EDMONTON, Alberta — We should probably start this off by acknowledging that the Penguins didn’t deserve to make it into overtime Monday in Calgary.
But largely due to Tristan Jarry, who might have played his best game of the season, they had a chance to pull off an improbable win during 3-on-3 action.
Unfortunately, the Penguins once again were unable to seize control, continuing an unwelcome trend. Seven of their games this season went into overtime, including Monday’s 2-1 shootout loss to the Flames. They’ve won just one in OT.
“Historically, we’ve had pretty good success in overtime. We feel like we have the personnel, especially when we’re healthy, that can thrive in those circumstances,” coach Mike Sullivan said Tuesday, a day before his Penguins play the Edmonton Oilers here. “But a lot of it boils down to commitment and details.”
Well, the Penguins are pretty close to being at full health. So what gives?
Two years ago, after some early-season struggles in overtime, the Penguins found a formula that made them one of the league’s toughest teams at 3-on-3.
Read More
Instead of playing run-and-gun hockey, which was fun for fans to watch when the NHL switched to 3-on-3 overtime in 2015, the Penguins embraced cold, sometimes boring efficiency. They hogged the puck, didn’t let opponents get to the far bench for line changes then tried to take advantage of those tired bodies.
From late November in 2019, when the Penguins made a breakthrough in terms of player buy-in, through the end of last season, they were 11-4 in games decided in OT, including 5-2 last season. Only six total games went to a shootout.
Already this season, they have been to five shootouts, losing four. Win, say, three of them in overtime, and the perception of the Penguins looks different.
After Tuesday’s practice at Rogers Place, Sidney Crosby acknowledged the team has drifted away from the disciplined approach that brought it past success.
“Those details are important, whether it’s line changes or puck possession. So the better job you do of that, the better chance you give yourself to win games,” he said. “It’s a pretty fine line in overtime, with the chances going back and forth. But we can probably generate a little bit more to give ourselves a chance.”
Not to quibble with the captain, but the stats say the issue is the other end.
In terms of their expected goals percentage, scoring chances and shots from the slot in overtime, their rates are similar to each of the previous two seasons, per Sportlogiq. But they have experienced significant slippage defensively.
Compared to last season, the Penguins are allowing 25 more seconds of opponent puck possession per five minutes of OT, they are giving up about 50% more scoring chances and their rate of shots allowed from the inner slot has tripled.
Set aside the stats, and the eyes will tell you that the Penguins have not been able to “out-change” opponents at the same rate. Other teams have wised up. And now they are pouncing on Penguins breakdowns, not the other way around.
“It seems like everyone is getting better at it,” Teddy Blueger said of the overtime chess match. “It’s getting hard to create chances until there’s one breakdown that leads to a rush the other way. And it seems like other teams are doing a better job of just holding onto the puck and staying with their guys on defense.”
With time ticking down in Monday’s overtime, the Flames nearly won the game after one offensive-zone turnover led to an avalanche of odd-man rushes.
After the Penguins charged into Calgary territory, Johnny Gaudreau stole the puck and sent the Flames on the counterattack. They were unable to bury their chance and there went the Penguins the other way. Kris Letang and Jason Zucker got two whacks on a 2-on-1 rush. But Jakob Markstrom kept the puck out.
At this point, Letang was absolutely gassed. It was late in a 57-second shift and now he had to skate the length of the ice for the fourth time in quick succession. He could only helplessly watch as Jarry flashed his glove to rob Gaudreau.
“When it gets turned over, your eyes kind of light up because you’ve got a scoring chance the other way,” Blueger said. “But when you’re chasing and you’re behind the play and it’s an odd-man rush, you just hope that Jarry makes a save. There’s not much you can do. It can be tough if you’re at the end of your shift.”
Thankfully for the Penguins, Jarry has been perfect during 3-on-3 overtime. He has stopped all 14 shots he’s faced, tied for the NHL lead after Monday’s games.
Tuesday, Sullivan didn’t seem overly concerned about his team’s play in OT.
But something said three weeks ago by Todd Reirden, filling in as acting head coach while Sullivan was sick, confirmed that it has been a source of frustration.
“I can tell you that we didn’t decide to change our strategy and our scheme for [overtime],” Reirden said after a Nov. 9 loss in Chicago. “We feel pretty good about how we did in those situations last year with the puck possession and that game plan. And I think we haven’t done a good job of executing it [this season].”
Matt Vensel: mvensel@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mattvensel.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.