Jason Mackey: Hi folks. Welcome to my weekly chat. We'll get started here at 1. Just finishing up a story about Matt Murray's potential contract extension. Feel free to fire away now, and I'll be back to answer 'em all in a bit. Thanks.
Steeler Joe: Hey, Jason. Happy offseason! Saw your piece on Malkin--I mean, there's not really a serious chance he gets moved, right? I am with you, that it seems to be more about sending a message to him. At the same time, that's a risky move, isn't it? A petulant star, and you're going to poke at him about his commitment? I feel like there are some real concerns right now with the chemistry of this entire organization, and it's at the heart of the early exit this year and the lackluster regular season. Maybe it starts at the top?
Jason Mackey: Hi Joe. Yeah, I think there's a chance he gets moved. A good one? Probably not based on his no-movement clause and what you would have to get back to feel OK moving a player of his import. But they are legitimately discussing which direction to go -- including breaking up the core. I don't think it's a chemistry issue within the entire organization, but I do think they need to pick a direction and go with it. Also, look at a team like Carolina ... obviously not as skilled, but they have a better idea of who they are and how they want to play. The Penguins need to get back to that, Malkin or not.
Dead Fan: Hey Mackey, are you still listening to the Grateful Dead? I've been listening to some choice nuggs lately to cope with the playoff exit. Mostly stuff from 71-73, because the bass riffs in those days match the tones of my emotions. What are you jamming to when you space out these days?
Jason Mackey: Always listening to the Dead, although I don't space out or anything like that. Just enjoy the tunes. Been a big '89 kick lately, specifically Alpine Valley. As one of my friends likes to say, it's desert island good.
Guest: Will Jack Johnson be back next season?
Read More
Jason Mackey: I think so. The organization isn't as down on Jack as the fan base, believe me. And also, given his lengthy contract, I think it would be tough to move that.
sonics: When does the Seattle Franchise join the league for their first season?
Jason Mackey: 2021-22.
Danimal: If a league of hockey players shout "I quit!", but nobody paid to get into the arena to hear them, do they make a sound?
Jason Mackey: Why would an entire league be in one building at one time?
athletic: Are you sad that you didn't go to the Athletic with Ed and Nesbitt?
Jason Mackey: Not at all. I wish them nothing but they best. They and Sean are great and will remain friends. But I'm extremely happy at the Post-Gazette and proud of what we're doing here.
hockey: I've been gone for a few years, but I remember a while back that you were going to do some research for a chat attendee on Jim Thorpe and whether or not he played hockey. Did you ever get any info on that? Thanks, Jason!
Jason Mackey: And thankful aren't we all. Ha. No, no info. Sorry. Maybe next week.
Jason: What do you think of the Malkin trade? Did we get fair value?
Jason Mackey: The Malkin trade? Did I miss something?
Guest: I get all of the trade Phil talk - but wouldn't he be more valuable to the team to trade at the deadline, rather than now. All teams know his deficiencies but might be more willing to take him on if what they most need for a playoff push is just scoring? Love the chats BTW!
Jason Mackey: I see what you're saying, but I think you might be splitting hairs. Any team that takes on Phil -- then or now -- knows what they're getting. The dude can certainly score and play offense. You're going to have to be willing to live with the rest of the stuff or think you can change. I'm not sure timing changes teams' minds all that much. Thank you for the kinds words on the chats. Glad you enjoy them.
Bobby: Have you done laundry this week? Remember to pack extra underwear for the Arts Fest
Jason Mackey: Just finished. And thank you.
Dirty Troll: For trades involving either Kessel or Malkin, i'd be happy to get draft picks but most importantly, salary cap relief. What say you, big boy?
Jason Mackey: I'm with you on Phil. I think they're going to need it. Plus, they need to do something. It might be a year or two early, but you'd rather do that than a year or two late. Malkin is different. You would need to get premium return, and I just don't see it. Plus, I just don't see how Malkin doesn't retire a Penguin -- pardon the double-negative. That said, given how aggressive Rutherford has seemed about this whole thing, I think it has to be taken seriously, don't you?
The Other Guard: Hi Jason - On a scale of 1-10, 10 being most likely, where do you see a Malkin or Letang deal? I hope GMJR does not make a deal out of frustration(see Carl Hagelin) or just to make one. Thanks Jason!
Jason Mackey: Dealing Hagelin wasn't out of frustration, to be fair. It was more that he felt his team needed something. It also didn't crater the entire season, contrary to what I think some people believe. I'd put a Malkin deal at about a 2. Letang at around a 5, depending on return and whether they believe he can be a little more responsible during key times.
Andrew from Long Island: Does Malkin really get shopped or is this GMJR sending a message?
Jason Mackey: I think it's more than message sending. But I don't think he will ultimately end up getting dealt.
Rick in Orlando: Trade Malkin Letang Kessel Johnson or Hornqvist? If you could get fair value for any of them, I would trade all of them. However the only player I see that happening with is Malkin. What say you?
