It’s been the Penguins’ on-again, off-again dalliance. Occasionally there have been sparks, other times not so much. It has involved one man giving an impassioned speech in defense of his actions, and it has evoked equal parts excitement and fury among the fan base.
No, if you’re a Penguins fan there’s really nothing quite like the proverbial Dominik-Simon-with-Sidney-Crosby debate, except maybe griping about poor Jack Johnson.
The Simon Situation has been kicked around for years, the analytics crossed with the traditional stats, Mike Sullivan defending the whole thing like he did last year in Buffalo, and finally this year we may have reached something of a consensus: We should all agree that right now would be a really good time for this blasted thing to work.
“We’ve used Dominik there off and off because at certain times we think he’s the best fit,” Sullivan said. “This is one of those times.”
Simon agreed. Again, with some very simple reasoning.
“It would be a great time to click, definitely,” Simon said with a smile. “It’s always a good time for it.”
Read More
So, how does that happen?
2. Simon’s offseason training was simple. For two weeks in Prague, then the rest in Toronto, Simon pushed the pace. Shooting was a priority. So was his speed.
“I tried to work on my edges, shooting and finishing,” Simon said. “I didn’t have any daily goals, but from when you’re little, you’re just trying to shoot hard and aim it at good spots. Let’s see if it’s going to show up.”
Through six games — admittedly a way-too-small sample size — it’s shown up pretty much like it always has. With Simon on his right wing, Crosby has been on the ice for a greater percentage of shot attempts, scoring chances, high danger chances and goals, while Simon has scored one of those and assisted on another.
“When you’re on the first line, you’re supposed to produce,” Simon said. “There’s pressure you have to deal with. I don’t mind it. I know we were able to produce before. Now it’s just about figuring stuff out so it can last and stay together.”
3. There are times where I think the Penguins have been overly reliant on Crosby and Simon together. This is not one of those times. Now, given their injuries and available personnel, it makes sense. Their other lines have offered pretty decent balance, which we’ll get to below, and I didn’t particularly like what I saw from Patric Hornqvist during his surprise, one-game cameo with Crosby.
It could’ve been the Penguins’ poor opening night on the whole, but that group did not have the dominant feel that it’s had in the past. Meanwhile, Hornqvist has added some finish to the second line with Jared McCann and Dominik Kahun, while Brandon Tanev has been good for the third with Teddy Blueger and Zach Aston-Reese.
“He does so many other good things that help his line have success,” Sullivan said of Simon. “He’s real strong on the puck. He’s a good playmaker. He’s pretty solid defensively. He has a 200-foot game. There are a lot of things he does to help that line. Obviously we’d like to see him finish a little more than he does. That’s something that’s a work in progress.”
4. How to get the goals to come is a bit of a tricky thing. (The puck must go in the back of the net; I know, I know.)
Both Sullivan and Simon talked about needing to avoid focusing on scoring. Sounds like Simon can probably psych himself out or tend to focus on that too much at times.
It’s understandable for a young player who’s had it beaten into his head that he doesn’t score enough to play where he’s been playing.
“You can’t be focused on trying to score,” Sullivan said. “You just have to try and play the game the right way and focus on the process. You get an opportunity to get around the net, put it on the net, shoot the puck, go to the net, look for rebounds, things of that nature.”
Added Simon, “You want to do almost too much.”
5. As I said before, I really do like Simon with Crosby right now, but the 25-year-old needs to do what his coach is saying: shoot the darned thing.
In the five games he’s spent on Crosby’s line, Simon has attempted 14 shots during five-on-five play, six of those coming in one game (Oct. 8 vs. Jets). Simon had five scoring chances in that game and five in the other four games combined.
If Simon is shooting the puck and creating rebounds or tip-in opportunities for Crosby, you could maybe live with the lack of goal production. But in order to stay, he has to be doing something in the form of traditional stats.
“Our discussions with Dominik are more about just the process, just focus on playing the game the way it should be played and taking what the game gives you out there,” Sullivan said. “If he can do that, hopefully some will go in for him.”
