The Penguins’ search for new hockey operations leaders is starting to pick up.
One month after Fenway Sports Group fired the front office duo of Ron Hextall and Brian Burke, the search for their replacements will soon be narrowed.
Initially, FSG cast a wide net when doing their due diligence on candidates for what is expected to be a multi-layered hockey operations structure. It is believed that FSG will soon begin the second round of interviews, if they have not already. FSG has managed to keep the list of interviewees private thus far.
The search should reach its conclusion before the end of the month. And that will be a good thing because the Penguins, who could opt to again hire a president of hockey operations over top of a new GM, have lots of work to do.
The Penguins in 2023-23 got 93 points from Sidney Crosby and 82 games from Evgeni Malkin, and yet they still missed the playoffs for the first time in 17 seasons. Stanley Cup contention will be even more difficult moving forward.
They have 11 players under contract 30 or older. Eight Penguins have some level of no-trade protection. They have seven unrestricted free agents. And given that they have a few holes on the NHL roster, the $20.2 million in salary cap space that Capfriendly projects them to have is not as much as it seems.
Read More
The new hockey operations leaders will be stepping into an incredibly challenging situation. But as a starting point, they will at least have Crosby, Cup-winning coach Mike Sullivan and the 14th overall pick in next month’s NHL draft.
Plus, there are other pieces, some more movable than others, that can be shuffled around to try to send Crosby and Co. on another deep postseason run.
Let’s go through the Penguins’ roster, putting players in specific buckets, to get a sense of who will be here in 2023-24 and who could be on the move.
THE BIG THREE
Last summer, Fenway Sports Group committed to moving forward with the core trio of Crosby, Malkin and Kris Letang. Crosby and Malkin are under contract for three more seasons. Letang is signed through 2028. All three have full no-movement clauses and can veto any trade. They’re not going anywhere now.
The new general manager will be tasked with building around those three longtime Penguins, at least in the short term. Maybe that changes down the road if the team continues to inch away from contention and the team and the players agree that it is time for a change. But right now, it remains Cup or bust.
BRYAN RUST
Rust is in his own bucket as a valuable-but-aging player with a restrictive contract. The 31-year-old winger received a full no-movement clause through 2024-25 for accepting a team-friendly salary last offseason. So Rust can’t be traded anywhere unless he wants it. And all indications are he still loves it here.
So while he would be a logical candidate to be moved in a hockey trade to try to change the supporting cast, Rust is expected to be back next season.
HOCKEY TRADES
Jake Guentzel, Rickard Rakell, Jeff Petry and Marcus Pettersson are good players who would entice other teams. They are also key lineup pieces here.
If the new front office wishes to make a significant player-for-player trade, those four would garner interest. Guentzel and Rakell are top-six forwards who appear to still be in their primes. Petry underwhelmed a bit in 2022-23 but remains a top-four right-shot defender. Pettersson is coming off a career year.
Guentzel, Rakell and Petry all have partial no-trade protection. That gives them a little leverage but would not prohibit the Penguins from moving them.
In particular, Guentzel is an intriguing case. He has 159 goals in his last 331 games and Crosby loves playing with him. But he also has one year left on his contract. So if the Penguins can’t extend him this summer, they could shop him. He would be a premium trade chip even with his pending free agent status.
PROBLEM CONTRACTS
Jeff Carter has full no-movement protection. He told the Post-Gazette last month that he wants to play next season and is happy in Pittsburgh. Because Carter was over 35 when Hextall signed him, there is no cap benefit to buying him out. So he might be back for the final year of his deal, making $3.1 million.
Mikael Granlund has two years left on a contract that pays him $5 million annually. The good news is he does not have a no-trade clause. The bad news is that no other team will likely want him, unless the Penguins throw in something nice to sweeten the deal. Granlund is Pittsburgh’s only viable buyout candidate.
Jan Rutta’s $2,750,000 salary is hardly crippling, especially if he stays healthy next season. But that’s too much money for a limited third-pair defenseman.
LET THEM WALK
The Penguins have a slew of free agents, one of them being Brian Dumoulin.
Dumoulin was a big part of the back-to-back Cup teams and is a popular player within the team. But his mobility and defensive prowess further deteriorated last season. The Penguins must put sentimentality aside and move on.
There is no reason to retain 30-something trade deadline pickups Nick Bonino and Dmitry Kulikov. Or Danton Heinen, who is a replacement-level player.
Josh Archibald and Drake Caggiula are decent depth players in a vacuum. But the Penguins need size and snarl in their bottom six, not more little guys.
GO AHEAD AND TALK
The new front office should have discussions with the agents for Tristan Jarry and Jason Zucker about possibly re-signing them, only if the price is right.
You can make the case for letting Jarry walk. He has been ineffective or injured at the end of the last three seasons. But he is a two-time All-Star and the alternatives in free agency are uninspiring. Maybe there is a short-term prove-it deal that works for both parties. Otherwise, the Penguins should say goodbye.
Unless Pittsburgh creates more cap space, Zucker will likely sign a multi-year deal elsewhere. That might be for the best. His passion and energy level were second to none last season. But his injury history should give them pause.
Their decisions with Drew O’Connor, Ryan Poehling and Dustin Tokarski require considerably less thought. O’Connor and Poehling are young contributors worth retaining as restricted free agents. Tokarski is a solid third goalie.
FRINGES OF THE ROSTER
The following depth players, neither irreplaceable nor insignificant, remain under contract for 2023-24: Forward Alex Nylander; defensemen Chad Ruhwedel, Mark Friedman and Taylor Fedun; and backup goalie Casey DeSmith.
PROSPECTS TO WATCH
Ty Smith, the offensive-minded defenseman acquired in the John Marino trade, is expected to be back in the mix for an NHL roster spot after spending most of last season in the American Hockey League. Moving on from Dumoulin would open up a lineup spot, but the Penguins would likely add a veteran lefty.
Up front, Sam Poulin, Jonathan Gruden and Valtteri Puustinen are still looking to become NHL regulars. No one else has been knocking on the door.
Top goalie prospect Joel Blomqvist could make the jump to North America next season. But he must earn his stripes with Wilkes-Barre/Scranton first.
Matt Vensel: mvensel@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mattvensel.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.