Sometime Saturday, shortly after the Penguins had picked another 200-plus-pound prospect, a conversation from a couple weeks prior came to mind.
Craig Button, the former Calgary general manager who before that helped build the Dallas team that won a Stanley Cup two decades ago, was giving his thoughts on St. Louis bludgeoning Boston to win it all — and why it would be a bad idea for some other contenders to pivot toward that big, bruising style.
“You can’t start saying, ‘Look at what St. Louis did. We better be like them,’” said Button, who is now an analyst for TSN in Canada. “Every team has its own unique DNA. … I will say this very clearly: Any manager that wants to retool his team based on what happened in recent history is making a massive mistake.”
It’s too early to declare that this is what general manager Jim Rutherford and the Penguins are doing, just because they drafted three power forwards who aren’t expected to be ready to play in the NHL for two, three, four years.
They have already been trending this way a little bit since repeating as champs two years ago, trading a first-rounder for Ryan Reaves; bringing in physical blue liners in Jamie Oleksiak, Jack Johnson and Erik Gudbranson; keeping Garrett Wilson in the lineup last season over guys such as Teddy Blueger and Adam Johnson.
Despite that, the Penguins continued to be a team that often tried to win by blowing by or dangling around defenders, instead of punishing opponents down low on both ends of the rink. When you have top-end creators in Sidney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin, Kris Letang, Jake Guentzel and Phil Kessel, why lean on a heavy game?
Read More
So what are we to make of the Penguins picking three power forwards in a row?
Quebec area scout Luc Gauthier, who watched a lot of first-round pick Samuel Poulin and third-rounder Nathan Legare in the Quebec Major Junior Hockey League, said that character, speed and skill are still the three primary characteristics the Penguins look for in their draft picks. But Gauthier also mentioned the Blues when discussing those two.
“If you look at the Stanley Cup final, the way St. Louis played, Boston played, they’re big, strong, and they skate,” he said. “Both of those guys have those qualities.”
Director of amateur scouting Patrik Allvin suggested that the Penguins just picked the top guys on their board, though in the case of Legare, the team traded a trio of 2019 picks to jump up into the third round to take the sturdy winger.
Maybe that was the case, that the top guys on the board just happened to be large. But there sure seems to be something more to their selections.
Perhaps the Penguins just felt there was a shortage of size within their shallow farm system, so they drafted Poulin, Legare and fifth-rounder Judd Caulfield.
After all, none of the prospects — at any position — they picked in the previous three drafts topped 200 pounds at the time they were picked, though obviously they weren’t finished products physically at age 17, 18, 19. And in the Post-Gazette’s annual ranking of the top 10 prospects in the system, only three weighed more than 200.
Another possibility: The Penguins know they will eventually have to change their style of play in a few years once Crosby and, if they are still playing in Pittsburgh, Malkin and Letang reach their mid-30s. Might they have actually been thinking that far ahead when they took Poulin, Legare and Caufield?
Based on their win-now approach under Rutherford, maybe not.
Let’s circle back to the present. It’s unclear if this draft class says anything about how Rutherford and coach Mike Sullivan want the Penguins to play next season.
The moves they make next — and also the ones they don’t — will tell us that.
Button cautioned that the Penguins, frustrated after getting swept in the first round by a hungrier Islanders team, shouldn’t try to mimic the Blues.
He pointed to the puck-hogging Red Wings teams of the last decade. In 2007, they lost to the big, bruising Ducks. Afterward, then-Ducks GM Brian Burke boasted that going forward, teams would have to play like his to claim the Cup.
“What was Ken Holland going to do? Go and change his team all the sudden because they got beat in a playoff series against the Anaheim Ducks?” Button said.
The Red Wings kept their core and their identity intact and made back-to-back Cup finals. You may recall whom they faced and how those series played out.
Button believes the Penguins need to make tweaks with their personnel. But he feels “the spine of their team” is still “pretty damn good.” And if they stick to being the Penguins instead of trying to be the Blues, they can still win it all again.
“I would suggest that anybody saying that the Penguins aren’t a contender,” Button concluded, “I’d say you better examine what a contender is then.”
Penguins announce camp roster
The Penguins on Monday announced the 41-man roster for their 2019 prospect development camp, and it includes all five of their picks from last week’s draft.
Samuel Poulin, Nathan Legare, Judd Caulfield, Valtteri Puustinen and Santeri Airola will all attend the camp, which runs Wednesday through Friday at UPMC Lemieux Complex in Cranberry.
Calen Addison, the Penguins’ top pick in 2018, and Filip Hallander, drafted 58th overall last year, are among the other invitees.
This year’s camp begins at 1 p.m. Wednesday. The three-on-three tournament is set for 7 p.m. Friday.
For the full camp roster and schedule, click here.
Matt Vensel: mvensel@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mattvensel







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.