Jason Mackey: I don't see who would want the Johnson contract. Hornqvist probably, too, given his recent concussion history. If he's healthy, too, I also believe Hornqvist can and will be productive again. I would move on from Phil to free up the money and change the culture a bit.
Willie B.: Just for fun, what might a hypothetical Malkin-to-Florida trade look like?
Jason Mackey: If I was Rutherford, I would want Vince Trocheck to be involved, I know that. Probably Trocheck and some premium picks/prospects. I don't think that would actually happen, but I'm saying where I would start. I think Vince would be a terrific fit in Pittsburgh.
Ron Francis: The majority of GMJR's trades since winning the 2017 Stanley Cup have failed. Moves to acquire Ryans Reaves, Derrick Brassard and Tanner Person and sell Ian Cole, Filip Gustavsson and Carl Hagelin were all mistakes. His batting average has been very low. It's not coincidence that the Penguins have gotten worse. This seems like it would be enough to warrant a change at GM. What more would it take for the Penguins to consider a change?
Jason Mackey: A lot more, Ron. You're also discounting Rutherford acquiring Marcus Pettersson, Jared McCann and Nick Bjugstad during that same time period. Do those count for nothing? I also don't blame Brassard on Rutherford. The thought process was right. There was no way anybody could have predicted he would be such a sourpuss about everything.
Dan Mucy: Hi Jason, happy to talk again! Well, Jim Rutherford has drawn a line in the sand, so to speak. Doesn't he now have to put up or shut up? I'm afraid if he doesn't make big changes, we will be the latest version of the Blackhawks and Kings. Also, glad JR is supporting Sullivan. At some point NHL players gotta stop running coaches out. Keep up the great work, my friend! Dan
Jason Mackey: Thanks, Dan. I do think there's a bit of a line here with Sullivan. Rutherford is backing his coach and seemingly is insisting they listen to him. Good for him. I think Sullivan is a terrific coach, and I think it's absurd that hockey players "tune out" the coach. ... Given what he's said and done with the sizable changes being discussed, yes, I think he has to do something. However, he was probably going to trade Phil all along. If he moves Phil and Olli -- which I think he will -- I think that's enough to follow through.
Dave h: Why did we ever get rid of Tom Kuhnackel?
Jason Mackey: Don't know all the ins and outs, but I know the Pens offered Kuhnhackl a deal he felt was kind of a low-ball offer -- either in years or dollars, can't remember which. Kuhnhackl felt he could get more elsewhere and also achieve more of a prominent role. Penguins couldn't give Kuhnhackl much more, so he moved on.
TortorellaLite AKA MikeSullivan: Not really a question, but just wanted to remind everyone that Letang is terrible and always has been regardless of the PG's beat writers aka Pittsburgh's sport public relations department try to tell us. Hands down the most overrated defenseman in the league.
Jason Mackey: Wow. Funny you bring this up because I took a considerable amount of heat for asking Letang on breakup day if he needed to change his game -- some, and maybe they're right, thought that was borderline insane. My opinion: Letang isn't overrated at all. He's a terrific defenseman, but he does take a few unnecessary gambles. Also takes too may hard hits. A-plus work on the troll job, though: coming into a chat simply to try and insult "the PG's beat writers aka Pittsburgh's sports public relations department." Wish we got double pay for that.
Andrew from Long Island: It pretty obvious some changes need made... Play GM for a day, how would you change these currently constructed penguins...
Jason Mackey: I wouldn't do a ton, honestly. I would move Phil and Olli. I'd try to get another Jared McCann -- a young, energetic, top-six forward. Someone like Micheal Ferland from Carolina I think would fit here. But I wouldn't trade Malkin. I wouldn't trade Letang.
George: Are the Penguins likely to bring back Matt Cullen? if yes what would they do with Blueger(he has proven to be much better a centre than wing).
Jason Mackey: I don't think they're going to bring back Cullen. I also question whether he even wants to play. But Rutherford has already said Blueger will be in the top 12. That basically means the end of the road for Cullen here. One would think anyway.
George: Any chance of Penguins going for PK Subban?
Jason Mackey: That would certainly change things up, but no, I don't see that happening.
George: Who are the Penguins looking at in terms of UFA's if any?
Jason Mackey: I think it's a little early to start seeing names, but I know Micheal Ferland was someone they liked around the trade deadline. Have to imagine he's a possibility in free agency, too.
Southern Penguin: Jason, love your chats and your articles in the PG. From what you and others have written since the sweep there seems to be a consensus that there was a failure of communication or “buy-in” between HCMS and some key members of his team on how he expected them to play and also an issue between GMJR and HCMS on personnel. If those situations are as they’ve been portrayed and not simply an overreaction to the playoff loss is it not incumbent on ownership to step in and more or less demand that everyone start rowing the boat in the same direction?
