The preseason ended on a low note for the Penguins on Saturday night at PPG Paints Arena. In the sixth round of a shootout, Casey Mittelstadt beat Pittsburgh goalie Matt Murray to give Buffalo Sabres a 3-2 victory.

The Penguins led 2-0 mid-way through the second period thanks to goals from Patric Hornqvist and Bryan Rust less than a minute apart.

However, Buffalo answered with a goal of its own at 11:03 in the second, when defenseman Marco Scandella blasted a shot from the left circle. Zemgus Girgensons later tied the score on a breakaway goal to force overtime and set the stage for Mittelstadt’s game-winner.

The Penguins finished the preseason at 2-1-3. The puck drops on the regular season on Thursday at PPG Paints Arena.

Advertise with us

Here are five observations from the preseason finale:

Injuries to Sidney Crosby, Bryan Rust loom large

Sidney Crosby and Bryan Rust, two of the Penguins’ top-six forwards, left Saturday’s exhibition game after blocking shots.

In the seventh minute of the game, Scandella took a shot that hit Crosby on the outside of his right foot. Crosby stayed in the game for about 10 more minutes. He finally went down the tunnel to the dressing room late in the first period and did not return to the bench the rest of the game.

Late in the third period, Rust took a slap shot off of his left hand during a Buffalo 5-on-3 power play. He immediately went to the locker room and did not return.

Advertise with us

“They both got hit with shots,” Sullivan said. “They’re being evaluated now. We’ll probably have more definitive answers in the morning.”

Forward depth and versatility proves critical

Throughout camp, Sullivan has spoken about how he likes the Penguins’ depth and versatility, especially at the forward positions. On Saturday, the Penguins were forced to show it out of necessity.

When Crosby went to the locker room, Jared McCann moved from the third-line left wing to the first-line center. Sullivan said he “actually thought [McCann] had a better game when we moved him to the center.”

“It’s nice to have that luxury when you have natural centers that have the ability to play wing,” Sullivan said. “When you get in a crunch, like this particular game, we have guys who have a comfort level playing at those positions.”

Advertise with us

Meanwhile, Alex Galchenyuk missed his second straight preseason game with a lower-body injury. Dominik Kahun, who played earlier in camp on Crosby’s right wing, showed his flexibility by playing on Evgeni Malkin’s left wing.

New-look penalty-killing unit stands tall

The Penguins’ penalty-killing unit has some new faces this season. Brandon Tanev, who signed with Pittsburgh as a free agent, has jumped right into the top unit. The Penguins have also been trying Nick Bjugstad out on the penalty kill during camp, something he didn’t do last season — or really much at all at the NHL level.

On Saturday, the Penguins were flawless on the penalty kill. All seven of Buffalo’s power play opportunities were snuffed out. The most critical of those moments came late in regulation. Buffalo had a 5-on-3 for 1:32 that Pittsburgh successfully killed off to force overtime.

“I think the guys are doing a good job,” Sullivan said. “They’re starting to grasp the concepts. I think they’re slowly but surely getting better at it and becoming more familiar with how we’re trying to kill. I thought they did a good job tonight.”

Advertise with us

The Penguins have a decision to make with their third pairing

Over the last several practices, the Penguins have rolled out the same defensemen in their top four. Kris Letang and Brian Dumoulin have been skating together as the top pair, while Justin Schultz and Marcus Pettersson have been together as the second pair.

The third pair?

Well, that’s where things get a bit more interesting. During Wednesday’s exhibition game, Erik Gudbranson and Juuso Riikola skated together while prospect John Marino and Jack Johnson sat. But on Saturday, it was flipped with Marino and Johnson taking over the third-pairing responsibilities.

Currently, the Penguins have nine defensemen on their roster. They’ll have to make some decisions soon about that final pairing.

Advertise with us

After a strong camp, Evgeni Malkin’s final preseason game is rather meh

Malkin showed up to training camp looking like a man who had something to prove. For the most part, the leaner, fitter Malkin said and did all the right things throughout the preseason.

Until Saturday.

He committed an awful turnover in the neutral zone late in the third period that forced Murray to stand on his head to keep the score tied. Later in overtime, he threw an unnecessary hip check as he coasted to the bench that resulted in an interference penalty. It was an ill-advised decision to say the least, especially considering the score and the time of the game.

Malkin had no problem scoring last year, tallying a very respectable 72 points. But his turnovers were a career high and his penalty minutes were the second-highest mark of his career. He’ll need to avoid lapses like the ones on Saturday if the Penguins are going to compete for their sixth Cup.

Mike DeFabo: mdefabo@post-gazette.com or on Twitter @MikeDeFabo.