The Penguins might be willing to trade Evgeni Malkin, Kris Letang and/or Phil Kessel. That’s been the bombshell of the offseason so far after the story broke in this space last week.
But that’s hardly it. Plenty more has been learned.
Here’s a look at the five biggest takeaways that have come about in the process of learning that the Penguins could look drastically different in 2018-19, starting with the man behind the bench.
1. While other NHL clubs churn through coaches at a crazy clip, general manager Jim Rutherford’s line of thinking appears a little different when it comes to coach Mike Sullivan.
Parse through some of Rutherford’s comments, and it certainly sounds like whoever is in the Penguins dressing room will have to do things the way Sullivan wants them done — or they won’t be there for long.
One example came in an interview early last week:
Read More
“We lost to a good team. But there were lessons to be learned in there, and everybody should have learned those lessons. I would say for people who don’t learn them going forward, as long as they’re still with our team and listening to what the coaches have to say, this is all very fixable.”
The key phrase there is “listening to what the coaches have to say.” Whether we’re talking about preventing short-handed goals or picking the right times to pinch, that didn’t happen nearly as much as Rutherford or other members of Penguins management would’ve liked.
“It’s about the system that the players buy into and being in the right place, giving the defense the right options to get the puck out.”
That was Rutherford on botched breakout attempts, and it says the same thing: There wasn’t enough buy-in to Sullivan’s system.
The third quote worth re-reading involves Rutherford talking about the Islanders and how impressed he was with the job coach Barry Trotz did there.
“The Islanders right from the start did a terrific job. The players bought into it, they got 102 points fair and square, then they beat us in four straight. They have a lot of good things going for them.”
There it is again with the buy-in, something the Penguins seemingly lacked. But it would seem that wasn’t because of a poor or inconsistent message provided by Sullivan. In Rutherford’s eyes, it appears to be mostly on the players.

2. This is not an idle threat.
You don’t shake this sort of stick at a first-ballot Hall of Famer who holds a full no-movement clause. The same goes for Letang and Kessel, who have limited trade protection.
Rutherford isn’t making some sort of statement — other than potentially letting other general managers know he’ll talk — as much as he’s being open and honest when it comes to what he thinks might be best for business.
Regardless of whether you agree with the potential moves or Rutherford speaking so openly about them, given how this season went, they should be examining every possible option. If anything, Rutherford should probably dig deeper.
This also isn’t a trade-just-to-trade scenario. Rutherford and others will have to be convinced that any sort of deal makes the Penguins better in the short and long term. Outside of moving Kessel, good luck with that.
3. Don’t waste time worrying about a potential Matt Murray extension. The two sides will get it done.
In discussing how the Penguins might build for the future and maximize their window of opportunity, Murray has been consistently mentioned in the same breath as Sidney Crosby.
It would be stunning if something did not come to fruition there.
4. None of this has been any easier to take given how the Stanley Cup playoffs have unfolded.
In the Eastern Conference, we’re talking about the top overall seed and both division winners flaming out in the first round. Same thing in the Western.
With Tampa, Washington, Nashville, Calgary and Winnipeg all failing to make the conference semifinals, the Penguins absolutely wasted a golden opportunity. There’s no other way to put it.
5. This wasn’t all bad.
Sure, emotions ran high on locker-cleanout day, and the Penguins didn’t finish in the same ZIP code as their ultimate goal.
But if there’s one thing that will force everyone into an honest assessment of how things are done — how talent’s evaluated, how games are played, the need for more structure — it’s a four-game flameout to a team that won a playoff series for only the second time in many Penguins players’ lifetimes.
No one should be surprised there’s been this big a ripple-effect, and it’s still only the beginning of May.
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.