Jason Mackey: Thank you for the kind words. I don't think Mario and Burkle need to do anything. One, they're hands-off owners to start. If they start meddling now, I don't know if that would play well, nor do they want to. Two, I don't think GMJR and HCMS were that far apart. Do they have stuff to improve upon? Absolutely. They got swept. Everybody has stuff to improve upon. But I don't think there's some sort of gulf between them.
George: What is a realistic return for Phil Kessel, would trading him even be worth it?
Jason Mackey: Return-wise, you're not looking so much at players you get back as you are the cap space created/achieved.
Jason Mackey: And yes, I think you could move Phil.
Andrew from Long Island: Rumors of Murray getting extended.... Def seems like a building block for now and future Penguin teams... Think GMJR would even consider trading him as the return could be potentially huge and play Jarry?
Jason Mackey: Not at all. He's an indispensable part of this team in the GM's mind.
Mark: What is Carolina doing that has the Islanders so baffled? Does this make the Pens issues bigger that expected?
Jason Mackey: I don't know if they're doing anything overly complex, but they are attacking the Islanders the way you need to -- simple, responsible plays, being willing to dump the puck in and not turn it over and giving them freebies. Carolina has been very ... not careful but maybe call it diligent with the puck. It has helped them. And they've converted on their chances. Penguins did not.
Christian: Hi Jason, it’s become apparent that one of the bigger goals of the offseason is to have the players listen to Sullivan. How does the organization begin to accomplish that and do you think they will be successful in this goal?
Jason Mackey: I agree with you that one of the biggest goals has to be for players to listen to Sullivan. And their route of getting them to do that is interesting -- saying they need to listen again instead of just firing the coach, the way other NHL teams probably would. I would imagine that this sort of embarrassment would help. If it doesn't, if they're still stubborn, I'd look at getting new players.

GPT: Jason, have you heard GMJR take any sort of responsibility for making the Pens slower and less talented the past 2 years? He's fired a bunch of shots at the players (some of it deservedly so), but he is the one that has put this roster together.
Jason Mackey: He's made mention that we're in all in this together, but he does not believe speed has played a huge factor ... at least not his team having too little of it. GMJR has framed it more as how they play the game and how quickly they move the puck. He thinks they're fast enough; they just didn't play a fast enough game, if that makes sense.
Stinkpot: Do you foresee any WB/S Penguins moving to the big club next year?
Jason Mackey: I think Ethan Prow will probably get a shot. I don't know if you want to count Juuso Riikola with that group, but he's another one. Also look for Adam Johnson, Sam Lafferty and Anthony Angello to get a long look in training camp, although I think they'll start the season in the AHL.
Christian: Jason, something that I don’t believe that has been talked about enough is how the Penguins could potentially draft an immediate impact player in the first round. From where they are picking in the draft and knowing how deep this draft is how likely do you think that is?
Jason Mackey: I think it's possible, but I don't know if it's likely. If they were in the top five, yeah, I think it's possible. But the first round has about a half-dozen guys who can immediately make the leap. Four of five of those are usually the first guys off the board, then one or two other surprises.
Johnal: Seeing the report from John Shannon that Francis hasn’t outright ruled out a return to hockey management, do you think the Penguins might want his services come July 1st when his deal with Carolina expires?
Jason Mackey: It's been my understanding that Francis has some family ties to the Raleigh area that might preclude him from taking a job where he would have to move. Maybe that has changed. If it has, then yeah, I think Rutherford would love to have Francis. But at one point he did sorta need to stay down there, as I understood things.
Jeff H: JM- I think ppl realize u could never replace 58/71 value to this team and will never get close to trade value back for either of them and the Pens become a much worse team. But Pens must rid themselves of 73- anyway/anyhow.
Jason Mackey: I'm not going to absolve Jack Johnson of blame here, but c'mon, with everything that went wrong with the Penguins this season, we're using trading Jack as the ticket to the promised land? I think there's some unnecessary vitriol being spilled here. He's a third-pairing defenseman.
Christian: Jason, can you see this core, maybe except for Kessel, winning one more cup?
Jason Mackey: Yes, I absolutely can.
Colonel Sanders: What's your favorite flavor of Blizzard at DQ?
Jason Mackey: Love Blizzards. And true story: We always go to Rossi's parents' Dairy Queen. Salted caramel truffle every day of the week, please.
Athletic: "We're coming to get you Barbara" - The Athletic
Jason Mackey: My name's not Barbara, nor will you have much luck.
Jake: Any legitimacy to Malkin being open to being traded to Florida and NYR? Saw it on a rumor site so obviously I have my doubts but you never know as well. Also, with Guentzel’s yearly progression, shouldn’t he be considered one the “untouchables”? He seems to get better every year, he and Crosby have undeniable chemistry, is probably Sid’s best linemate in his time in Pittsburgh.
Jason Mackey: Yeah, I don't see a scenario where Guentzel gets moved. That would be dumb. I could see Malkin being OK with getting moved to Florida or NYR. He lives in Miami. They're supposed to load up. I've seen them linked to Panarin and Bobrovsky. Having another Russian or two in a low-pressure market where you spend your summers? Wouldn't be the worst thing. Also believe that Malkin, along with many NHL players, loves Manhattan. Have a tough time seeing Malkin fit into the Rangers' rebuilding plans, though.
