The story of the Penguins’ offseason has been — and will continue to be — the uncertain futures of Evgeni Malkin and Kris Letang.

As their unresolved contract situations extend into the summer, all eyes will be on those big-name free agents. But they aren’t the only ones on general manager Ron Hextall’s plate at the negotiating table.

Here’s a look at each of the other Penguins’ restricted and unrestricted free agents.

Danton Heinen, RFA, 26 years old, forward

Advertise with us

Signed last offseason to a prove-it, one-year, $1.1 million deal, Heinen was one of the value additions that helped the Penguins round out the roster. His versatility proved valuable when he appeared on all four lines and on both wings. Along the way, he recorded a career-best 18 goals, as his production out-weighed his cap hit.

Extending Heinen a qualifying offer would cost the Penguins $1.1 million. But that doesn’t mean he’d have to play for that dollar figure. Based on his production last year, Heinen is probably due a slight raise.

But how much? For the cap-strapped Penguins, the answer to that question likely hinges on if Heinen remains on the team in 2022-23. While he’s not going to break that bank, the Penguins need to pinch pennies if they want to keep their bigger assets on board or find money to make a splash in free agency.

Kasperi Kapanen, RFA, 25 years old, right wing

Coach Mike Sullivan talked in the preseason about how he hoped Kapanen would use his eye-popping speed and above-average shot to become an “elite” player in the league. Instead, it was the opposite. Kapanen slid down the depth chart, was half as productive as least season and ultimately spent two games in the press box as a healthy scratch.

Advertise with us

While Kapanen has underwhelmed, the decision whether to keep him on the roster next season might be a bit more complicated than it does at first glance.

The recently expired deal that carried a $3.2 million cap hit was front-loaded and bonus-laden. Therefore, extending a qualifying offer to retain exclusive negotiating rights costs the Penguins a very manageable $840,000.

The trouble is, that’s only Step 1. While players are permitted to play on the qualifying offer (Marcus Pettersson did so a few years back), there’s no chance Kapanen will accept this close to the veteran minimum.

That could set the stage for a challenging arbitration hearing. So when it comes to pure asset management, extending Kapanen a qualifying offer seems like the most likely scenario. But then comes the challenge of either finding a dollar figure that satisfies both sides or finding a trade partner who believes in Kapanen’s upside.

Brian Boyle, UFA, 37 years old, center

Advertise with us

When Boyle joined the Penguins on a professional tryout in training camp, there was no guarantee he’d even make the team, let alone play regular minutes. But quickly he became a valuable reinforcement in the middle and a trusted voice in the dressing room.

The Penguins knew they were getting a capable center who could fill in while Sidney Crosby and Evgeni Malkin were recovering from offseason surgeries. They knew they had a faceoff specialist and sound penalty killer. What they didn’t expect was he’d score 11 goals and play well enough they eventually found a place for him at wing in a more-healthy lineup.

While Boyle exceeded expectations, keeping him next year remains a question mark. Set to turn 38 during the 2022-23 season, Boyle’s skating legs are not what they were. The need at center is also not nearly as great with Sidney Crosby healthy and at least some type of No. 2 center on the books, whether that’s Malkin or another player.

While Boyle would likely be willing to play for another bargain deal, at some point the Penguins may want to use their final roster spots on players like Drew O’Connor and Radim Zohorna, who are much younger and provide some of the same positional flexibility.

Rickard Rakell, UFA, 29 years old, winger

Advertise with us

Ahead of the deadline, general manager Ron Hextall said publicly he was looking for more than just a rental. Now the time comes to see if Rakell can be more than that.

In his brief time with the Penguins, Rakell showed some of the offensive instincts that initially enticed Hextall to swing his biggest move in Pittsburgh. Rakell’s four goals with the Penguins, plus the 16 he scored in Anaheim, gave him his fourth 20-goal season.

