Even in defeat, Erik Karlsson left a memorable first impression.

Karlsson’s Penguins debut in the team’s 4-2 loss to the Chicago Blackhawks Tuesday night was as mixed a bag as his reputation as a brilliant offensive-minded player who can at times leave something to be desired on the defensive end. Contrary to his polarizing performance, however, Karlsson assessed his play in the season opener alongside fellow defenseman Marcus Pettersson quite plainly as “OK.”

"I think we can feel that it was the first game,” Karlsson said. “You know, preseason is never the same. And overall, I think everybody felt pretty good body-wise. We [had] energy out there. Now, we just got to find a way to utilize that energy a little bit better at times and put together a more solid 60 minutes."

Karlsson was on the ice for nearly half of regulation, skating a team-high 26 minutes and change. He flashed on numerous occasions, like when leading a breakout early in the second period from the goal line extended before absorbing a huge check to set up a fruitless three-on-one for the Penguins.

Advertise with us

He made the PPG Paints Arena crowd let out a round of “oohs” in his first regular-season opportunity on the power play, dancing a defender before whipping a shot from the high slot that was gloved by Chicago netminder Petr Mrazek, who made 38 saves on 40 shots. Per Natural Stat Trick, Karlsson finished the night with a team-best 1.56 expected goals.

Simultaneously, Karlsson also finished the night with a minus-2 rating, on the ice for three of the Blackhawks’ four goals (with one being an empty-netter, of course) and a team-worst 2.18 expected goals against. His eagerness to join the rush on the offensive end was best exemplified in the opening period when Jake Guentzel covered for Karlsson as the reigning Norris Trophy winner was deep in the offensive zone on a three-on-two.

Prior to Tuesday’s game, coach Mike Sullivan discussed what plans were in place for when Karlsson inevitably gets caught on the offensive end of the ice as the opponent rushes the other way. Sullivan equated the team’s plan to what’s already in place with Kris Letang, that it’s essential for either right-shot defenseman to be partnered with a steady, defensive-minded player.

“That allows players like Erik and Tanger to do what they do. I think we would be foolish as a coaching staff to get in the way of that,” Sullivan said pregame. “We're going to try and wrap some parameters around it so that we're somewhat predictable for one another.

“But certainly, we don't want to get in the way of that because we think that's something that's going to give us a competitive edge.”

Advertise with us

In the small sample size of the season opener, though, that advantage went to the Blackhawks. Of course, it didn’t help that the offensive opportunities Karlsson set up proved to be all for naught.

With the game tied up 2-2 late in the third, Karlsson glided into the heart of Chicago’s defense before dumping off to Guentzel for a perfect one-timer from the near faceoff circle. Making perhaps his best save of the night, Mrazek stole a goal from Guentzel, who dropped his head in disbelief at the netminder’s effort.

Quite often, Karlsson occupied the ice simultaneously with Guentzel, Sidney Crosby and Bryan Rust. Letang, meanwhile, more often roamed the ice with Evgeni Malkin’s line.

It’d make logical sense that Karlsson, a riskier and more offensively-driven player than Letang by comparison, spent more time on the ice with Crosby, a more conscientious defender than Malkin. Sullivan downplayed the significance of this early development, saying that the reality is they’ll each play significant minutes.

To Sullivan’s point, Letang was no slouch, logging over 24 minutes, which was second only to Karlsson.

Advertise with us

"They're going to be behind multiple lines because of that, so they're going to get some time behind both Sid and Geno,” Sullivan said. “We think that over the course of time, they'll develop some chemistry.”

With due time, the Penguins will adjust more to Karlsson’s game, especially with training camp now in the rearview mirror. Guentzel had a clear understanding, and he didn’t skate a single shift in the preseason.

But for one night, albeit a disappointing one, Karlsson generated both groans and cheers. For the Penguins’ sake, they’ll hope the latter becomes much more commonplace.

Andrew Destin: adestin@post-gazette.com and Twitter @AndrewDestin1