They weren’t stars. But for a few moments once upon a time, they were bright enough to write themselves into Western Pennsylvania sports lore — cult heroes — only to as quickly fade into the mists of history. About and of them we will ask in this Sunday series: Where Yinz Now?

Patrick Lalime was back in town for a work trip late last month, and it didn’t take long for memories from his brief but remarkable stay to come rushing back.

Of course, he had dinner at Monterey Bay Fish Grotto on Mt. Washington, one of his favorite spots in one of his favorite cities. While there, he took a moment to look out over the Pittsburgh skyline, wondering where the time had gone.

It felt like yesterday — not nearly three decades ago — that he stood there and posed for a Sports Illustrated photographer. The once-proud magazine profiled the goalie for the Jan. 20, 1997, issue. Its bold headline read: “Patrick Who?”

Advertise with us

Lalime, who will turn 50 this summer, came out of nowhere in 1996-97 to give the Penguins maybe the best — and definitely the most improbable — stretch of puck stopping the team has ever witnessed. Today, Lalime remains one of the most fascinating what-might-have-been stories in Pittsburgh sports history.

Less than a year after Lalime set the NHL record for the longest unbeaten streak to begin a goalie’s career, a 14-0-2 rookie run that captivated the city and later the hockey world at large, the Penguins unceremoniously traded him away.

Lalime would bounce back and enjoy a long, successful pro career. But he still ponders a question that many fans have kicked around on area barstools.

“Who knows what would have happened had I signed back here?” he sighed.

In the latest installment of our “Where Yinz Now?” series, we met up with Lalime on Jan. 26 at PPG Paints Arena. Lalime, who is now a TV analyst, opened up about his road to Pittsburgh, that unforgettable streak, what he is up to now and whether he has any regrets about the abrupt end of his Penguins tenure.

Advertise with us

“Everyone [with the team] was awesome. It was just a fun environment to be around,” Lalime said. “If there’s one thing when I look back at my whole career, not signing back here is the one where I still have a little bit of a sour taste.”

Coming out of nowhere

Before he streaked into the record book and provided a glimmer of hope for the Penguins, Lalime had to overcome long odds to just make it to Pittsburgh.

He was only NHLer from Saint-Bonaventure, a Quebec village with a population of about 1,000. He played his minor hockey down the road in Drummondville, first strapping on the pads because every kid had to take a turn. Lalime loved it and said yes when the coach asked him to play goal in their playoff game.

“We lost 9-0,” he said. “But afterward, I said I wanted to play goalie forever.”

Advertise with us

Lalime said he was cut on a few occasions during his climb to the Quebec Major Junior Hockey League. But the budding butterfly goalie got on the NHL radar.

The 1993 draft was held in Quebec City, and his family was in the crowd. In the sixth round, his brother somehow got behind the table for NHL’s central registry. He was peeking at the draft list when Patrick’s name suddenly popped up.

“He turned around and started yelling, ‘It’s Pat! It’s Pat!’ ” he happily recalled.

The Penguins had picked Lalime, much to the chagrin of one Montreal scout.

One year later, Lalime went pro. He felt he had a strong NHL training camp. But Pittsburgh had two established veterans, Tom Barrasso and Ken Wregget.

Advertise with us

He reported to Cleveland of the International Hockey League and was trying to establish himself there when his agent called to tell him, “Pack your gear.”

This was his first — but not his last — contract squabble with the Penguins, who had yet to sign Lalime to a NHL deal. The agent, looking to keep Lalime busy, eventually got him a deal with the Hampton Roads Admirals of the ECHL.

Soon, Barrasso would get hurt, forcing the Penguins to get a deal done. Lalime didn’t see NHL action then. But two seasons later, his moment would arrive.

Just a few weeks into the 1996-97 season, Barrasso was lost for the season to a shoulder injury. Pittsburgh recalled Lalime to back up Wregget and wanted to see how things played out. It was probably telling that Lalime, then 22, was with the team for a few weeks before he was trusted to make his first NHL start.

He actually made his NHL debut in relief in an 8-3 loss to the New York Rangers on Nov. 16, 1996. Wregget, who was pulled after giving up five goals, was the goalie of record for that one. The first shooter Lalime faced? Some Gretzky guy. Lalime stopped that, but Mark Messier pumped the next shot behind him.

Advertise with us

Next period, he thought was ready for Messier when he skated down the wing.

“He went top corner,” he said. “And I’m thinking, ‘OK, welcome to the league.’ ”

The record run begins

The streak started Dec. 6 in Washington, D.C. Again, Lalime replaced Wregget, who was not feeling well. The Penguins were down 2-0 when he came in but rallied to win 5-3. Lalime stopped 16 of 17 shots in his first career victory.

Lalime made his first start the next night, a matchup against the Mighty Ducks of Anaheim at the old Civic Arena. Looking back, he still has a fondness for the Igloo, calling it a “sacred land.” He stopped 30 shots in another 5-3 win.

Advertise with us

“It was a quick turnaround. I wasn’t trying to think. I just wanted to go play,” he said. “I was a little nervous obviously. But the guys played so well in front of me. They scored a few goals and took the pressure off me. It was awesome.”

He beat the Ducks on their home ice four days later. Then the Penguins headed to San Jose, where he got the first of his three shutouts during the streak.

“I wasn’t supposed to play,” he said. “We came down the elevators and Kenny said, ‘Be ready. I lost my contact lenses and we don’t have backups.’ So I went in and played that game. I wasn’t too busy that one. But I got the shutout.”

As the Penguins celebrated his latest win, he watched Darius Kasparitis skate over to the game puck, thinking the defenseman was retrieving a keepsake.

