What’s wrong with the Penguins?
That’s the question that’s been asked in barber shops, bar rooms and basically everywhere in between over the past few weeks, as the Penguins (39-23-6, 84 points) have fallen into a puzzling slump.
On Feb. 18, they were in first place in the division, looking every bit like a Stanley Cup contender. Now? They’ve lost eight of their last 10 games, including back-to-back Metro matchups this weekend against the Washington Capitals and Carolina Hurricanes.
So, seriously, what’s wrong? Tough question. But let’s try to answer it with insight from coaches, players, stats ... and conspiracy theories.
Mental approach
Mike Sullivan knows his team better than anyone else, so he deserves to have the first word.
Read More
“First and foremost, it’s the mindset going into games,” the coach said when he stepped to the microphone following Sunday’s 6-2 loss. “And then responding to adversities and the ebbs and flows of the games.”
The Penguins have been defined by their resiliency this year. Somehow, one of the most injured teams in the league was also one of the best. After Saturday’s loss, Evgeni Malkin theorized that the Penguins have exhaled now that several players returned from injury and have deviated from what made them successful.
But as Jason Zucker pointed out, let’s avoid becoming too trite argument. It’s not simply a matter of working harder. It’s about working smarter, too.
“You can work as hard as you want,” Zucker said. “But if you’re not making the right plays and executing on those plays, you’re not going to win games.
Odd-man rushes
During Saturday’s loss to the Capitals, the Penguins surrendered three goals during odd-man rushes. This was more than a minor blip on the radar.
Sullivan identified this as an issue in last year’s early postseason exit and almost completely flipped this stat on its head during the first several months. But recently, that old wart has reared its ugly head again.
“It’s certainly an area we’ve discussed a lot in the last five or six weeks,” Sullivan said. “... It’s definitely an area of our game where we’ve got to improve.”

Power play
The Penguins have scored a power play goal in four games in a row. But that stat is a bit deceiving.
Dating back to the Feb. 20 loss in Toronto that started the tailspin, the power play is just 5-for-38 (13.2%). They’ve also allowed two short-handed goals in the last three games and squandered an early 5-on-3 during the loss to the Capitals. While Malkin cashed in during the two-man advantage against the Canes on Sunday, the Penguins were 0-for-6 during 5-on-4 situations.
“It’s probably a microcosm of our overall game,” Sullivan said. “We’re just a little disconnected. We’re not executing. We’re not anticipating.
“A lot of it is the play away from the puck. The puck support and coming to the puck and giving options for the puck carrier. When our power play is at its best, you see that instinctive play on display. ... They’re always one step ahead of the penalty killers. Right now, we’re not.”
Secondary scoring
In the eight losses during this lull, the Penguins have been shut out twice and scored just 12 total goals. Not a single one of those goals has come from a member of the bottom six or a defenseman.
Sure, part of that is because fourth-line center Teddy Blueger, for example, has the highest defensive-zone start percentage on the team at 69.7%. His line is supposed to be a shut-down line more than a scoring line. But still, just a little more production from their bottom-six could make a big difference.
Jared McCann and Brandon Tanev were two consistent — and clutch — contributors during the first half. McCann scored 14 goals and racked up 28 points in the first 44 games. He has zero goals and just six points in the last 21.
Tanev scored 10 goals and tallied 21 points in the first 45 games, including two overtime game winners and a couple regulation game-winners. While he brings value even when he’s not scoring, he has one goal and three assists in the last 22. Did they over-perform in the beginning of the season, or are they under-performing now?
Ideally, the depth the Penguins added at the deadline would help them to roll four lines and come at opponents with wave after wave after wave. But when the bottom six isn’t producing, it’s taking playing time away from Crosby and Malkin.
The defense has regressed
Just nine times this season the Penguins have given up double-digit high-danger scoring chances during 5-on-5 situations, according to Natural Stat Tick. All but one of them has come after Christmas. Clearly something has changed.
Now, when we talk about defense, we’re not talking about any one player or even any one defensive pair. Defense is a six-man job that needs to be played in all three zones. Football coaches like to say the best offense is a good defense.
In hockey, sometimes it’s the opposite. The best defense can be a good offense that hogs pucks in the offensive zone, wins puck battles and controls zone time. It’s going to take all six players on the ice to turn this stat around.

Goaltending has come back to earth
As mentioned earlier, the Penguins are leaving their goaltenders out to dry way too often because of the high-danger chances and odd-man rushes. But even with that said, the goaltending hasn’t been quite as sharp as it was during earlier stretches this season.
Jarry was playing like a Vezina Trophy candidate from mid-November through the end of December. He went 12-2-0 during that stretch with a sparkling .941 save percentage and a 1.78 goals-against average.
Now, it appears he is human after all. Since the calendar changed to 2020, he’s 7-7-1 with a .901 save percentage and 3.05 goals-against average, including Sunday’s game when he allowed six goals. While his numbers aren’t terrible — nor are they helped any by the play in front of him — he’s not stealing games.
They’re not playing together
Jake Guentzel got hurt. Dominik Kahun got traded. Sam Lafferty got relegated to the press box. Joseph Blandisi was reassigned and traded. Andrew Agozzino, too. At the same time, four new forwards joined the team via trade. Nick Bjugstad, John Marino and Brian Dumoulin returned from injury.
Sure, the additions should help. And Blandisi isn’t Wayne Gretzky. But he was young, hungry, knew the system and played to it. Lately, there have been a lot of moving pieces and not a lot of clarity on how they fit together. It’s fair to wonder if all that shuffling has impacted the team chemistry.
“I think our team looks a little disconnected,” Sullivan said. “It’s not collective, cooperative play. You have to play together out there. You have to play as a group of five.
“The league is too hard. It’s hard to take it by yourself and think you’re going to go through five guys and score a goal. It’s just too hard. We have to realize that and get back to our team game.”
Luck
There’s a reason the NHL playoffs are based on series and not single games. This is a sport that can be misleading in small sample sizes.
The Penguins probably played well enough to win in Los Angeles and, maybe, in Anaheim during the West Coast trip. A key turn of events during Sunday’s game — when Evan Rodrigues hit a post on one side of the ice and then committed a penalty on the other — is another example of how games can change in a flash. Lately, the Penguins have been finding themselves on the wrong side of the puck luck.
“We’re talking about small things here,” Crosby said. “... That’s a huge turning point. That’s the kind of games they’re going to be from here on in. We have to find a way to be on the right side of those.”
With 14 games left in the season, there’s still time to put things together and make a run. The Penguins are, after all, still just five points from first place in the Metro. But they’re also just five points from being left out of the playoffs entirely.
Time will tell if the adversity the Penguins are facing now is the opening scene of the championship DVD ... or if this is the beginning of a scene that eventually fades to black.
“I really believe in this group of players,” Sullivan said. “I believe we have what it takes. We’ve got to find a way to pull ourselves together.”
Mike DeFabo: mdefabo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @MikeDeFabo.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.