FORWARDS
Grade: C-.
Really, who didn’t predict that Garrett Wilson would be outscoring Sidney Crosby, Jake Guentzel, Patric Hornqvist, Jared McCann and Bryan Rust combined three games into the series? Aside from everyone, that is. Wilson, a fourth-liner, scored the Penguins’ only goal in Game 3 when he deftly deflected a Marcus Pettersson shot out of the air and past Islanders goalie Robin Lehner for a short-lived 1-0 lead. It was the kind of goal high-end talents like Crosby and Guentzel generally can be counted on to produce, but neither has managed so much as a second assist in this series. Although Crosby got pucks to Guentzel in good scoring positions several times Sunday, the touch that allowed Guentzel to pile up 40 goals during the regular season has deserted him during the past week. While Lehner deserves much praise for his play against the Penguins, they could do a much better job of getting bodies to the net to make his job more difficult and to create — and perhaps, capitalize on — a few rebounds.
DEFENSEMEN
Grade: D+.
New York has a ferocious forecheck, and often has gotten it going by chipping pucks past Penguins defensemen in the neutral zone, then chasing them down. Although the Islanders’ speed and willingness to operate in high-traffic areas can make it tough on any opponent, some of the biggest problems the Penguins’ defensemen had in Game 3 were self-inflicted. Justin Schultz had perhaps the most obvious gaffe when he was guilty of an ill-conceived pinch shortly after New York had tied the score, 1-1, forcing his defense partner, Jack Johnson to face a 2-on-1 break. Brock Nelson capitalized on that odd-man rush — one of quite a few New York enjoyed on the afternoon — beating goalie Matt Murray from inside the right circle for what proved to be the winning goal.
Read More
GOALIE
Grade: C-.
The 1-0 lead that Wilson’s goal gave the Penguins lasted all of 28 seconds, as Jordan Eberle beat Murray from along the goal line to the left of the net even before the Wilson goal was announced to the PPG Paints Arena crowd. Eberle’s shot was brilliantly placed, but Murray left his feet for no apparent reason and, in so doing, exposed the top of the net. After Murray made several stops that kept the Penguins within striking distance, he gave up a back-breaker when Leo Komarov, who had six goals in 82 regular-season games, beat him from below the right dot midway through the third period for a 3-1 lead. Murray hardly bears primary responsibility for the Penguins being one defeat away from the off-season, but he has been decidedly outplayed by Lehner.
SPECIAL TEAMS
Grade: C.
The Penguins had a chance to grab a 1-0 lead when defenseman Adam Pelech was called for hooking midway through the opening period, but failed to generate a shot on goal. Their next two opportunities with the extra man were a little more menacing, but the power play finished the day 0 for 3 to fall to 1 for 8 in the series. Against a stingy defensive team like the Islanders, not exploiting chances with the man-advantage is a serious problem. Penalty-killing has been an issue for much of the season for the Penguins, but actually was a strength in this game, as New York was thwarted on both of its power plays. Matt Cullen, Zach Aston-Reese and Brian Dumoulin did some particularly inspired work while killing New York’s 5-on-3 advantage that lasted for 53 seconds in the middle period.
COACHING
Grade: C.
Mike Sullivan tried everything from a little late lineup maneuvering — McCann was in the starting lineup after not appearing on the 20-man roster the team distributed after warm-ups — to overhauling the makeup of his top three lines, and didn’t get much tangible to show for any of it. Sullivan won his first nine playoff series behind the Penguins’ bench, but his record is about to fall to 9-2 because the Penguins have run into a club that is faster and more fundamentally sound, energized and disciplined than the one Sullivan is directing.
Dave Molinari: Dmolinari@Post-Gazette.com and Twitter @MolinariPG.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.