“All of the sudden, he just flips it right up into the stands!” he exclaimed. “I was like, ‘Kasper, what are you doing?!?’ He had to go and exchange the puck for a stick or something. I still have all those pucks from the streak at home.”

Advertise with us

Everything was going Lalime’s way, and that would continue for a long while.

Most Penguins fans who were around for the heydays of Mario Lemieux and Jaromir Jagr have fond recollections of the unbeaten streak and the buzz that took over the ‘Burgh. Ditto for Lalime’s memorable mask. It was painted to look like a baby penguin busting out of its eggshell — like Lalime, just starting out.

But given all the firepower the Penguins had in their lineup in those days, some fans might have forgotten just how dominant the rookie was during that run.

He posted a sparkling .947 save percentage over those two months and didn’t allow more than three goals in any game. He was peppered on a few occasions, facing 50-plus shots twice and 49 in another win. All three of those outings still rank in the top 30 in team history for saves made by a goalie in a game.

“It was a good mix where the guys would score and I was shutting the door,” he said. “I was receiving a lot of shots and I enjoyed it. When you come in [to the NHL], you don’t really know what to expect. You’re just trying to go through the motions. You don’t stop to think. You just keep going. I was in the zone.”

Advertise with us

All I do is win, win, win

Around town, Lalime quickly became a cult hero and started getting recognized wherever he went. He said they were “great fans” and treated him so well.

Back in Saint-Bonaventure, people erected a sign that kept track of the streak. Every time the Penguins won, they put a bigger number up on the board. When he was home for the All-Star break that winter, his phone rang off the hook.

In January, Sports Illustrated sent their NHL writer to Pittsburgh to profile him.

The attention was overwhelming at times for Lalime, not used to the limelight.

Advertise with us

As the wins piled up, some around the league expressed skepticism about his staying power. One was Ken Hitchcock, the head coach for the Dallas Stars.

“I remember that he said he [coached] against me in the minor leagues and I wasn’t that good,” Lalime said. “I ended up having a good game in that one.”

One night after holding Dallas to one goal, Lalime set the record at Hartford.

“I remember Mario in the room saying, ‘Let’s go get this for the kid,’ ” he said.

Lalime shut out the Whalers to move out of a tie with Montreal’s Bill Durnan and Boston’s Ross Brooks for the longest undefeated streak to begin a career.

Advertise with us

“I always say ‘we’ broke the record,” Lalime said. “I think it is such a good streak because it was a team thing, you know? If we win, I win. Everybody’s happy.”

Andrew Hammond had a great run a decade ago, but the record still stands.

Lalime made 49 saves against Calgary to extend his streak to 16. But it ended Jan. 23 with a loss to Colorado. He still contends that Valeri Kamensky had his skate in the crease — illegal then — when he scored the winner in overtime.

Two weeks later, “the bubble burst.” At one point, Lalime lost six in a row, giving up at least four goals in every game, and the Penguins fell out of first place.

“All of a sudden, you are doubting things,” he said. “Everything was going so well and you’re doing the same thing and it’s not working. I think that’s what this game does to you. It brings you back [to earth]. It’s a very humbling game.”

Advertise with us

Lalime lost 10 of his last 13 decisions that season and watched from the bench as Wregget and the Penguins lost 4-1 to the rival Philadelphia Flyers in the first round of the playoffs. After the season, Lemieux retired for the first time.

“It was special just playing with him,” he said. “To me, he’s still the best ever.”

Lalime had no idea his days with the Penguins had also come to an end.

Life after the streak

Lalime’s contract was up, and after the run he went on, he expected the Penguins to sign him to a one-way deal that would pay him the same amount in the NHL or the minors, relevant given the presence of Barrasso and Wregget. Lalime said he understood the situation and had no issue spending time in the minors.

Advertise with us

When the Penguins wouldn’t budge, his agent advised him to hold out again.

The 1997-98 season arrived, and Lalime was still not under contract. Eventually, he signed with Grand Rapids of the IHL, so he could keep his game sharp. Just before the NHL trade deadline, the phone in his hotel room started ringing. It was his wife. Her aunt heard on the radio that he was dealt to the Ducks.

Nearly 30 years later, Lalime still wonders how his career would have unfolded had he just called general manager Craig Patrick and found middle ground.

“Regret, it’s a big word,” he said. “I was 22, 23 at the time. And you’re following your agency. But in a perfect world, I would have loved to come back here.”

It took more than two years and another trade, this one to Ottawa, before Lalime resurfaced in the NHL. He won the starting gig in his second season there. He tallied 200 career wins split between five NHL teams, earned an All-Star invite in 2003 and took the Senators on a trip to the Eastern Conference finals.

Advertise with us

“Four years as a starter, made an All-Star Game. It was a lot of fun,” he said. “I was lucky to get another chance and tried to make the best of it, you know?”

He retired in 2011 after three years in Buffalo. He said the Sabres tried to hire him to be a goalie coach in the minors. But Lalime took a media job instead.

Since 2014, Lalime has been with TVA, a Canadian French-language network. He does color commentary on select Canadiens games, plus some studio work. It allows him to remain near wife Marie-Helene and their three daughters.

“I’m still in the game, still see my friends here and there,” he said. “It’s different. I miss being part of a team and winning together. You get that if you coach, but you invest a lot of time when you’re coaching. In my mind, I’ve got the best of both worlds right now. I’m doing hockey and go on the road with guys.”

When Lalime checked into his hotel here last month, the man behind the counter told him he didn’t need to see his ID. Lalime’s black hair is shorter now and he’s put on a few pounds since his playing days. But he still recognized Lalime.

Advertise with us

“He said to me, ‘I just want to thank you for everything you did for the city when you played.’ Oh wow, did that bring back good memories,” Lalime grinned.

Matt Vensel: mvensel@post-gazette.com and @mattvensel on the website X