The Penguins couldn’t have drawn up a much better Saturday afternoon.
They got Evgeni Malkin back, another strong start, a short-handed goal and a whopping 52 shots, while holding two of the NHL’s top scorers without a point for three periods. But they lost, 2-1, to the Edmonton Oilers, only because it was one of those days when the puck looked like a Roomba to the opposing goalie.
It took the Penguins 47 shots to finally put one past Mike Smith, the 37-year-old scrambler who signed with Edmonton this summer after Calgary let him walk. But they couldn’t complete the comeback as Leon Draisaitl scored in a back-and-forth overtime to spoil the nice little Saturday the Penguins had planned.
“We probably deserved better,” Matt Murray said. “Smith kind of stole one.”
Despite a 1 p.m. start, the Penguins marched down the tunnel with plenty of life. While they did not score four in the first period like they did in Tuesday’s 7-1 win over the Philadelphia Flyers, they fired 18 pucks on goal in the period.
Smith twice stopped Jake Guentzel on the game’s first shift. Sidney Crosby had a glorious chance and an open net but couldn’t flip the puck past a sprawling Smith. The Penguins peppered him on the power play during the second period.
Read More
In the third, on another Pittsburgh power play, Smith stretched out his left pad to deny Guentzel, who tried to redirect a Kris Letang hard pass. Smith squeezed Bryan Rust’s tricky shot on a 2-on-1. He later booted out another Guentzel tip.
“He played unreal,” Justin Schultz said. “We had a lot of Grade-A chances.”
Especially on the power play, when the Penguins went 0-for-5 in the loss and now have gone eight games and 20 total opportunities without a goal.
“The only thing that’s missing right now is finish,” coach Mike Sullivan said. “We’re getting [traffic]. We’re getting shots to the net. We’ve had a couple of rebound opportunities. We had a back-door chance [from Letang to Guentzel] that didn’t find the back of the net. It was a terrific play by those guys.”
Sullivan added: “We just have to stay with it. … We can’t get discouraged.”
The Penguins did score their only goal on special teams. With John Marino in the box, Bryan Rust carried the puck up the ice short-handed and slipped it under a stick to Brian Dumoulin, who uncharacteristically jumped up to create a 3-on-2. The blue-liner fired one past Smith’s glove for his first goal of the season.
In overtime, after the two teams exchanged odd-man rushes and near-misses, Draisaitl got loose on a breakaway and beat Murray while getting hooked.
“That’s what happens when you have a really good chance and you miss the net or something. Everybody’s going towards the net instead of coming back the other way,” Murray said of the eventful 3-on-3 OT. “We probably traded three or four chances each and then Draisaitl made a really good play.”
During regulation, the Penguins put the clamps on both Draisaitl, who entered Saturday with the NHL lead in goals and points, and Connor McDavid, his center and the former league MVP who is nipping on his heels in the scoring race.
The Penguins have allowed just six 5-on-5 goals over their last six games.
The only one scored by the Oilers came 7:21 into the second period. Colby Cave cruised wide down the right wing and around Marcus Pettersson, cut inside from a sharp angle and pulled the puck around Murray to finish off a pretty goal.
“I think we’re just committed to it – playing the right way, having guys above the puck and really competing on defense,” said Murray, who made 26 saves.
The Penguins, for the first time this season, could deploy their full lineup. After losing Rust to injury in the preseason finale, they then watched Malkin, Alex Galchenyuk and Nick Bjugstad join him on injured reserve during the first week of the regular season. Malkin, who missed 11 games, was the last to return.
Malkin showed no signs of rust Saturday. He fired a team-high six shots, pumped up the power play and was their most dangerous player in the second period.
When Malkin and those others were out, the Penguins posted a winning record and, with the help of fast and feisty youngsters who have since been sent back to the American Hockey League, established an encouraging early-season identity based on collective play, straight-forward offense and pesky puck pursuit.
The Penguins played that way again Saturday but only earned one point in the standings due to the stellar play of Smith, who stopped 51 shots in a win.
Matt Vensel: mvensel@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mattvensel.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.