the game,” Sullivan said in Seattle. “They get a lot of defensive zone starts against other teams’ top players. They win a lot of faceoffs. They drive the puck down the ice for us. They establish offensive zone play a lot of times.”
And so he keeps them together, while the rest of his lineup continues to churn.
Matt Vensel: mvensel@post-gazette.com and @mattvensel on X






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.