Kris Letang talks after practice on Saturday at UPMC Lemieux Sports Complex.

Amid all the worrying over who plays and who sits on defense, the Islanders’ heavy forecheck and the traffic they’ve created around the net during a pair of Long Island losses that have the Penguins facing an 0-2 series deficit for the first time in six years, now we have a debate over hockey analytics on our hands.

Beautiful, isn’t it?

When coach Mike Sullivan showed his lines during Saturday’s practice at UPMC Lemieux Sports Complex, the player who was skating to the right of Sidney Crosby generated the biggest discussion point.

It wasn’t Bryan Rust, who began Games 1 and 2 of the Eastern Conference quarterfinals there.

Advertise with us

Nor was it Jared McCann, who apparently visited a witchdoctor or something overnight and hopes to play in Game 3 Sunday after missing Game 2 on Friday.

It also wasn’t Patric Hornqvist, whose hard-nosed style might be the perfect antidote for the physical Islanders.

Sullivan instead went with Dominik Simon, and — admit it — a large number of you freaked the heck out.

Dominik Simon? Doesn’t he have, like, two goals in 40 games?

Well yes, he does, and obviously that’s not good. But as the Penguins are rooting through the couch, tossing cushions aside while looking for the stupid remote control, Sullivan identified what he thinks the Crosby line has been lacking and acted accordingly.

Advertise with us

“We have to have the puck more,” Sullivan said. “When Sid’s line is at its best, they command a lot of offensive-zone time.”

If you frame the debate in this form, it makes sense. Simon might not score, but with those two, is that even necessary? Probably not if Guentzel and Crosby get hot.

But to do that, those two need to have the puck, and a (strong) case could be made that Simon is the top line’s best option for increasing offensive-zone time.

Of the aforementioned options, Simon has helped Guentzel and Crosby produce the best numbers in the following five-on-five stats that quantify puck-possession: shot share (61.4), goals-for percentage (66.7), shot attempts per 60 minutes of ice time (72.8), high-danger chance percentage (69.6) and goals-for per 60 minutes of ice time (5.3).

League-wide, Simon ranked first among all forwards (minimum: 800 minutes) when it came to high-danger chance percentage during five-on-five play (64.01).

Advertise with us

If you want to base line construction on who makes Crosby and Guentzel better from a numbers standpoint, it’s hard to argue with Sullivan’s logic.

“Even though he may not score, usually when his line scores, he’s a part of it,” Sullivan said of Simon. “He’s a guy who’s good in traffic. He’s good in the battle areas. He’s strong on the puck. He’s got a good 200-foot game. He’s sound defensively. And he’s a good playmaker.”

The only problem, though, is that the Penguins aren’t playing a spreadsheet Saturday; they’re hosting the New York Islanders, who’ve made Crosby’s line go through layers upon layers through two games.

During that period, the Penguins’ top trio has combined for 12 five-on-five shot attempts, which is the same as Brian Dumoulin, who missed part of the first period in Game 1 and … well, is a defensive defenseman.

They’ve combined for five high-danger chances in two games and have been on the ice for a pair of goals-against.

Advertise with us

Looking at Crosby specifically, his shot share has dripped from 54.5 during the regular season to 50.8 through two games. His percentage of high-danger chances has taken the biggest hit, dropping from 58.6 to 43.8.

So even though Simon has scored just twice in his past 40 games and one goal in his past 33, Sullivan might not care. If he can help Guentzel and Crosby get something or anything going, it could be worth it.

“He sees the ice well,” Crosby said of Simon. “He holds onto pucks. He’s got a good shot. … He’s really good with the puck.”

Added Guentzel, “He’s a guy who controls the puck and is obviously a really skilled player. Whenever you can play with him, it helps a lot.”

With the threat of elimination looming should they lose again Sunday, the Penguins better hope that Simon can help their top line kick it into gear.

Advertise with us

“Every shift you want to use [the pressure of playing on the top line] as much as you can, create momentum and score goals,” Simon said. “That’s definitely the first focus you have when you’re on that line.”

McCann practices

McCann said he was “optimistic” and “looking to play” Sunday in Game 3 after an upper-body injury kept him out of Game 2 on Friday night.

McCann was a full participant in Saturday’s practice. He took Friday’s morning skate but didn’t feel right closer to puck drop and sat out.

“It was a little bit more of a last-minute thing,” McCann said. “I kinda took an awkward hit [a cross-check from right wing Cal Clutterbuck in Game 1]. It didn’t feel great. I’m feeling a lot better [Saturday] and ready to go.”

Advertise with us

After making his postseason debut Wednesday — he said the speed of the game was the biggest adjustment — McCann’s eager to get playoff game No. 2 on Sunday.

“It was frustrating,” McCann said. “I wanted to be out there and help my team. Not to be able to do that really [stunk]. I’m looking to play [Sunday].”

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.