There weren’t many five-tool players in the bunch.
Or any, really.
Yet while their evaluations on scouts’ 20-to-80 scale might’ve lacked, and most everyone inside the Penguins dressing room ditched baseball for hockey not long after Little League, there’s still some flickering fandom and unrealized dreams when it comes to America’s pastime.
“Baseball was a big part of my childhood,” said Brian Dumoulin, who played the sport through his sophomore year of high school, primarily as a first baseman. At 6-foot-4, Dumoulin possesses a perfect pitcher’s build and spent some time on the mound. He even played middle infield on occasion.
“It was a fun sport, but as I got older, it did start to get a little boring,” he said.
Dumoulin certainly isn’t alone, if you’ve paid attention to MLB’s pace-of-play initiatives and the pitch clock that’s set to arrive in 2023. A native of Biddeford, Maine, and a Red Sox fan growing up, Dumoulin also has company when it comes to excitement surrounding the the Monday’s Winter Classic against the Bruins at Fenway Park.
Read More
While Dumoulin understands the area and what Boston’s baseball team means to it, it doesn’t take a hardcore seamhead to grasp how special it will feel to skate inside one of baseball’s most historic venues.
“I played there twice in college,” said Dumoulin, a Boston College product. “It will be fun to go back and experience it all. It will be even more special now with my wife and son being able to go.”
The scouting report Dumoulin gave on himself was funny. The defenseman said he lacked power but generally put the ball in play, his strikeout total respectable.
It was a similar assessment to the one provided by Dumoulin’s coach, Mike Sullivan, who’s probably the most high-achieving ballplayer the Penguins have. Growing up about 40 minutes southeast of Fenway in Marshfield, Mass., Sullivan went to a ton of Red Sox games with his grandfather, father, uncles and brothers.
In college at Boston University, not only did Sullivan regularly occupy outfield seats on summer nights, but he actually played a year of college baseball, a little-known fact about the Penguins bench boss.
“It was kind of a funny experience because the baseball season starts well before the hockey season ends,” said Sullivan, who obviously starred on the ice for legendary hockey coach Jack Parker. “I came on in the middle of the season. They had already been playing for a month. I didn’t play a whole lot, but I enjoyed the experience.”
Sullivan was a shortstop. He had a strong arm but struggled making consistently accurate throws to first base. He mostly hit leadoff and could put the ball in play. What Sullivan lacked in power, he made up for in speed and range.
“I’ve always loved baseball, and I’m obviously a diehard Red Sox fan,” Sullivan said. “I have so many incredible memories of going to Fenway Park when I was a kid. Now having the opportunity to play a hockey game there, for me, it’s the thrill of a lifetime.”
There are plenty with zero baseball experience, as well. Kasperi Kapanen said he never played because “it just wasn’t my sport.” Kris Letang had similar feelings. Although he enjoyed watching the Expos play in Montreal, the pace of baseball didn’t sit well with the high-energy Letang. “I needed to move,” he said.
In Anaheim, Rickard Rakell remembered one experience where the Angels brought the Ducks over to take batting practice. “I did OK,” Rakell said smiling, admitting that he had no other meaningful experience on the diamond.
That wasn’t the case for Sidney Crosby growing up in Cole Harbour, Nova Scotia. As obsessive as Crosby might’ve been about hockey, his same group of friends took a break during the summer months and played baseball. It also helped that Crosby had the same coach [Paul Mason] for both.
“I liked it a lot,” Crosby said. “I liked the team aspect of it. It’s obviously way different than hockey. It’s a little slower paced, more relaxed. It was fun in the summers to spend time at the baseball field.”
Position-wise, Crosby played catcher, pitcher and third base. He enjoyed being around the action on every pitch and might’ve avoided the hot corner — except that Penguins emergency goalie Mike Chiasson was actually the team’s primary catcher, so Crosby had to shift positions to remain in the lineup.
If you’re ever looking for a laugh, Google Crosby, Jack Johnson and baseball fight to learn about a wild skirmish the duo endured at Shattuck-St. Mary’s in Minnesota.
As for Crosby’s pitch mix ...
“We weren’t really allowed to throw curveballs,” Crosby said of when he’d take the mound back home. “It was mostly fastballs and changeups. And, to be honest, there wasn’t much difference between the two. It was more placement.”
There’s one link on the Penguins that should seem obvious but actually petered out ... or, let’s say Petry’d out. An MLB pitcher, Dan Petry won 125 games over a 13-year career and went 18-8 with a 3.24 ERA for the Tigers’ 1984 World Series-winning team.
Yet his son, Jeff, found hockey and loved it, nervously ditching baseball after his junior year in high school. (Although Jeff fretted over what Dan might say, dad was completely supportive.) A first baseman and pitcher for St. Mary’s Prep in Orchard Lake Village, a suburb of Detroit, Petry helped his team to a 2003 Division II state title before calling it quits.
“My junior year in high school, I stopped playing baseball and chose hockey as my path," Petry said in a 2015 ESPN article. "I was always better at hockey and I enjoyed it more. I was more passionate about it."
Growing up in Minnesota, Ryan Poehling considered himself a pretty big baseball guy. A diehard Twins fan, Poehling’s favorite player as a kid was Torii Hunter for the incredible, athletic catches he’d make in center field.
Poehling played baseball until he was about 14. He bounced around in the field, but his favorite positions were shortstop, catcher and outfield. With Target Field only about 20 minutes from his offseason home, Poehling tries to get to a handful of games every summer but grew frustrated with the Twins’ September collapse this season, as they ceded the AL Central to Cleveland.
“Hard team to love, but I do love the Twins,” Poehling said.
As a kid, Poehling actually participated in a 64-team 12-U tournament in Cooperstown, N.Y., site of the National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum, one that ran concurrent with the Little League World Series in Williamsport.
There was never anything that organized for Danton Heinen as a kid in Langley, B.C. The Penguins winger made it a year or two past Little League age and enjoyed his (brief) career as a pitcher. At the same time, it got to the point where hockey was just too demanding.
Brock McGinn never played organized baseball. He stuck to hockey and lacrosse while growing up in Fergus, Ontario, though he has joined a slow-pitch softball league with some of his buddies back home. The acclimation process has not been easy.
“It’s harder than it looks,” McGinn said with a smile.
Bryan Rust, similar to Poehling, is a tortured Tigers fan from his time growing up outside of Detroit, though his baseball career didn’t last much past the age of 10. Since establishing himself in Pittsburgh, Rust joked that he’s found solace in the pain and torture that Pirates fans have often experienced.
Casey DeSmith was never big on baseball. The goaltender played one season when he was 5, and that was it. At the same time, it doesn’t take a Sullivan-level admiration for baseball to realize that what the Penguins will have the opportunity to do is bound to be really cool.
“Being from New Hampshire and growing up watching the Red Sox, I know how historically important Fenway Park is,” DeSmith said. “It’s gonna be a fun experience, and I’m excited to get back there.”
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.