6. Moving on …
I’m a bit confused by what the Penguins are doing on defense, so I thought I would deconstruct a couple truths here. The following statements, I believe, are accurate:
• The Penguins currently have nine defensemen on their NHL roster. That’s borderline insane. I’m not going to sift through 30 other rosters, but I can’t imagine anyone else has this going on.
• They really like John Marino.
• Sullivan does value guys playing on their natural sides … unless you’re a veteran like Trevor Daley who has done it his entire career.
So where does that leave us? Well, with an imperfect equation.
7. Let’s say they leave their top-four — Brian Dumoulin and Kris Letang, Marcus Pettersson and Justin Schultz — alone. I think you’d have a tough time making the case for any of those guys to sit.
You have five guys (five!) for two spots. You could also use some salary-cap space, which makes trading Juuso Riikola, Chad Ruhwedel or Marino a waste of time.
That leaves us with Erik Gudbranson and Jack Johnson. Gudbranson has been the better lineup decision most nights, but if they want to keep Marino, he should probably play on his natural side, the right. That pushes Gudbranson over to the left, his off-side.
Johnson has been better on the left, but you probably don’t want to play him with Gudbranson (it kicks Marino out), and I think Sullivan would probably rather have a root canal than go 11/7 again.
8. The solution here is easy, but it’s really not: General manager Jim Rutherford needs to have a feel for the tenability of this situation. It’s fine to try and hold out a little for the best possible trade return, especially involving Johnson, but there’s no guarantee the return will be great given Johnson’s age and contract.
Rutherford also must be careful when it comes to potentially shipping out Gudbranson — TSN’s Bob McKenzie said Rutherford has been dangling both him and Johnson — because of the physicality they would lose. Not trying to get super old school here, but I do find value in some of it the rough-and-tumble stuff. I really think the players do, too.
Which means this should be fascinating to watch play out over the next couple weeks, especially when you consider that Riikola had a strong camp and was actually tracking toward an opening night lineup spot until the 11th hour.
9. Perhaps it’s time that we start talking about Letang’s stellar start to the season. The Penguins’ No. 1 defenseman has points in all six games, including multiple points in the past two.
He’s a plus-4 while averaging 25:36 a night. No regular has fared better than Letang’s five-on-five scoring-chance percentage of 60.44.
Most of all, Letang has looked more poised with the puck, and he’s been very much bought in to the Penguins’ simplified style they’ve adopted amid all the injuries.
10. Speaking of that …
Remember when it was being brought up that Sullivan has lost his team or they’ve tuned him out or something like that? Ah, the good old days.
What Sullivan has done — getting the Penguins to play a simple game — has been extremely impressive, and it speaks to what a terrific coach he is, among the NHL’s best.
They’re basically retooling on the fly, making the best of what they have. They’re giving up less on the defensive end, it’s translating to more offensively.
“If we’re committed in our zone and focus on the little details, it’s going to translate to our offensive game,” Letang said. “We have so many guys who can score goals and make plays.”
11. Most impressive about the way the Penguins are playing might be this: They have just 14 minor penalties through six games; only eight teams have less. Until Sunday, when they were short-handed six times, the Penguins had been among the NHL leaders in this category.
The discipline has been a welcomed change for the Penguins, who seem to struggle every October and November when more penalties are usually called.
12. Spent some time above talking about Simon with Crosby and what that line has produced together.
Let’s not lose sight of the real driver there: an incredible start to the season from Crosby.
Crosby has 10 points (three goals) through six games, his best work through six games of a season since accumulating 12 points (five goals) in 2013-14.
Whether it’s been on breakouts, kicking the puck to teammates or his usual dominance around the net, it’s really been something to watch thus far for the Penguins captain, who has seemingly taken his game to yet another level.
13. What the Penguins are doing with all these kids has been something to watch, and I wanted to touch on a couple things relative to that …
The Penguins have liked Sam Lafferty for awhile. I remember a particular conversation, I believe in the Raleigh airport, with Rutherford about Lafferty and some of the young kids the Penguins had coming up, guys who needed just a little more seasoning.
What these guys have done, especially the center from Hollidaysburg, has surprised nobody.