Pens7297: I know this will be brought up far too many times in this chat, but maybe it really is time to let Malkin go. I think people are too hung up on him being a franchise player and whatnot and using that as an excuse for not trading him. I don’t think he’ll ultimately get traded, but why is everyone so hellbent on keeping a moody player who seems to only play well when he wants to play well? People keep saying that it was just a rough year for him, blah blah blah; however, he’s had several rough years in the past and we’ve all seen that he’s capable of flipping a switch and going from meh to WOW in a matter of a game. He didn’t do that this season even after he acknowledged his poor play multiple times. Between that and his attitude, why give him yet another chance when he’s done this time and time again?
Jason Mackey: My argument would be because you don't let someone like Evgeni Malkin go for nothing. I think the Penguins are smart for putting all options on the table. They got their butts kicked. They should look at everything. But think of it from a business perspective: You're selling one of your biggest assets at perhaps its lowest point. Ron Burkle didn't make oodles of money doing stuff like that.
GPT: Is the organization not down on Jack Johnson because they think he's a good player, or because they're still defending his signing? Because if it's the former.....
Jason Mackey: I think it's more that they think he's useful in his role. You might disagree, but they -- from everything any of us has heard -- have no issue with some of his analytics. It's more of an eye-test thing and valuing the person.
Andrew from Long Island: Gets more in a trade.... Phil or Matta
Jason Mackey: Would think Phil, although it might be close.
Cameron: Who’s the most likely player with over 5m cap hit to move? What would you expect return to be ?
Jason Mackey: Kessel. Maybe a couple of draft picks. No first or anything splashy.
Ty: If Kessel approved a trade to Arizona and the Pens were going to send him there, what would you want in return, Jason?
Jason Mackey: Whatever got the deal done. As I've said, I wouldn't get hung up on return. I'd try to get a sense for what Arizona was willing to pay, maybe try to up it a time or two, then simply get the deal done.
Jackattack: The invincible, colossal, stupendous unbeatable Islanders are down 3-0....we are a worse team than we thought. No playoffs next year ot at best 8 seed and 1 and done.
Jason Mackey: You think they should play the games or just cancel 'em since we already know?
Jeff H: 73 MUST GO . 3 will go bc he has trade value - think Lehkonen + 3rd rdr. 72 could go too if the value back is worth it. 81 will go and ppl will be surprised that a point per gm guy has value ???? Think Fiala type winger, a #3-5 LHDman, & 2nd &3rd rd picks. I just think its time to go young legs and build around 87-71-58. What do u think JM?
Jason Mackey: If they trade Jack Johnson, I would think winning the Stanley Cup would only be the start. Next would have to be solving world hunger, eradicating homelessness, who knows? The possibilities are endless.
Jason Mackey: Seriously, yes. I agree with most of what you said -- except for the eagerness to move Jack. In all likelihood, it won't happen. But I would move Phil and Olli and try to get an injection of some youth on the wing.
Dave: Hey Jason! Something I have been meaning to ask your thoughts on. When it comes to the term 'fast team' who actually makes the determination other than the naked eye test? Basically how do you define a fast team and how are they measured? Thanks!
Jason Mackey: It's basically an eye test, although next year, with puck-tracking technology, the hope should be to time how quickly teams are able to get the puck out of their own zone, on average. Once that data is available, truly measuring speed should be easier.
George: Is Matt Cullen likely to be coming back?
Jason Mackey: I'm not expecting Cullen back.
Ty: Why hasn't anyone discussed having Jarry as trade bait? Is he going to waste away in WBS since they just signed DeSmith?
Jason Mackey: Because he had a mediocre year in the AHL. They have him, but Jarry isn't going to carry a deal by himself. He's a sweetener at this point.
Tim C: With the success Carolina has had against the Islanders, do you think it changes the analysis of Pens series with Islanders? Seems to me that Carolina’s success suggests Pens loss was more about intangibles than scheme, speed, etc.
Jason Mackey: I don't know. I don't ascribe Carolina's willingness to play a patient, smart game to the Penguins having more issues than we originally thought. I think the Hurricanes have been willing to play a style the Penguins, for whatever reason, were not.
Cameron: Also - do you expect Wilson to resign either as a 4th liner, WBS’s captain again, or to look for work elsewhere?
Jason Mackey: I think he'll look for work elsewhere. If he doesn't find it, I think the Penguins would be interested in bringing him back as an AHL player. But I think they realized he was probably in over his head being counted upon as an NHL regular.
Hornqvist Fan: Jason, love the Pens chats. How does this team become younger and tougher to play against if you have Kessel, Malkin and Letang on your roster? Granted they won’t move all 3 let alone 2 of these bigger offenders but please this team needs an infusion of better two way players.
