With two Stanley Cup rings in his pocket and one more year on his contract in Los Angeles, Jeff Carter imagined an uneventful deadline day in 2021.

He had spent a decade with the Kings, raising banners and a family. Chances were, that’s where the veteran forward would eventually retire. Not so. Ron Hextall, in his first-ever trade as Penguins general manager, orchestrated a reunion with a player he knew well from stints in Philadelphia and L.A.

What would his role be in a new city?

“To be honest, I didn’t really know where I was going to fit in,” Carter said last postseason.

Advertise with us

Here’s where: all over.

In an ideal world, Carter would be penciled in as the third-line center where he could provide reliable defense and the occasional scoring spark behind star centers Sidney Crosby and Evgeni Malkin.

But these are the snake-bitten Penguins we’re talking about. Circumstances are almost never ideal.

As a result, the Penguins have leaned on Carter’s versatility to fill a variety of voids. Center. Wing. Penalty kill. Power play. The malleable, two-way nature of Carter’s game has made him one of the regulars helping to keep a constantly evolving team photo in focus.

Currently, with Jason Zucker’s injury status still uncertain, the Penguins have once again leaned upon Carter’s versatility. Zucker, who was injured during Thursday’s game in Minnesota, is still being evaluated. He skated in a track suit after practice, but coach Mike Sullivan did not have any additional information about his status.

Advertise with us

For the time being, the club has cast Carter in Zucker’s role as the left winger on the Malkin line. While the results themselves have been a mixed bag, the fit makes sense on a number of levels.

“I think he can help Geno’s line in so many different ways,” Sullivan said. “But for me, the biggest thing is just he’s an intelligent player on both sides of the puck.”

From an offensive standpoint, Carter brings a grip-it-and-rip-it, shoot-first mentality that has resulted in 415 career goals over 17 seasons. Sullivan has often mentioned that Malkin benefits from having a player on his wing who is willing to get to the net. Carter is that kind of straight-line player who isn’t afraid to park his 6-foot-3, 219-pound frame in front of the blue paint.

“You score goals in the weirdest way when you’re at the net,” Carter said recently. “Something’s going to go off your [butt] or off your shin pad or off your skate.”

While finding a winger to put the puck in the net is critical for a Penguins team that’s leaned heavily on the Crosby line for offense, the more significant perks of playing Carter alongside Malkin come in the face-off circle and in the defensive zone. Those two areas are relative weaknesses of Malkin’s games — and strengths for Carter.

Advertise with us

Consider that Malkin has only won more than 50% of his face-offs once in his career (2019-20). This year, his 43.7% success rate in the dot is actually worse than his underwhelming career average (44.3%).

On the flip side, Carter has taken nearly 15,000 face-offs in his career and won 51% of them. He’s currently won a career-best 56.4% of his draws, which ranks 10th best among eligible NHL forwards.

“He’s a right-handed shot,” Sullivan said. “He can take face-offs on that right side where he’s pulling to his backhand. But he’s also really good on his forehand, as well. So if Geno’s struggling in the face-off circle, we can utilize [Carter] in that capacity.”

At the same time, Carter also adds a defensive conscience to the Malkin line. It’s no secret that Malkin loves to freelance, going off the grid to produce both highlight reel plays and frustrating moments. Having someone like Carter, who has received Selke Trophy votes on numerous occasions, alongside Malkin adds a stabilizing presence.

“I think he takes some of the defensive pressure off of Geno when he’s there just because he’s familiar with playing down low in our system,” Sullivan said. “... He’s an intelligent player on both sides of the puck, so he makes good decisions. [He has] awareness and recognition skills of when he needs to become the low man if Geno’s not back or things of that nature.”

Advertise with us

When Malkin came back from injury in mid-January, the Penguins initially played Carter on his wing for some of these same reasons. They later tinkered with Carter alongside Malkin on a few different instances when situations merited consideration.

It remains to be seen how long this latest combination sticks together.

Mike DeFabo: mdefabo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @MikeDeFabo.