For coach Mike Sullivan, the Penguins’ current power-play inconsistencies have conjured up a memory from years past.

Back when he was in college at Boston University in the late 1980s, Sullivan played under Jack Parker — a coaching lifer who spent four decades behind the bench for the Terriers. When Sullivan got into coaching, Parker relayed a piece of advice from one coach to another.

“Sometimes, it’s the best idea to start with your five best players,” Sullivan remembers Parker saying. “And then figure it out from there.”

During Monday’s practice at UPMC Lemieux Sports Complex, Sullivan applied that lesson. The top power play unit once again featured two defensemen, Kris Letang and Justin Schultz, along with Evgeni Malkin, Jake Guentzel and Bryan Rust.

Advertise with us

Basically, the personnel grouping comprised the new-look top line that’s been assembled in Sidney Crosby’s absence, plus the two most offensively inclined defensemen. Or, as Parker might define it: the five best players.

“We like the two-defensemen look,” Sullivan said. “It gives us two righties. They’re one-time threats. They’re both good players. They’re interchangeable as far as their positions. It helps us create some movement.”

The Penguins discussed the two-defensemen look as early as the offseason, dabbled with it in training camp and deployed it several times throughout this season. It makes sense, considering the unique and offensively minded playing styles that Letang and Schultz like to use.

“When you look at [Schultz] and [Letang], they’re both offensive guys who are basically extensions of the forwards,” Rust said.

Typically, one of the defensemen mans the point and the other is off to the side on the flank. But the Penguins are encouraging motion throughout their power play, hoping that not just the puck moves but also players change places as well. In that sense, the positions are more like starting points or suggestions than anchors keeping them in a specific region on the ice.

Advertise with us

“I feel like me and [Letang] are pretty interchangeable,” Schultz said. “We don’t have a set spot. I think it creates more movement on the power play and opens up more. It’s nice being out there with another D-man for sure. But whoever is out there, we’ve got to do better on the power play.”

That’s the truth.

Through 21 games, the Penguins have converted on just 16.1% of their opportunities. Only eight teams in the league are worse in that department.

The lower point came from Oct. 16 to Nov. 19. The Penguins went through an 11-plus-game slump during which they went 0 for 28 on the power play.

The power play looked as if it found its footing, and maybe even began to turn a corner, when it scored seven times in the next eight games. But in the last five games, the Penguins have scored only once with the man advantage. Even that one is tough to count, though, because the Detroit Red Wings had pulled their goalie.

Advertise with us

Sullivan said execution, effort and decision-making have all played a role.

“We’ve had moments where we thought we were gaining traction,” Sullivan said. “We scored a few goals. And then we take a step back.”

The Penguins knew coming into the season that the power play would need to change a bit with Phil Kessel, a longtime mainstay on the left circle, now in Arizona. But with so many injuries, there have been times when the choices have been limited.

Malkin, Crosby, Patric Hornqvist, Nick Bjugstad, Letang, Schultz and Rust have all played major minutes on the power play this year. All of them have also missed considerable time with injuries. With so many moving pieces, the Penguins have tried to simplify the approach.

“We’re trying to shoot the puck a little bit more and get some net traffic and see if we can’t create some opportunity that way,” Sullivan said. “My experience of coaching any aspect of the game is when any one part of our game struggles, we just try to simplify.”

Advertise with us

For now, that means doing as Parker suggested all those years ago. Put the best five on the ice, and figure it out from there.