Jason Mackey: I think they can be extremely difficult to play against if Malkin and Letang play the way they're capable. If Malkin opens 2019-20 the way he closed 2017-18, they're golden. Letang had a terrific 2018-19 regular season before struggling in the playoffs. There's some recent precedent of them playing terrific hockey; I wouldn't say it's impossible. ... They do need better two-way play, I'll agree there. But I don't think you can confine that criticism to two guys.
dfunk: What is the market for Phil and Olli? Have you heard of any teams that have inquired?
Jason Mackey: It's too early for that sort of stuff to come out.
Casey: Jason, all of Rutherford's moves indicate he wants to get away from the small-and-fast model to a heavier game. Could that be at the core of the issues with the team? The leaders might say the right things, but there must be at least some residual resentment from the players that the GM is essentially forcing them to change a winning style that, I'm guessing, everyone loved to play.
Jason Mackey: I don't think that's the case. You're basically saying that they're not trying because they're pouting over Jim's moves. I can't get on board with that. I think they might have worse players, and some of their best players have failed to produce. But they're not sacrificing their own careers because they're mad at the GM.
Joe: Who would be possible candidates for a Phil trade? I've heard Arizona and Nashville. I know Toronto is paying some salary...would the Penguins be allowed as a 2nd team to cover salary if needed?
Jason Mackey: The salary isn't an issue, and yeah, I would think Arizona and Nashville would be two teams who might have interest. Florida, too. Phil lives down there in the offseason. Low-pressure. They're about to spend some money. Phil might make sense given their strong centers and lack of scoring wings.
bill : I understand the season ended very badly, but.. this idea of trading Letang is crazy to me. There are many times that he seems like the most talented and gifted player on the ice, he can do so many things, why give that up? We've put up with the bad parts of Geno's game for a decade, why not Letang? If you were told you had to give up one of them, who would you give up? I would keep Letang.
Jason Mackey: It would depend on return. I don't think you can make it that black or white, nor do I think it's smart to do that. I agree with you on Letang, though. When he's right, man, he's so absurdly good. And it was a bad playoff, yes. So what? Was he alone? Heck no. The concern for me is more Letang refusing to buy into a more structured approach, which I think the Penguins need to do. If anyone is unwilling to do that, I think they have some problems.
MA: Any thoughts on who (or what position) the Penguins will pick in the first round?
Jason Mackey: I would imagine best player available. They have plenty of room to add premium talent.
GPT: Dumo is decent (not great, but decent), and every other defenseman outside of a 22 year old rookie was terrible this year, and somehow people are clamoring to trade Letang?? Yeah, he made a couple of costly mistakes. That's what happens when you literally have one defenseman capable of skating the puck out of the zone and making a breakout pass to a forward. Unbelievable.
Jason Mackey: I think there's some oversimplification here, but I get what you're saying. And it's certainly not all on Letang. Dude does way more harm than good, and they had way more issues than just the defense.
PGH yinzer: Do u think Pittsburgh media and fans are just spoiled from the Pens? Bc when one of the best athletes in PGH sports history in Letang, who comes back from a stroke, comes back from a career ending type injury.
Jason Mackey: How are we, the media, spoiled by the Pens? Do you think we're writing about these potential moves because we're mad at Letang, Malkin and Kessel for losing? Gimme a break. We're writing about them because people in the organization -- the GM included! -- are talking about them.
Guest: What are the chances of Jacques Martin being snapped up by either Buffalo or Edmonton as a head coach? Do you think Gonch will be here full-time next year?
Jason Mackey: Tough to say on Gonch. Assistants weren't available to us for much of last season, so I can't say I talked to Sergei much. It's a family thing with him, whether he wants to be away for that much time. ... I do think Jacques could go. Ottawa would be my pick there.
Subtlety: Is there an example of another team in the salary cap era who deliberately pushed their best/most talented players out the door in an attempt to shake up the room and actually saw a net short term benefit? (I.e not a Tavares situation where the player basically held all the cards.)
Jason Mackey: There's no example period of a team that has done something that significant in the salary-cap era -- the result good or bad.
Casey: If we're talking UFAs, you have to believe Carl Hagelin gets a second look after the fallout of trading him. The PK tanked, the team slowed to a crawl, it threw two lines out of rhythm, and there was a demonstrable change in Patric Hornqvist when he lost his best friend amidst a very trying season. He had a $4 million hit - can he really expect to get a big raise on top of that?
Jason Mackey: I think he's gonna want a raise, yes. Does he get it? Tough to say. Only takes one. I don't think it makes a bunch of sense for the Penguins to throw gobs of money after Hagelin. Yes, he's fast, but he had, what, five goals? He's already on the wrong side of 30. For that money, they need more youth and finish, IMO.
Guest: I really think Rutherford needs to take on more blame for the teams woes for all of his constant trading and he never seems to blame himself for causing some of this mess .
Jason Mackey: I do think the constant tinkering had an effect on team chemistry.
Respected Gentleman: How come no one has brought up bringing in an emotional support animal for the team? I'd suggest either a Turtle, Cat or by golly, a Penguin itself
Jason Mackey: If the Penguins had their own emotionally support animal ... and it was a penguin ... oh, boy.
