The Penguins power play unit whacked and hacked. They gritted and grinded in front of the net, getting the movement they were looking for. They changed places on the ice, and then personnel, adding Evgeni Malkin from injured reserve and then Alex Galchenyuk as an extra wrinkle.

After all that, what did they have to show for it? Nothing.

Five chances. Zero goals. It continued a confounding slump during which the Penguins have not scored a power play goal in eight games and 20 opportunities.

And then, alas, the Penguins finally cracked through on the power play ... well, an Edmonton power play. Late in the third, Brian Dumoulin joined the rush, providing the lone short-handed goal in Pittsburgh’s 2-1 loss.

Advertise with us

If you’re looking to tell the Penguins special teams’ story through the first 14 games, the 60 minutes against Edmonton summed it up quite well.

And really, there are two sides to the special teams story. On one hand, the power play that was for years one of the league’s best has become (at least statistically) one of the worst in the NHL during this current lull. Pittsburgh has scored just six goals this season with the man-advantage. Only five teams in the league have converted fewer times on their power play.

But at the same time, while Mike Sullivan and his players have been asked question after question after question about what’s wrong with the power play, the penalty-killing unit has, quietly, become the league’s best.

So you want the good news or bad news first?

Let’s start with the good because that’s what seems to be lost in this narrative.

Advertise with us

When it comes to killing penalties, the Penguins find themselves on the right side of three stats. Not only are they among the least-penalized teams in the league, but on the rare occasion they commit one, they are also among the best at killing the penalty and scoring short-handed goals.

“Not taking a lot of penalties is the No. 1 key,” Bryan Rust, who typically works with the top penalty-killing unit, said. “I think for us, we’re just working as a unit. Just playing hard and trying to pressure the puck when we can.”

Through 14 games, the Penguins have been forced to kill just 34 opposing power plays, second behind only the Winnipeg Jets (31). Opponents have only scored just five power-play goals against Pittsburgh. That’s tied with the Florida Panthers for the best in the league. And, to top it off, Pittsburgh has scored three short-handed goals, just one behind the league leaders in this category.

While Dumoulin’s short-handed goal provided the highlight, the more fitting snapshot of the power play unit came during the Oilers’ first power play.

Brandon Tanev buzzed around in his defensive zone without a stick like an angry gnat trapped in a bottle, just looking for a shot to block or someone to hit. Finally, he found one. With two hands, the player teammates have affectionately nicknamed “Turbo” decked an Oiler in front of the net.

Advertise with us

“I think the guys on it are doing a terrific job,” Sullivan said. “They’re committed. I think we’ve got good speed on our penalty kill with some of the guys we’ve added. We get Rusty back in the lineup. We get some speed guys that have an opportunity to put people under duress. That’s an important part of it.”

And now, the other side.

Entering this season, the Penguins knew there would be change on their power play after long-time mainstay Phil Kessel was shipped to Arizona. His tick-tack-toe passing often set the table for teammates.

Then, the Penguins lost Malkin and Galchenyuk to injury, which delayed the chemistry-building process. Currently, Pittsburgh is using a couple variations on its top unit. In one look, two defensemen — Kris Letang and Justin Schultz — are paired with forwards Sidney Crosby, Jake Guentzel and Malkin.

As the Penguins showed on Saturday, they can also sub one defenseman for Galchenyuk. While the goals aren’t there, the players and coaches aren’t displeased with the look and feel of the unit.

Advertise with us

“From my vantage point, the only thing that’s missing right now is finish,” Sullivan said. “If we weren’t generating scoring chances or we didn’t have zone time or didn’t have a high success rate on the entries or we were losing faceoffs of that sort, we could look at the structure, the process and the execution. But ... we feel as though a lot of that has been there.

“It’s not like we’re not generating opportunity. If we weren’t, it would be a different narrative. As I said to our players, we have to stay with it. We can’t get discouraged. We’ve got to get more determined.”

Mike DeFabo: mdefabo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @MikeDeFabo.