The debate has raged in earnest since the moment Washington defenseman Matt Niskanen concussed Sidney Crosby with a brutal cross check in Game 3 of the Eastern Conference semifinals two years ago.
Should the Penguins load up on physical players to protect stars like their captain and fellow center Evgeni Malkin? Or is a team game that prioritizes speed and skill up and down a lineup the path to championships in the modern NHL?
Three of the most celebrated hitters and punchers in club history said Thursday that they fall somewhere in the latter camp.
“I don’t think you need an enforcer these days,” said Matthew Barnaby, who played for the Penguins from 1999 to 2001. “We played in a different era. When I played for Pittsburgh, we had [Mario] Lemieux, we had Jaromir Jagr, [Martin] Straka. We had a plethora of guys that were very talented, but you had to defend them. Now I think it’s more about a team toughness and not backing down, but you don’t need a guy to protect guys, so I think Pittsburgh’s fine that way.”
The former winger was in town along with fellow ex-Penguins Arron Asham and Francois Leroux to tape an “Enforcer’s Night” episode of CBS Sports Network’s “Poker Night in America: Celebrity Home Game” at the Rivers Casino on the North Shore. The episode will air on the network May 23.
The gathering presented a perfect opportunity to discuss where the role fits in the NHL’s landscape and the Penguins’ strategy.
Read More
A few weeks after the Niskanen hit and a second consecutive Stanley Cup victory in 2017, general manager Jim Rutherford acquired winger Ryan Reaves, a celebrated fighter, in a deal with St. Louis. Since then, he’s added the heavyweight presence of defensemen such as Jamie Oleksiak and Erik Gudbranson through trades.
Those moves produced questionable results. Reaves saw little playing time before Rutherford shipped him to Las Vegas in a subsequent deal for center Derick Brassard. Oleksiak was returned to Dallas this past season. And while Gudbranson received good reviews after coming to the team at the trade deadline in March, the group around him never seemed to resolve where he fit into its overall identity.
For that reason, Asham believes it’s important for the Penguins to find some balance in their pursuit of toughness.
“I think there’s always room for a guy to be an enforcer-style player,” Asham said. “Now, there’s not a guy who just goes out there and fights. You have to be able to play the game.
“There’s not really a true super heavyweight like there was five years ago ... those guys are long gone now.”
Among the reasons is that star players tend to do a pretty good job of taking care of themselves.
The Niskanen hit notwithstanding, all three enforcers praised Crosby and Malkin for their awareness and knack for avoiding unnecessary risks for the most part.
“I watch every single game that these guys play,” Barnaby said. “I don’t see them getting taken advantage of on a nightly basis.”
Inconsistency in officiating and the league’s approach to discipline are probably the bigger issues.
Niskanen, for example, was not suspended for the cross check on Crosby, but teammate Tom Wilson was banned for three playoff games last season for delivering a high hit that broke the jaw of Penguins winger Zach Aston-Reese.
Leroux thinks it’s important not to overcompensate, though. He feels inconsistency will always be part of the game, and that the best thing teams like the Penguins can do is make sure they’re fielding rosters that can stand their ground but punish teams on the scoreboard, too.
“If you’ve [got a] guy who can go out there on a regular shift and not be a detriment to your team, that can also bring physicality, I think that’s the key,” he said.
Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.