This is the third installment of Penguins primers leading up to the start of training camp on Sept. 13. We’ve already previewed the centers and wingers. Today, we move to the blue line.
When the Penguins open the season Oct. 3, Marcus Pettersson and Justin Schultz very well could team up to form the second defensive pairing. There’s an argument for it. There’s an argument against it. (We’ll analyze both later).
But when it comes to shaping the Penguins’ blue line this season — and beyond — how this duo performs together on the ice is only part of the equation. That’s because both defensemen are dealing with their own separate contract questions.
Pettersson’s issue is the more pressing of the two. Since he came over from Anaheim in the Daniel Sprong trade in December, Pettersson has established himself as a player the Penguins want in the organization long term. When he became a restricted free agent after the season, the Penguins submitted a qualifying offer to retain negotiating rights.
As it stands now, Pettersson is unsigned with just over a week until training camp. Both sides favor a multi-year contract. But the major road block is that the Penguins are up against the salary cap and would need to clear space to get such a deal done.
A trade would be one way to create the space. Or, the Penguins could sign Pettersson to a shorter contract, possibly using the qualifying offer, and attempt to revisit the matter at a later date.
Read More
In the meantime, Schultz’s contract issue isn’t as pressing, but it’s no less significant. He is entering the final season of a three-year contract he signed with the Penguins following a breakout 51-point season in 2016-17. The 29-year-old defenseman will earn $5.5 million this season and could be in line for a raise as an unrestricted free agent.
This leaves the Penguins and Schultz with some decisions to make.
On one hand, Schultz has enjoyed some of his most productive years with the Penguins. Would the right-handed, puck-moving defenseman want to stick around an organization that’s found ways to maximize his skillset? Or would he choose to leave Pittsburgh for what could be a better payday?
On the flip side, could the organization move Schultz this season and get something in return? Or, for a team that’s clearly in win-now mode, do they keep Schultz, maximize the potential for this year and risk losing him for nothing?
As the season unfolds, both contract situations are worth watching.
Speaking of pairings... spread out talent on the back end or form the best possible second pairing?
Atop the depth chart, the first defensive pairing seems clear. Kris Letang’s aggressive, play-making style meshes well with Brian Dumoulin’s stay-at-home approach. No reason to break those two up.
But when it comes to the other two pairings, there are several ways to go.
Coach Mike Sullivan could choose to team up Pettersson and Schultz, as previously mentioned. This would create the most talented second pairing possible. If they’re on the ice together with Evgeni Malkin’s line, they could go a long way toward solving Malkin’s minus-25 number from last season.
But lumping together that talent leaves a less-than-desirable third pairing of Jack Johnson and Erik Gudbranson. The Penguins have expressed their desire to have one puck-mover on every pairing. Johnson and Gudbranson both bring some punch, but neither is necessarily a puck mover.
If the Penguins want to spread out their talent over two lines, the other option would likely be to team left-shooting Pettersson with right-shooting Gudbranson. Left-shooting Johnson and right-shooting Schultz would be the other pairing.
Letang is who he is… one of the best defensemen in the game
Penguins general manager Jim Rutherford raised some eyebrows at the end of the season when he said, “I think our defense is the best now that it’s been since I’ve been here.”
That point can certainly be debated. But no matter how you feel about the Penguins’ defense, one thing is clear: They have one of the NHL’s best defensemen — and he’s coming off one of his best seasons.
Veteran defenseman Kris Letang was named by the NHL Network as one of the league’s top 10 defensemen. Last season, he matched a career high with 16 goals and produced his second-highest point total of his career (56). Only in 2015-16, when Letang posted 67 points and 16 goals, was he more productive.
He’s an aggressive player who isn’t afraid to take chances. This has led to some criticism over the years. Last year, Letang’s ill-advised decision to skate into the teeth of the Islanders’ defense in transition resulted in an odd-man rush the other way and an overtime loss.
Letang’s style is his style. He doesn’t plan to sacrifice his strength by worrying about his weakness.
Can they stay healthy?
Letang has endured a long list of injuries throughout his career. Multiple concussions. A broken toe. Broken foot. Broken hand. An elbow infection. Groin and knee injuries. Numerous unspecified upper- and lower-body injuries. Most notably, he missed several months in the second half of the 2013-14 season after suffering a stroke.
While many of the injuries were out of Letang’s control, he’s missed more than 150 games over the last six seasons.
He’s just one of the Penguins defensemen who has been hampered by injuries in the past. Schultz suffered a gruesome ankle injury that limited him to just 29 games and 15 points last year. And Dumoulin played through a torn posterior cruciate ligament in the postseason.
If the Penguins are hit by another injury or if they want a spark on a given night, a few others could crack the rotation.
Juuso Riikola, a 25-year-old Finnish defenseman, recorded five points in 37 NHL games last year. Chad Ruhwedel (18 games, two points) and Zach Trotman (13 games, four points) could also be options.
Numbers that matter
• $7.25 million: The combined salary of Johnson ($3.25 million) and Gudbranson ($4 million). If these two team up together, that’s a lot of money for the Penguins to dedicate to a not-so-potent third pairing.
• 29: Career NHL fights for Gudbranson. While analytics weren’t friendly to the former No. 3 overall pick, he soon made his presence felt after joining the Penguins at the trade deadline. At 6 foot 5 and 217 pounds, he gives Pittsburgh some muscle on the blue line.
• Six: Times Letang has finished in the top 10 for Norris Trophy voting. Last year, he was sixth. Calgary Flames defenseman Mark Giordano took home the award.
Mike DeFabo: mdefabo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @MikeDeFabo






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.