Welcome back to Mike’s Mailbag.

It’s now been seven weeks since the NHL officially “paused” its season. Optimism is building that, in some way, the league will return this summer. But how? I addressed that — plus Snoop Dogg, Jake Guentzel’s salary and more — in this week’s mailbag. 

Rich: What’s the one crazy rule you would add to hockey if you could?

Mike: I’ve been thinking about overtime a lot lately. Actually, probably a little too much. Here’s my solution: Start at 5-on-5. Every three minutes eliminate a player. So 4-on-4, 3-on-3, 2-on-2. ... Finally, you’re left with the key part of my plan: 1-on-1 with goalies in full pads. It would be electric.

Advertise with us

Lisa: Do you think Jake Guentzel undersold his value with the contract he signed? It seems 40-goal scorers are worth more.

Mike: In December 2018, Guentzel signed a five-year, $30 million contract extension. It was smart deal by general manager Jim Rutherford that should keep Guentzel in Pittsburgh for a significant chunk of his prime. And it keeps looking better and better for the Penguins. Guentzel scored 40 goals last year and was on pace for another 40 this year before his injury.

With a $6 million average annual value, he is tied for the 90th highest-paid player in the league. There are 22 others who also make $6 million per year, including 12 other forwards.

Here are how the other forwards who make the same average salary rank in goals-per-60 since the start of the 2018-19 season:

Filip Forsberg: 53rd with 1.29 goals/60

Advertise with us

Nikolaj Ehlers: 56th with 1.28 goals/60

Timo Meier: 67th with 1.23 goals/ 60

Brock Nelson: 97th with 1.11 goals/60

Brandon Saad: 100th with 1.11 goals/60

Taylor Hall: 203rd with 0.85 goals/60

Advertise with us

Mats Zuccarello: 229th with 0.81 goals/60

Kyle Okposo: 248th with 0.79 goals/ 60

Loui Eriksson: 410th with 0.58 goals/60

Jordan Staal: 439th with 0.54 goals/60

David Backes: 524th with 0.43 goals/60

Advertise with us

Milan Lucic: 525th with 0.43 goals/60

Guentzel? Since the start of the 2018-19 season, he ranks 24th in the league with 1.51 goals/60 minutes. Clearly, he’s the most productive goal-scorer in his wage bracket.

So to answer your question, yes, I do think Guentzel could have made more. But it would have come with a price.

The Penguins have a good thing going. They’re a star-studded organization with players who, generally, value winning over money. It starts with the captain. Sidney Crosby makes $8.7 million per season, which made him the 24th highest-paid player this year. Most everyone would agree he’s far more valuable than that.

So while Guentzel might have been able to make more, it would likely mean less of a chance to hoist another Cup.

Advertise with us

John: If you could pick one Penguins uniform to resurrect as an alternate, which would you choose?

Mike: Generally speaking, the Penguins jerseys are great. With one exception. The all-yellow, nacho cheese third jerseys is gross.

The blue ones were legit. But they’ve done those before. I think enough time has passed that the so-called “pigeon” could make a comeback and be cool again. If I could pick just one to bring back, it would be the diagonal “Pittsburgh,” preferably with Snoop Dogg at the reveal party.

Chris: If the NHL does come back this summer, what’s the best way for it to resume?

Mike: First of all, if I’m the commissioner, I say forget about the rest of the regular season and go straight to the playoffs. There’s absolutely no reason the 17-49-5 Detroit Red Wings need to mentally stay in limbo for another several weeks, spend three-to-four weeks at a training camp and then play out the string.

Advertise with us

Any game is going to come with some level of risk. Every time you add a game or add a person to a “bubble,” those risks are magnified. So this should be scaled back as much as possible.

Now, when it comes to the playoffs, the league will have to get creative. Typically, the top three teams in each division earn berths in the playoffs. The next two teams in terms of total points, regardless of division, earn the wild-card spots.

However, because the season hasn’t been finished, we’re going to need to expand the postseason to give teams on the bubble a fair chance to get in.

Let’s look first at the Western Conference because it’s a little more straightforward there. In the Central Division, the three teams would be the Blues (94), Avalanche (92) and Stars (82). From the Pacific, the Golden Knights (86), Oilers (83) and Flames (79) would be in. That all makes sense.

The issue is picking wild card teams. There are four teams who have played a different number of games who could be in consideration the two spots in the West: the Jets (80 points, 1.13 points per game), Predators (78 points, 1.13 ppg), Canucks (78 points, 1.13 ppg) and Coyotes (74 points, 1.05 ppg).

Advertise with us

Here’s my solution: Expand the postseason with a couple play-in series. In my hypothetical scenario, the Jets would play the Coyotes in a three-game series and the Predators would play the Canucks in a three-game series. Then, just let the tournament play out from there.

The Eastern Conference is a bit more complicated. But stay with me. The Bruins (100 points), Lightning (92) and Maple Leafs (81) would be in from the Atlantic. The Capitals (90), Flyers (89) and Penguins (86) would make it from the Metro.

Here’s where it gets tough. The challenge for the Eastern Conference is there are five teams for two spots: The Hurricanes (81 points, 1.19 ppg), Blue Jackets (81, 1.16 ppg), Islanders (80, 1.18 ppg) Rangers (79, 1.13 ppg) and Panthers (78 points, 1.13 ppg).

This has been such a weird season, so let’s get weird. My proposal would be to have the Rangers and Panthers, the two teams with 1.13 points per game, play a one-game playoff. Then, have the remaining four teams in contention for the wild card play in a set of three-game series like I detailed above.

Everyone in Pittsburgh knows how fluky and unfair a one-game playoff can be. But it’s also must-watch TV. What better way to resume the NHL season than with a made-for-TV event with high stakes?

Have a Penguins question? Need dating advice? Problem with a coworker? No question is a bad question. If you have one, tweet me @MikeDeFabo, slide in my DMs or send me an email at mdefabo@post-gazette.com.