Dirty Mike: What grade would you give the Pirates so far, Bill ?
Jason Mackey: I say a B-minus.
Joe: Would an important piece, like a Jared McCann, have to accompany a Kessel or Hornqvist to sweeten the deal?
Jason Mackey: I don't think there's any way they trade McCann.
Guest: Did something in particular happen to cause Malkin to become the “bad seed” ? He’s been find for years. Also the story about the video review incident Malkin isn’t that wrong. They had better defensemen before that could skate it out. Maybe he’s just frustrated with the caliber of talent GMJR is getting for the team. Personally i feel like they should’ve never traded Ian Cole. Can’t replace that heart.
Jason Mackey: I agree with you that trading Ian Cole was a move that did not work. I think they've been trying (unsuccessfully) to replace him ever since. I'm not going to comment on the video story. That's Josh's, he heard it, and I don't have the context. Also wouldn't expect the Athletic to criticize any of our work, and I wouldn't do that to them.
Andrew from Long Island: How long do you think this nucleus can competitively play at a high level?
Jason Mackey: For a couple more years, easily. I can also see Rutherford's thought process where he thinks he might try to maximize return now and try to get younger. But I don't look at this core and say it's over. Not by any stretch.
Guest: Do you think Sid can get thru to malkin Letang and Kessel to change their ways ?
Jason Mackey: I don't think that's Sid's job, and I don't think they need to "change their way." They just need to play a little better and more responsibly. Let's not make the mistake of putting the entire season on those three. I feel that's where this is going.
Badda Boom: Who will the local hockey team select in the 1st round of the 2019 NHL Draft presented by GoodYear Tires? I want names
Jason Mackey: Fruitless endeavor to even try at this point, sorry.
Joe: Why does Madden call you "McK-eye" rather than "Mack-ee?"
Jason Mackey: Not sure. It involves soccer, I believe. He explained it me once, but I forget. He uses it in real life, too. I'm used to it.
Todd: So, the Penguins can't move JJ's contract because nobody would want him (your words), but the Penguins are "happy" with his play. Doesn't that tell you that Rutherford is either dumb or blind to be the only GM to covet him?
Jason Mackey: I don't think so. When Jim signed Jack to a fifth year, I don't think he knew how this past season would go. Also, and I'm sure people are gonna freak out over this, Jack really wasn't the biggest problem the Penguins faced. When everyone played better, we weren't talking about Jack Johnson as much, were we?
Diane Holder: I'm an important person so don't you dare disrespect me and not answer my question. Will the Pens win the Stanley Cup next year?
Jason Mackey: I think we'll have to wait and see.
Subtlety: Because there is no scenario in which a Malkin trade makes the team better in an immediate sense.
Jason Mackey: I tend to agree with you.
Jack : Could Jack Johnson and Maata both be moved. I don’t know if a team would be willing to take on their contracts especially Johnson. I feel like Johnson is like Scuderi, old, can have some good games but slow. Maybe we can trade him for a Trevor Dailey like player.
Jason Mackey: I don't think the Penguins would be against it, but I don't think it's likely, either. Remember, too, that they don't have a ton of guys in the AHL able to come up. Riikola and ...
Wil: Jason - enjoy the chats! How do you think Sid sees the situation? He and Geno seem to have a good relationship, but does Sid see Malkin's performance the same way management does? Where does Sid see the need for improvement? Did he also tune Sullivan out and is immune to criticism, or was there a piece missing from the team which contributed to his performance in the playoffs?
Jason Mackey: I'm sure Sid would like to see Malkin stay, but I'm positive he also understands the business aspect of the situation. I also think he would be realistic as to what his bosses are doing right now -- doing their due diligence with everything. Remember that nothing has been determined. They're only critically assessing everything. I think we're kind of losing sight of that.
Guest: Given Kessel was the best forward in the playoffs and given how the playoffs are playing out this year shows the regular season doesn’t mean much , i would think we need to keep Phil, he knows when to step it up
Jason Mackey: I can see that argument. Why I think it makes sense to trade Phil has nothing to do with whether or not he produced in the playoffs. I think you have to do something, and he's a relatively easy something to do. Also, I worry about his game not aging terribly well. And if they want to get back to playing more of a structured, two-way game, Kessel is certainly an easy fix.
Guest: Who’s the Veteran player the pens get instead of Cully ?
Jason Mackey: I don't think they "have" to have one at all time.
Joe: If they replaced 3 on 3 overtime with...who could pull a baby grand piano from goal line to goal line the fastest, it would be worth it to keep Maatta.
Jason Mackey: I'm scared to learn what happens after two teams pull the baby grand in the same amount of time.
Mark : It wasn’t the coaching that lost it was lack of effort and want to
Jason Mackey: Tend to agree with you, Mark.
Subtlety: If Kessel gets shipped out, do you feel that it will be a James Neal-like return (two lesser players who hypothetically fit the scheme better) or are they looking purely for cap space and draft picks?
