The dust appears to have settled after an offseason overhaul in Pittsburgh.

The first few days of free agency went as expected, with the Penguins attempting to bolster the back end of their roster by signing five new players who will all earn the league minimum of $700,000 when at the NHL level next season.

They have also retained restricted free agents Sam Lafferty and Anthony Angello, giving them a full NHL roster and a shade under $2.6 million in salary cap space, per CapFriendly. So they are likely done signing anyone of significance.

Barring another trade, which would be general manager Jim Rutherford’s fifth of an eventful offseason, these sure look to be your 2020-21 Penguins.

Advertise with us

Working — perhaps foolishly — under the assumption that GMJR is indeed more or less done dealing, let’s zoom out and assess the team he has built:

1. Which move was the most impactful?

After another early playoff exit, the Penguins said goodbye to a few more guys who helped them hoist the Stanley Cup in 2016 and 2017. Matt Murray and Patric Hornqvist were traded. Justin Schultz left in free agency. Assistant coaches Mark Recchi and Jacques Martin were relieved of their duties.

But when you remove sentiment and focus solely on the bouncing puck, the reacquisition of Kasperi Kapanen is the move that will define this offseason.

Looking to strengthen the top six while injecting more speed and youth into the mix, Rutherford moved swiftly to get Kapanen instead of waiting to see if the eight teams still skating in the NHL playoffs could top Toronto’s offer for the No. 15 overall pick this fall. We will likely never know the opportunity cost of taking the deal.

Advertise with us

Rutherford is OK with that. Trying to maximize what is left of the prime years for Sidney Crosby and Evgeni Malkin, Rutherford is confident that Kapanen will fit in well to the right of one of those two star centers. And he believes the 24-year-old will best his previous career high of 44 points with more playing time.

If Rutherford is right, the top of the Penguins’ lineup may have as much firepower as anyone. But if Kapanen is the player he was in Toronto, someone who was slotted in as a third-liner, it’s hard to see the team significantly improving.

2. Did you forget about Jack Johnson?

We did not. Yes, Johnson was their weakest link the past two seasons. So it seemed inevitable that the defenseman would be bought out or traded in a salary dump. They did the former, and he has since signed with the New York Rangers.

But the belief here is that getting rid of a guy who averaged only 16 minutes of ice time against the Montreal Canadiens doesn’t suddenly fix everything.

Advertise with us

3. But the third pair will be better, right?

It should be, yeah, but no guarantees there. If the season started today, newcomer Mike Matheson and Chad Ruhwedel would partner on that third pair.

Matheson has a career minus-30 rating, his puck possession numbers at 5-on-5 are below average and he was benched by Florida in the playoffs. Meanwhile, Ruhwedel has typically been trusted to play only when someone else is injured.

But, for the Penguins, there is nowhere to go but up. Matheson is a very good skater and is a capable if inconsistent puck-mover. They hope to help him get his once-promising career back on track. And Ruhwedel may be as flashy as a rusted penny, but he knows his limitations and played pretty well last season.

If one of them can’t cut it, they can always address it at the trade deadline.

Advertise with us

4. What about the team’s bottom six?

Well, it’s going to look different, that’s for sure. Will it be better? *Shrugs*

In the past two months, the Penguins moved on from Hornqvist, Conor Sheary, Patrick Marleau, Nick Bjugstad and Dominik Simon. They also traded away Evan Rodrigues only to bring him back, like, six days later. *Shrugs again*

Jared McCann: third-line center? (Peter Diana / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Rodrigues, Mark Jankowski and Colton Sceviour are not known for their scoring, so the bottom two lines could be more defensive-oriented. If so, that would put a lot of pressure on the Crosby and Malkin lines to bring it most nights.

Two X-factors here are Jared McCann and Teddy Blueger. The McCann we saw in the first half last season is capable of driving play on the third line. And if Blueger makes strides in the offensive end and in the faceoff circle, he could finally halt the parade of underperforming third-line centers since Nick Bonino left.

Advertise with us

5. Jankowski is an elite yinzer name.

That’s not a question. But totally agree. You can already hear Penguins fans calling Mark Madden to say that “Jahn-kohw-ski” needs to shoot the puck more.

