It’s been a week since Jim Rutherford resigned, shocking the hockey world and leaving the Penguins scrambling to find a new general manager midseason.

Despite recent organizational instability and a dearth of draft picks and blue-chip prospects, the GM chair here remains coveted. Sidney Crosby, Mike Sullivan, strong ownership and first-rate facilities make it a desirable gig, as evidenced by all the resumes that flooded David Morehouse’s inbox within 48 hours.

“We’re going to do a careful analysis of people who are interested,” Morehouse, the team’s president and CEO, said after Rutherford walked away last Wednesday. “We’re going to look at people who we think fit into the Penguins mold and into our model. And we’re going to make the hire when we find that.”

Since then, the Penguins have whittled down the list of potential targets and have been lining up their first round of interviews. Multiple reports have revealed a dozen or so candidates, though a few of them are under contract with other NHL teams and might not be permitted to pursue this position with the Penguins.

Advertise with us

What does that list say about what the Penguins are looking for in their next GM and also how the organization views its longer-term outlook?

Here are six takeaways from what we know about the GM search so far.

1. They are casting a wide net.

Not only do the Penguins plan to speak a bunch of candidates, they also appear to be keeping an open mind about the type of GM they will be bringing in.

Peter Chiarelli is an experienced GM with a Stanley Cup on his resume from his time in Boston. Chris Drury and Chris MacFarland are up-and-coming executives.

Advertise with us

Patrik Allvin, their interim GM, has toiled out of the spotlight while scouting in Europe. Kevin Weekes shows off his gregarious personality on NHL Network.

Former NHL general managers Mike Gillis, Joe Nieuwendyk and John Ferguson Jr. have been waiting a long while to get a chance to be a head honcho again.

Plus, a few former Penguins front-office staffers have been getting buzz.

2. GM experience isn’t a must.

Last week, Morehouse indicated that the Penguins plan to remain in “a win-now mode” for at least the short term. That seemed to suggest the Penguins would covet someone with experience as a team’s lead hockey decision-maker.

Advertise with us

However, several of the known candidates don’t have that on their resume.

MacFarland has received rave reviews for helping the Colorado Avalanche draft and develop one of the NHL’s top under-25 cores. Ditto for Drury, who reportedly told the Penguins on Wednesday that he’ll remain with the New York Rangers.

Weekes, who will be among the first to interview per TSN, has been in the media since retiring from the NHL in 2009. The former goalie, who played for Rutherford in Carolina, interviewed for recent GM openings in Arizona and Florida.

Scott Mellanby, a longtime lieutenant in Montreal for Mario Lemieux’s buddy Marc Bergevin, was another possibility the Penguins eyed. But the Canadiens announced over the weekend that he was pulling his name out of consideration.

3. Familiarity will be a factor.

Advertise with us

The Penguins, while casting a wide net in these early stages, have also been linked to a few executives who rose through the ranks here under Rutherford.

Tom Fitzgerald is said to be among the top candidates, per the Athletic. But he is also under contract with the New Jersey Devils until season’s end. Sportsnet has reported that the Devils could soon lock down their new GM longer term.

Jason Botterill, who just joined the expansion Seattle Kraken as the assistant GM to Ron Francis, was also mentioned as a potential target. He helped Pittsburgh go back-to-back in 2016 and 2017, but his brief stint in Buffalo was rough.

Allvin has been with the Penguins since 2006, helping them win the Stanley Cup three times and serving as director of amateur scouting from 2017-20. In November he was elevated to assistant GM after Jason Karmanos was dismissed.

Speaking of Karmanos, Sportsnet reported the Penguins may have interest in him as a Rutherford replacement. Which, honestly, who saw that one coming? Elliotte Friedman wrote Tuesday that Rutherford and Karmanos, who had a longstanding relationship, had “a falling out” that led to the latter’s October firing.

Advertise with us

4. Winning pedigree wanted.

Among the known candidates, only Chiarelli won the Cup as general manager. But most of them have contributed to winning in some fashion at the NHL level.

There’s the aforementioned foursome of former Penguins executives.

Mike Futa worked alongside Kings general manager Dean Lombardi to bring a pair of Cup parades to Los Angeles. Ron Hextall was also a Kings executive when they won it all in 2012 then returned to Philadelphia to build their current core.

Nieuwendyk, another name mentioned by Sportsnet, is among a handful of NHLers who won the Stanley Cup while skating for three different franchises.

Advertise with us

Heck, Drury was the winning pitcher in the Little League World Series. However, the Stanley Cup he won in Colorado in 2001, his NCAA title at Boston University and those two Olympic silver medals were presumably more appealing.

5. They’re taking a longer view.

That the Penguins are not just interested in older guys who have done the job before suggests they may want to take a longer view than they did under Rutherford.

Their interest in the likes of Drury, Futa, Hextall and MacFarland reinforces that notion. Those four are highly regarded around the NHL because of their track record drafting and/or developing young players. The same applies to Allvin, who would not be a candidate if the Penguins didn’t appreciate his work as a scout.

Morehouse made it clear last week that the Penguins aren’t interested in a rebuild. But that doesn’t necessarily mean they want to keep trading away high draft picks and their top prospects in pursuit of a Cup in the next year or two. There’s middle ground here for a franchise that is in a pivotal moment in its history.

Advertise with us

The contracts for Evgeni Malkin and Kris Letang are up after next season, but Crosby is signed through 2025 and has given no indication he wants to finish his career anywhere else. Given his smarts, sublime skills and work ethic, the future Hall-of-Famer could very well play until he is 40, good health permitting, at a high level.

Do they want to pivot to an approach that allows them to transition into the next era of Penguins hockey while still trying to build around Crosby? That would be a tricky tightrope to tiptoe, but the right person might be able to pull it off.

6. The search should move quickly.

By all accounts, the Penguins want to get their next GM in place pretty quickly, certainly before the NHL trade deadline on April 12. With the use of video calls, they could finalize their hire before the end of February if they want.

The thought here is that the Penguins should take all the time they need to make sure they nail this critical hire. If their ideal candidate won’t be available until this summer, bring in a senior advisor to help Allvin navigate the playoff push.

Advertise with us

That said, a number of the candidates listed above are intriguing, particularly MacFarland and Futa. Or perhaps Allvin shows them something the next few weeks. This is a good group to pick from, which is not surprising considering Pittsburgh’s winning pedigree and the captain and the Cup-winning coach already in-house.

Matt Vensel: mvensel@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mattvensel.