Jonathan Gruden on joining the Penguins
That unforgettable night in Nashville, when the Penguins became the only team in the salary cap era to win the Stanley Cup in consecutive years, Marc-Andre Fleury scanned the crowd of giddy faces, looking for the kid who took his job.
When the veteran goalie made that gracious gesture at Bridgestone Arena, moving the 23-year-old to the front of the line to lift the Cup, it felt like a passing of the torch. Matt Murray would be the man in Pittsburgh for the next decade.
Three years later, Murray’s time with the Penguins is already over.
The Penguins on Wednesday traded Murray to the Ottawa Senators. In return, they received 20-year-old forward prospect Jonathan Gruden and a second-round pick, which they used to draft Finnish goalie Joel Blomqvist later in the day.
It ended a flummoxing five-year run in Pittsburgh for Murray, who didn’t come close to touching the sky-high expectations placed on him after he became the first goalie in NHL history to win the Cup twice before the end of his rookie year.
Murray, in an Instagram post, thanked Pittsburgh “for some incredible years.”
Read More
“I cherished every opportunity I had to step onto the ice in a Penguins jersey. I learned so many valuable lessons, developed so many great friendships and experienced some truly awesome moments,” Murray wrote.
He specifically thanked general manager Jim Rutherford and coach Mike Sullivan, along with other Penguins coaches, staffers and former teammates here.
Rutherford, who chose to keep Murray over an expensive and aging veteran in Fleury when the expansion Vegas Golden Knights entered the NHL in 2017, said that Murray had difficulty dealing with the pressure of being “the guy.”
Due to injuries and inconsistency, Murray never started more than 50 games in a season. He ranked 37th in the NHL in save percentage over the last three years. He won just two of his final 12 playoff starts. And he spent his final game in black and gold on the bench, watching the completion of another collapse.
“Those first two years, it was him and Fleury. They were good for each other. They had a very friendly competition, and they cheered for each other,” the GM said. “But when you lose a guy like Fleury and become the guy … I think from a mental point of view, that became maybe a bit of an adjustment that never took full hold.”
Rutherford also suggested that Murray, who supplanted one of the most popular Penguins ever, may have been bothered that he “didn’t get the credit that he deserved or thought he was going to get” for helping lead the team back to glory.
“I don’t know. You’ll have to ask him how he feels about that,” Rutherford said. “But that was my opinion, that maybe he deserved a little more credit.”
Murray was unshakeable during those two Stanley Cup runs, which he punctuated in 2017 with back-to-back shutouts to close out the Nashville Predators. He parked his 6-foot-4 frame atop his crease and was seemingly square to every shot.
He showed flashes of that elite level in the past three seasons, particularly in the second half of 2018-19, when he almost single-handedly lugged the Penguins into the playoffs. He finished that season with a .919 save percentage.
But his confidence waned at times. When the Penguins played too loose and the goals started to pile up, he retreated deeper into his crease, fearing back-door plays. That left him vulnerable upstairs, particularly on his glove side.
The Penguins and his agent discussed an extension last summer but couldn’t find common ground. Then Murray had another early-season slump to open 2019-20. Tristan Jarry took advantage, establishing the longest shutout streak in team history and making his All-Star Game debut after a fantastic first half.
Both goalies were ordinary down the stretch, so for the playoff qualifying round against Montreal, Sullivan went with the guy who helped him get his name etched on the Cup twice. Murray gave up a back-breaker to Jeff Petry in Game 3 and was benched for the final game of the playoff series loss to the Canadiens.
In the last three postseasons, Murray went 7-12-0 with a .908 save percentage — solid but not good enough to make up for his regular-season unreliability.
The Penguins made Murray available in trade talks after another early playoff exit. They believe Jarry is ready to take over the crease. Finances were also a factor, with the salary cap ceiling flattened due to the coronavirus pandemic. They have less than $5 million in cap space with free agency looming Friday.
Murray is a restricted free agent this offseason and could be awarded around $6 million if he goes to arbitration. Rutherford worried that if things got to that point, they might have to let Murray walk and get nothing back in return.
“The market is flooded right now with goalies,” he said. “I didn’t have an offer that I could take until this morning. And based on where the market is, I think we did pretty good to get the second-round pick and get a prospect in Gruden.”
The Senators, whom Rutherford said “were in this process for a long time,” plan to lock down Murray, who turned 26 in May, to an extension. Maybe he will get his game going back in the right direction with that rebuilding club.
In Pittsburgh, the torch is now passed to Jarry, who has a .914 save percentage in 62 games over four NHL seasons. The Penguins last weekend signed the 25-year-old to a three-year deal with an annual average value of $3.5 million.
A reunion with Fleury, who could be on the outs in Vegas this offseason, seems unlikely. Rutherford said he is comfortable with Casey DeSmith, who spent all of 2019-20 in the American Hockey League, as Jarry’s backup in 2020-21.
Wednesday’s trade leaves the Penguins with just nine players from their most recent Stanley Cup win in 2017. Patric Hornqvist was dealt to the Florida Panthers on Sept. 24. That list should be trimmed to seven soon, as Justin Schultz and Conor Sheary are unrestricted free agents who are not expected back.
“Because of the new CBA we have now and the lower cap, we get forced to do things that we didn’t think that maybe we’d have to,” Rutherford said. “There’s not a player that I don’t trade or don’t let go that it doesn’t bother me personally, especially … with these guys that gave so much to win the Stanley Cup.”
Matt Vensel: mvensel@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mattvensel.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.