Jason Mackey: It's the second option.
Guest: I agree with you on Letang. When he's right, man, he's so absurdly good. And it was a bad playoff, yes. So what? Wanna fight about it?
Jason Mackey: I would not, no.
Rico Fata: Is it too early in the season to turn on my AC? I'm normally a pretty level headed guy but this heat is making me crazy
Jason Mackey: It's also too early in our house, Rico.
Guiseepe: 1st time caller, long time listener. How long have you been in the radio business?
Jason Mackey: About 35 years.
bill : Please explain to me the often heard, poorly defined, vague, intangible assessment that a team "lacks an identity. It's funny how teams that win have an identity and teams that lose don't. The penguins had an identity in March but lost it apparently. What was the Capitals identity last year? Play hard, score timely goals, get big saves, play good defense, be opportunistic? Something tells me this years cup winner will have all those things too. Nonsense. Penguins identity hasn't changed in decades. Some years they play well enough to win it all, some years they don't. Leave me alone with this lacking an identity nonsense.
Jason Mackey: I see what your saying. The vagueness in hockey terms kills me sometimes, too. Play the right way. Get pucks deep. Be hard to play against. What does that mean? ... In this case, though, I think we're saying they needed to have more team speed, needed to attack more and put additional pressure on their opponents, needed to be more resilient and capable of coming back, that sort of thing.
Fan: I can't believe i finally made it on the air. I've always wanted to say this.......Stan.Guy. Love the show
Jason Mackey: Congrats. Big day for you.
Stranded Island: Biggest surprise of the 2nd round? Isles going down 3-0? But Barclays Center is not nearly the same home ice advantage as Nassau is.
Jason Mackey: Very, very true. Hate Barclays. Nassau rocks.
bill : Jason, do the coaches try to play certain defense pairs with certain lines as much as possible or are the rotations totally separate? I would think playing with certain defensemen would help forwards like Geno especially, and perhaps Letang would benefit with more responsible forwards.
Jason Mackey: They do -- when possible. For example, Sullivan has usually preferred to play Letang with Crosby's line. Sometimes that hurts Malkin, as there's obviously an upgrade with Letang. I'm sometimes surprised he doesn't deviate from that more.
Subtlety: The last real penguin they had died of pneumonia.
Jason Mackey: That's too bad.
Southern Penguin: Don’t you think Letang’s somewhat snarky comments after the playoff loss were mostly made out of frustration over how it all went down? I hope he knows that any reasonable fan knows that he and everyone else will make mistakes...they’re human after all. But I would hope after some reflection he’s smart and talented enough to know he has to do everything he can to eliminate the kind of critical mistakes he made against NYI.
Jason Mackey: I'm not sure. I wouldn't call Letang's comments snarky, though. I think he thought I was asking if he needed to change his entire game. That's not what I asked. I had explained more about taking fewer risks. But naturally he's gonna be mad; it's a couple days after their season ended. I don't fault Letang at all. And he's right. It's a game of mistakes. I would never suggest he make none. That's stupid.
Guest: Any word on why Sid isn’t holding his hockey school again this year ?
Jason Mackey: No. I caught that earlier. I was a little surprised. Maybe he's going to re-career and take up baseball.
GPT: What's your take on Bjugstad? Is he a piece moving forward? He is still young and has size, but doesn't seem to use very much and isn't terribly cheap.
Jason Mackey: I think there's more to tap into with him. For that I wouldn't aggressively look to deal him. But if someone called and asked, I wouldn't hang up the phone. Doesn't use his size terribly well. Should produce more goals and points for that price.
Staal Factor: Is this the first time that Jordan has done anything of real significance since he left the Pens? Been a long time coming since the 6th grade picnic, as Mike Lange would say
Jason Mackey: I thought it was the eighth-grade picnic. It's the first time he's been in the playoffs, to be fair.
Casey: Re: Hagelin - I'll put it another way: there is no one on the current roster or in the system that either pushes the pace or plays such a responsible brand of hockey (both of which was visibly lacking in the Islanders series). If we are talking how much certain skills are valued at, I'd really be blown away if Rutherford could balk at $4-4.5 million for Hagelin while handing Johnson his contract (and I'm not in the crowd that thinks Johnson is in any way, shape, form, or fashion to blame for this season).
Jason Mackey: Hagelin had five goals this past season. No way I'm paying $4.5 million per season to someone who had five goals this past season. Rutherford was wrong to trade Hagelin, and Tanner Pearson stunk out loud. But knowingly signing such a lack of finish, for that price, man, no way.
Subtlety: How much of a step forward should we expect next year from McCann and Bjugstad? A nice bump in production would ease some of the pain from a roster transition away from a potential Kessel (or other big) trade.
