NEW YORK – This was not a poor performance by any means. But there was just too much for the Penguins to overcome to make it another magical night.
The Penguins had to get back up after their triple-overtime thriller Tuesday, a late night in Manhattan that drained players both physically and emotionally.
They were severely short-handed, losing three key players to injury in Game 1.
There was the two-goal deficit they found themselves in for a second straight game, not ideal with Igor Shesterkin standing on his head down at the other end.
And a kooky carom during the third period sealed a New York Rangers victory.
The Penguins lost, 5-2, Thursday at Madison Square Garden. Their first-round series with the Rangers is now tied, 1-1. But as the series heads to Pittsburgh for Game 3 at PPG Paints Arena on Saturday, they are fine with where things stand.
Read More
Coach Mike Sullivan struck an optimistic tone despite a lopsided final score.
“It was a hard-fought game,” he said. “We can take a lot of positives. I thought at 5-on-5, for the most part, we were pretty good. Listen, we’re playing a real good opponent. They’re a good team, too. And when we were in our zone, I thought we defended hard. We had some looks in the offensive zone, as well.”
Even with the teams having a similar number of shots and scoring chances in Game 2, per Sportlogiq, the Rangers began to pull away during the second period. A few key plays went their way in the third to put the game fully out of reach.
Early in that period, Shesterkin made the save of the evening when he zipped over to deny Evgeni Malkin, whom Danton Heinen spotted at the back door. Moments later, he stretched out his right pad to cut off Sidney Crosby’s tip-in try.
After squandering those opportunities, the Penguins watched the Rangers score a fluky goal to push their lead to 4-2. Artemi Panarin’s centering pass to no one in particular hit Mike Matheson’s skate and caromed in. Matheson, in disbelief, stared up at the concave ceiling at Madison Square Garden on his way off.
Frank Vatrano then snapped a shot past Domingue’s glove to make it 5-2.
“We got that late one and then we had some chances there in the early third and then they got a bounce,” Crosby said. “That’s really what it came down to.”
The puck dropped at Madison Square Garden about 43 hours after Malkin scored in triple OT to give Game 1 to the Penguins. In that 4-3 win, they rallied past the Rangers after a rocky first period. Starting strong Thursday was a focus.
But the Penguins fell behind, 1-0, seven minutes into the first. Andrew Copp scored from the slot after a team-wide breakdown left two Rangers uncovered.
“Our starts are still lacking a bit. We’ve got to find a way to come out of the gates a little better,” Crosby said. “Hopefully being at home will do that for us.”
Jake Guentzel tied up the score, 1-1, two minutes later. The Rangers in the first period had more giveaways than an “Oprah” episode. The Penguins capitalized on one of them after Crosby intercepted a Panarin pass in the neutral zone. Guentzel scored on a busted play, beating Shesterkin for the third time in the series.
In the second period, the Rangers settled down to take another two-goal lead.
They pulled back ahead with their power play. Parked in the high slot, Ryan Strome tipped Adam Fox’s shot and it trickled between Louis Domingue’s pads.
Sullivan said special teams is an area where the Penguins must be better. They have allowed two power-play goals and given up one short-handed this series.
Chris Kreider scored on another deflection from the slot to make it a 3-1 game.
“Obviously, when you get down two [it’s tough to win],” Crosby said. “We’ve done that a couple times now. It’s not something we want to make a habit of.”
Unlike their Game 1 win, the Penguins couldn’t dig their way out of that hole.
Before the end of the second, Crosby got the Penguins back within a goal. He lugged the puck over both blue lines before banging a rebound past Shesterkin.
But Shesterkin made those two timely saves early in the third to keep the Rangers on top. The Vezina Trophy favorite has stopped 118 of 124 shots in this series. And he looks to be OK after Jeff Carter bowled him over late in the game.
“He’s a good goaltender. I know we’ve got to get a lot more traffic there. [Shooting often] has been an emphasis,” Heinen said. “We’ve done a good job.”
In the series, the Penguins have gotten goals only from their big guns. Guentzel and Crosby combined for four at 5-on-5. Bryan Rust scored on a 5-on-3 power play in Game 1. And Malkin tipped home the winner here late Tuesday night.
However, despite the absence of production from depth players, Sullivan seemed to be satisfied with the caliber of chances the rest of the team earned.
“I think these guys are trying to play the game the right way,” Sullivan said.
Domingue, one of the heroes of Game 1, made 35 saves in his first playoff start.
While the 30-year-old looked clumsy at times inside the crease, like when he made a sprawling glove save on Mika Zibanejad in the first period, he pretty much made all of the stops he was expected to make. Only Vatrano’s goal was iffy.
“He was solid. He made some big saves, especially when it was a one- or two-goal difference, that kept us in it. You look at that fourth one, it’s a bad bounce,” Crosby said. “He did a heck of a job. He’s competing in there and giving us a chance. It would have been nice there to give him some help and see what happens.”
With neither Tristan Jarry nor Casey DeSmith able to practice between the first two games of the series, it could well be Domingue’s crease again Saturday.
In addition to their top two goalies, the Penguins were also down top-pair defender Brian Dumoulin and middle-six wingers Rickard Rakell and Jason Zucker.
Given the absence of a few of their more important players, there was no shame in the Penguins heading back to Pittsburgh with the series evened up, 1-1.
“It’s a best-out-of-five now,” Marcus Pettersson said. “They’re a good team. We knew it was going to be a tough series. So keep our heads up.”
Matt Vensel: mvensel@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mattvensel.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.