It was all there on Teddy Blueger’s blade, a golden opportunity to bury his first goal in 23 games and help the Penguins avoid a brutal loss.

The Penguins and San Jose Sharks were tied late in regulation Saturday. Brock McGinn, one of his regular wingers on the third line, drew a defender then dropped a perfect pass to Blueger, streaking in all alone down the middle.

Blueger received it in a shooting position, froze Kaapo Kahkonen with a quick deke then pulled the puck onto the backhand. He was staring at about two feet of empty net but he couldn’t tuck it between Kahkonen’s left toe and the post.

After the goalie pounced on the loose puck and got a whistle, Blueger lifted both of his arms over his head in disbelief then tomahawked the end boards.

Advertise with us

That was the latest public display of frustration for Blueger, who recently attempted to snap a stick over his knee and at a morning skate a week ago got into a heated exchange with Casey DeSmith, one of his best buddies on the team.

Still steaming back on the bench, Blueger watched Sharks center Logan Couture score the winner 50 seconds later, sending the Penguins to another loss.

The Penguins, who sputtered into the All-Star break with just five wins in 16 games since Christmas, have bigger problems than the 28-year-old Blueger. But heading into the season with so much uncertainty in their bottom six, Blueger was supposed to be the one sure thing — a frisky, tone-setting fourth-line center.

Instead, he has only one goal in 34 games and has slipped a bit defensively.

Before the break, he said he was trying his best to maintain a positive mindset.

Advertise with us

“It’s harder to not press when you’re not scoring or the team is losing,” he said.

Blueger remains as valuable as ever on the penalty kill, which transformed from one of the NHL’s worst to one of its better units once he returned from injury. And he has won 51.6% of his draws for Pittsburgh, a top-10 faceoff team.

But his surprising struggles at 5-on-5 have contributed to the destabilization of the bottom six — an area that must improve, coach Mike Sullivan recently said.

After Blueger made his season debut in early November, he found quick chemistry with Ryan Poehling and Josh Archibald. But both of them got injured — Archibald is still out — and Blueger has had difficulty gaining traction with others.

It’s been most glaring in the offensive end. Four defensemen have more goals.

Advertise with us

Despite averaging more shots per 60 minutes at 5-on-5 compared to the past two seasons and seeing a significant uptick in shots from the inner slot, Blueger has not scored at 5-on-5. His lone goal came at 4-on-4, when the Penguins caught the Columbus Blue Jackets trying to pull their goalie back on Dec. 6.

Recently, the trio of Blueger, McGinn and Jeff Carter at least earned chances.

“The offense has been missing,” Blueger said. “The last few games, we had some offensive zone time. We’ve had some chances. We can execute better, but we’re also not getting the bounces. It’s just one of those stretches right now.”

Blueger is not on the team to score goals. He has yet to net 10 in a season. But he did average 0.46 points per game over the previous two seasons while teaming up with various wingers to keep opponents occupied in their own end.

This season, Blueger and his linemates have had 20% less offensive zone puck possession, per Sportlogiq, averaging about half as many scoring chances off the cycle game. He has not generated a single chance from the forecheck.

Advertise with us

He said that if he is not scoring goals he must find ways to help in other areas.

“You just try to build confidence through making some good plays,” he said. “If you make a wall play or win a big faceoff, use that as positive reinforcement.”

But Blueger has been less impactful on the defensive side of the puck, as well.

In the past, Blueger displayed a knack for putting himself in passing lanes. But this season, he has been less disruptive in all three zones. Per Sportlogiq’s tracking, he is not blocking as many passes, he has pounced on fewer loose pucks and has won just 1.9 puck battles per 20 minutes, compared to 3.9 last season.

And at a team level, the Penguins are giving up more high-danger scoring chances this season with Blueger on at 5-on-5, per Natural Stat Trick. And while his rate of 2.48 expected goals against per 60 minutes is one of Pittsburgh’s best marks, he landed between 1.9 and 2.1 in each of the previous three seasons.

Advertise with us

Add it all up, and Blueger’s lines have been outscored 14-6 at 5-on-5 so far.

He has just not looked like the same player since a high, hard hit from Winnipeg Jets defenseman Brenden Dillon shattered his jaw. The scary play, which occurred last January, left blood pouring out of Blueger’s mouth for a few minutes. He also missed the first 11 games of this season with an upper-body injury.

Since then, the tenacity that was such a hallmark of his game has only shown up in spurts. But he insists injuries have not had a lingering effect on his play.

“That was a frustrating stretch [in the fall], but I feel good now,” Blueger said.

On a personal level, the worst season of his NHL career arrived at a bad time. He will be an unrestricted free agent this summer. The trade deadline also looms.

Advertise with us

Asked about that, Blueger said he believes he has done a good job of blocking out thoughts about his uncertain future. He says he is more concerned with elevating his play and helping the Penguins get their season back on the rails.

“Just take the game as it comes and focus on being in the moment,” Blueger said. “And whatever may come down the line, I’ll deal with it when we get there.”

Matt Vensel: mvensel@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mattvensel.