I also happen to think that given Lafferty’s grasp of his role, his work on the penalty kill and how he skates, he’s really giving himself a chance to stick around longer-term.
“You can see it every shift, I think he’s gaining more confidence,” Sullivan said. “We always felt like Sam was closing coming into training camp. I think he has a whole lot more confidence in himself that he belongs here. That’s great for him, and it’s great for us.”
14. May be something, may be nothing … I’ve been impressed with how ready these guys have appeared, outside of Andrew Agozzino and the 1:44 he played against the Ducks.
Has it been a different training camp? Has it been new Wilkes-Barre/Scranton coach Mike Vellucci? I’m not sure what it’s been, quite honestly. Could just be good, young players doing their thing. But it’s been noticeable.
The Penguins’ young players are better prepared to come in and make an impact.
“I just think it speaks volumes to the organization,” Aston-Reese said. “All the guys in Wilkes, when they got called up, they were ready to go.”
15. One byproduct of the infusion of youth has been a healthy competition for bottom-six roster spots.
I like Aston-Reese as a person and think there’s a very good hockey player in there. For whatever reason, I think the Penguins have had a difficult time extracting that thus far this season.
Until Lafferty and Co. came up, it seemed.
Perhaps it’s not directly related. Maybe it’s just finding a line that has clicked or whatever, but it seems like Aston-Reese has been more noticeable the past couple of games.
“It feels pretty good, especially against this team after what happened last game, giving them an easy goal, then not being able to respond,” Aston-Reese said after scoring twice in Winnipeg Sunday and getting some measure of revenge for a turnover he had against the Jets at PPG Paints Arena. “To be able to get those against this team feels pretty good.”
16. I found this quote from Matt Murray interesting after he notched his 100th NHL win.
“It’s really humbling. If you would have told me as a kid that I would have 100 wins in the NHL, I’d be thrilled. I’m feeling very lucky, for sure.”
Murray isn’t always the most expansive in his answers, but I thought this came across as genuine, a milestone that absolutely meant something to him.
Also, Murray could utter three syllables, none of them in English, and it wouldn’t take away from the most important thing here: The dude’s been playing really well thus far. Really quiet game.
Crossing my fingers for Murray-[Marc-Andre] Fleury on Saturday night. It’s long overdue.
17. The Penguins did an absolutely tremendous job for Mike Lange bobblehead night last week. The video was incredible. The ceremony was classy, and I’m glad Lange made a few brief comments; I think people loved it.
Plus, the bobblehead actually looked somewhat like Lange, which was impressive.
18. I’ve said this on social media and probably in this space, too, but it bears repeating: I’m not sure if there’s a better feeling for a kid who grew up here to get to know Lange and how genuinely awesome the guy is.
The same, of course, goes for Steve Blass, Stan Savran, Gene Collier and other guys who are absolute legends, the type of people I grew up idolizing. They’re all incredible, and it never, ever gets old that I get to interact with them on a daily basis.
(I’d also pay good money to sit at Rivers Casino with Lange and Blass; what a trip that would be.)
19. Stat of the week: 96
That’s the number of penalties Brandon Tanev is on pace to draw, as he’s currently tied with Winnipeg’s Nikolaj Ehlers for the NHL lead with seven.
Obviously Tanev isn’t going to draw 96 penalties, but it did get me thinking. Nathan MacKinnon led the league by drawing 48 last season. Tom Wilson had an NHL-high 52 the year before.
Drawing penalties is usually done via speed or being a pain in the neck to play against, and Tanev, to his credit, has been able to combine both.
Also amazing once I fell down this rabbit role: Dustin Brown drew an NHL-high 224 penalties in 240 games from 2007-09. Next closest was Daniel Carcillo, at 185.
20. Non-hockey thought of the week: Spent this past Saturday at my alma mater, Westminster College, for homecoming. First time I had been to one since graduating in 2006, the result of being on the hockey beat.
Had a great time, obviously, but wanted to pass along a terrific restaurant recommendation if you’re ever up that way: North Country Brewery in Slippery Rock. We went a decent amount in college, and the place is just incredible. Beers, wings, all of it. You won’t be disappointed.
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.