Along the way, Rakell also showed more playmaking prowess than the club anticipated and a willingness to throw around his 6-foot-1, 195-pound frame. If the Penguins can afford to fit him, Rakell would be a nice addition to the forward corps as a Swiss Army knife in the top six who can play on both wings and with several different centers. The challenge will be that many other clubs will be willing to enter that discussion.

Evan Rodrigues, UFA, 28 years old, forward

Versatility is the first word that comes to mind when it comes to Rodrigues. He’s the only player on the team who regularly plays all three forward positions and on both special teams units.

Advertise with us

Figuring out exactly where he fits into the future plans of the club? Well that’s equally challenging.

Early this year, he ripped off a ridiculous 15 goals and 30 points through the first 33 games. At the All-Star break, he had put up All-Star caliber numbers. But in the final 49? His production fell off considerably, as he tallied just four goals and nine assists.

No other player on the Penguins roster has the ceiling to play on Crosby’s wing — or the floor to be in the press box as a healthy scratch.

That same versatility that attracted the Penguins to Rodrigues in the first place might motivate them again this offseason. However, there’s a decent chance some team out there can guarantee Rodrigues more regular minutes in the middle and a bigger paycheck after his career year.

Nathan Beaulieu, UFA, 29 years old, RHD

Advertise with us

When the Penguins acquired Beaulieu on deadline day, the condition was more important than the compensation. It stated that Winnipeg would receive a seventh-round pick if the Penguins won three playoff series and Beaulieu played in at least 50% of the games.

Well, the Penguins won zero series and Beaulieu played in exactly zero games. So in a sense, it was almost like the trade didn’t happen at all. However, Pittsburgh did get a brief chance to kick the tires on what Hextall termed a “rugged” defenseman during practice.

Beaulieu is a different type of defenseman than the Penguins have, with more size and physicality to his game. However, given the current state of the blue line, the Penguins do not have room on the left side or much of a need. Lefties Brian Dumoulin, Mike Matheson and Pettersson are all under contract and all make more than $4 million a year. Righty Mark Friedman, who is just as comfortable on the left, recently signed a new deal that extends through 2023-24. It’s also worth remembering lefty Pierre-Olivier Joseph is knocking on the door of the NHL.

So keeping Beaulieu likely either requires him to accept a role that includes time in the AHL or one of the left-handed defensemen leaving via trade.

Casey DeSmith, UFA, 30 years old, goalie

Advertise with us

For the second consecutive postseason the Penguins have to be wondering, how would the first-round series be different if DeSmith stayed healthy?

Once again, DeSmith sustained a groin injury — this time to the opposite side — that made him unavailable for the playoffs. It was a sudden ending to an up-and-down season. Through mid-January, DeSmith lugged around a .886 save percentage and 3.6 goals-against average. The troubling play reached a head when he was yanked from back-to-back games.

From there, DeSmith’s stats significantly improved down the stretch. In his final 17 games, he recorded a very solid .927 save percentage and 2.4 goals-against average.

At 30 years old, he’d be a cap friendly option at the position. And if he can play like he did in the second half of the season, he’d be a more-than-respectable backup. But given his early-season struggles and his injury history, can you count on him to be the guy in a pinch?

Twice the Penguins have learned the hard lesson of how critical goaltending depth is in the postseason. Using the limited cap space to find a proven goalie who can alleviate some of Tristan Jarry’s workload and be a reliable safety net might be a better bet than assuming DeSmith will be healthy and on top of his game when it matters.

Advertise with us

Louis Domingue, UFA, 30 years old, goalie

Domingue will forever have a place in Penguins folklore as the spicy pork and broccoli king who entered Game 1 in a pinch and earned the triple-overtime win. But what will his place be on the roster next season?

He’s a great story but also an NHL journeyman. If the Penguins are looking for a third goalie, Domingue is a decent option. Name a team with a better third goalie. Bringing him back likely depends upon if he’s okay with a role that will mostly be at the AHL level and the chance he could get leapfrogged by a younger goalie in the organization.

Mike DeFabo: mdefabo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @MikeDeFabo.