6. Are they going to miss Hornqvist?

The spastic Swede is another leader lost from the back-to-back Cup teams, so the Penguins will need fresh voices to emerge inside a business-like locker room. But on the ice, it was clear after the Kapanen trade that Hornqvist no longer had here the kind of role one making $5.3 million is typically expected to play.

Taking nothing away from what he did during his time in Pittsburgh, when he was a warrior and scored one of the biggest goals in Penguins history, but Hornqvist is on the decline. He did score 17 goals last season. But he turns 34 soon and the injuries have piled up, including a worrisome number of concussions.

Advertise with us

You can question the return the Penguins got from the Panthers in exchange for a fan favorite, but it’s hard to fault them for looking to turn the page.

7. Who will play on the PP anyway?

Two power-play part-timers in Hornqvist and Schultz are gone. That should free up Jake Guentzel to play more minutes on the top unit alongside Crosby, Malkin and Kris Letang, the leading candidate to play quarterback at the point.

Unfortunately, there is still a giant question mark parked in the left circle, a void they were unable to fill last season after trading Phil Kessel to Arizona. Bryan Rust and Kapanen are the top right-handed options for that spot. Rust actually led the Penguins in power-play goals last year, so he’s probably the best bet.

Regardless of which five guys get sent out on the top unit next season, the plan of attack on the power play is expected to change under new assistant coach Todd Reirden, who oversaw a formidable power play during his days in D.C.

Advertise with us

8. Will the penalty kill still be solid?

You’d think so. Mike Vellucci, another new assistant, is in charge of this area after Martin was let go. When he coached Charlotte to the Calder Cup in 2018-19, the Checkers had the American Hockey League’s top penalty kill.

Pretty much all of the personnel is back from the NHL’s 10th-ranked penalty kill last season, with the exception of Johnson. Jankowski and Sceviour give the Penguins two new forward options for the PK. Jankowski could, in particular, ease the burden on Blueger and handle some of those critical short-handed faceoffs.

9. When are you getting to the goalies?

You’re right. We should probably get around to talking about the plan between the pipes. With Murray sent to the Ottawa Senators, Tristan Jarry will enter next season as the clear go-to guy after his breakthrough 2019-20 season.

Advertise with us
The plan is for Casey DeSmith, center, to back up Tristan Jarry. (Peter Diana / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

The Penguins say they are comfortable with Casey DeSmith as the No. 2 goalie, a role in which he was quite good two seasons ago. He has the right personality for the gig and has proved capable of playing well after lengthier layoffs.

There had been chatter that the Penguins might try to pull off some salary-cap Pilates to bring back one of their most popular players ever. But the Vegas Golden Knights declared Monday that they aren’t trading Marc-Andre Fleury.

It will be fascinating to see what Jarry does with this opportunity. Is he the guy we saw in the first half of last season, when he put up sparkling stats and made it to the All-Star Game? Or was that him from Jan. 1 on, when his numbers were slightly worse than Murray’s? Odds are the real Jarry is somewhere in between.

10. Any young guys to keep an eye on?

Sure. Forwards Samuel Poulin and Drew O’Connor and defenseman P.O. Joseph are the prospects most likely to go all John Marino on everyone in training camp. And if none make the opening roster, chances are we will see at least a couple of them making their NHL debuts at some point this upcoming season.

Advertise with us

11. All right, so did this team get any better?

We recently posed this question to the Twitter masses and a resounding 64.5% of respondents said the Penguins are “about the same” as last season.

We aren’t going to argue with them. The Penguins shook up their supporting cast and coach Mike Sullivan’s coaching staff. Kapanen might upgrade their top six. But, for better or worse, the Penguins are sticking with the same core, the same head coach and the same speed-based game they employed in 2019-20.

So for the Penguins to take a leap forward next season and go on a deep run for the first time in a while, they need their big three to again play at an elite level, Sullivan’s new assistants to help the head coach make effective tweaks to his scheme and Jarry to give them better goaltending than they got from Murray.

It’s certainly possible that this crew still has another Stanley Cup run in them. As long as Crosby and Malkin are still going strong, it would be foolish to rule it out. But if this offseason overhaul wasn’t enough and the Penguins underwhelm again, you can expect even more dust to be flying around next offseason.

Advertise with us

Matt Vensel: mvensel@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mattvensel.