Jason Mackey: For sure. I think that's a really smart thing to focus on. Quite a bit from McCann, honestly. He should score 20. Should produce more assists, be a regular on the PK, etc. I'd expect Bjugstad to figure out what he is. Third-line center with some physicality? Top-six winger who can score? Setup guy? Finisher? Good defensively? What can you bring. Both have room to take bigger steps, though.
guest: Jus a quick one - any Wilkes Barre Lease renewal updates?
Jason Mackey: Nothing.
Young Rebel: Yeeeeeee-hhawwwwwwwwww it's almost that time of year......Football time in Kentucky!!!!
Jason Mackey: Congrats. Is it ever not football time in Kentucky?
Mick Shrimpton: During Rutherford’s season ending press conference and, seemingly every day, he contacts local media to spout off on Malkin/Kessel. Why has no one in local media asked Jimmy/Sullivan to grade their performance the last 2 seasons? Last I checked, Geno did not ask to trade away top prospects/draft picks for essentially malcontent Brassard? Did Letang negotiate against himself to secure playoff scratch J Johnson to “Scuderiesque” 5 year deal...it was Rutherford...
Jason Mackey: This kills me. Everyone wants Rutherford to "grade his performance." If he does, and he says he stinks, what does this change? Does that undo some of the trades and signings? Rutherford put together a roster that couldn't win a playoff game. That's his grade -- it stunk. He was no better than, what, 17 other teams? That's not good enough. It doesn't mean he should be tarred and feathered, but his grade wasn't good. Asking him to do it himself? What the heck is that gonna solve?
Southern Penguin: What is your plan for frequency of these chats during the off-season? I’ve become accustomed to my weekly dose of Pens news/discussion. Once again, thanks for your efforts to provide thoughtful answered
Jason Mackey: We'll do 'em from time to time. I don't have a set plan. Whenever Penguins are in the news cycle, we'll chat about it. Also around the drat and free agency.
Casey: At this point of the deconstruction of the Cup-winning roster, when does blaming recent shortcomings on the loss of friendships become a viable excuse? For some of the longer tenured Penguins, I assume it must be hard to essentially watch all of your best, longest friends disappear from your life. What kind of impact might this have on the leaders day-to-day efforts?
Jason Mackey: None. They're pros. They knew what they signed up for. If a player can't function because his friend got traded, that guy has way worse problems. Trust me, that wasn't an issue.
BigAl: Down here in South Florida and gotta say Panthers fans are clamoring about getting Malkin. Personally, I think they got fleeced in the deal
Jason Mackey: It's one of the more interesting potential destinations, I agree, but I still don't see anything happening.
Charlotte John: I love Malkin however, living in Charlotte I don't get to watch him everyday like I did in Pittsburgh. With that said, I was shocked to see the drop in skill level. It is like seeing your nephew show up to the house a foot taller than the last time you saw him....but his parents can't see the growth because they were exposed to it everyday. Jason, do you see how badly his skill set diminished?
Jason Mackey: I'm not sure I followed the analogy, John. However, having watched Malkin the entire season and talked to him about this stuff, I think confidence was a huge factor. He was pressing for much of this season. I really don't think it involved his skills diminishing.
pghgolfgirl: What is your take on all of the first round upsets? Overconfidence? League parity? Will and desire? And did you forecast CBJ's buy-in of Torts? He seemed on the ropes most of the season but now the team is really fun to watch. Could we see an all-Metro Eastern Conference Final?
Jason Mackey: It's been really wild. I didn't see this coming at all. And you're right -- I didn't even think of that, an all-Metro final. I think Columbus just goes to show how crazy chemistry can be in the NHL. Remember right after they added those guys, it looked like a gigantic failure. Now, here we are. Funny how those things sometimes take awhile to come together. Like everyone else, I've been completely shocked to see so many top teams lose. I think it proves the parity in the NHL right now is really something else.
GPT: Who knew we'd miss Ian Cole, Ron Hainsey, and Trevor Daley so much? I don't think this team is too far away. But they do need at least one more defenseman that doesn't get hemmed in their own end, which is something those guys did well.
Jason Mackey: I think those guys are great players, yes, but I think you might be trying to find convenient facts. Those guys also had better forward support. I wouldn't ignore this in all of that.
Thanks Jason: Thanks for the chats, Jason! Always a pleasure!
Jason Mackey: Ha. Thank you for participating!
Guest: We missed you Jason ... thanks for chatting today :)
Jason Mackey: I missed it, too. Thank you for participating and making these fun.
Subtlety: What are the chances we’ll ever see a Penguins offseason where people accept the result calmly, with an overall sense that [stuff] happens, they can’t win every year, and they’ve been rather lucky with success all things considered?
Jason Mackey: I have no idea, but what are you supposed to do when this is what the organization is saying on the record? It's not the media running with some sort of narrative. The dude making these decisions is openly talking about it.
2 balls 1 cup: Pens didn't play all that great at home this year. Time to demolish PPG and start again?
Jason Mackey: I'm gonna go with no on that one.
Jason Mackey: OK, folks. That's all the time we have for this week. Thank you, as always, for participating. We'll do this again soon!






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.