The Penguins dropped Game 2 of their first-round playoff series against the Islanders by a 3-1 margin Friday night in Uniondale, N.Y. New York now leads the series, two games to none. Here are some initial thoughts on the defeat.
It was over when: New York’s Josh Bailey buried a rebound on the power play to give his team a commanding two-goal lead at the 11:38 mark of the third period. It was too much for the Penguins to overcome on the road against their defensively sound opponent.
Heroes: The Penguins’ penalty killers kept their team in the game as they negated five Islanders power plays in the first 30 or so minutes. One of those power plays was a long 5-on-3, but center Matt Cullen and Co. stood tall to keep the game scoreless through the half way point. Granted, the Islanders aren’t a great team with the man advantage, but you’d expect them to cash in at least one of those opportunities, especially on the two-man advantage. Instead, they failed to even generate a consistent cycle to threaten the Penguins. It was phenomenal work. Of course, the unit did allow Bailey to convert late, but without the early kills, the Penguins would have been out of the game long before.
Goats: Jack Johnson returned to the lineup after missing Game 1 as a healthy scratch, and he responded by promptly taking two penalties in the first period, the second of which was called as the defenseman was skating back to the bench from the penalty box after serving the first minor.
#APRIL12 #PITvsNYI #GM2 1st period
— John Smith (@ThisIsMyReplay) April 13, 2019
Jack Johnson interference on Pelech#Isles PP pic.twitter.com/78pCD02sT8
Probably wasn’t the best way to endear himself to the coaching staff. Fortunately for him, his teammates picked him up and killed both Islanders power plays. (Plus another by Evgeni Malkin for good measure.)
Speaking of Malkin, his turnover midway through the third period led directly to Jordan Eberle’s go-ahead goal.
JORDAN EBERLE BEATS MURRAY WITH A NIFTY BACKHANDER! ISLANDERS LEAD!#Isles 2 - 1 #LetsGoPens
— Hockey Daily #StickTogether (@HockeyDaily365) April 13, 2019
(New York Leads Series 1-0) pic.twitter.com/5HQRdV7VhT
He compounded that error by taking two penalties and registering just two shots in the game. Worse, he was getting into scrums and just generally looked unfocused and frustrated. That plays right into the Islanders’ hands, and the Penguins need more than that from their star if they’re going to get back in this series.
Sidney Crosby, Erik Gudbranson and Patric Hornqvist also took penalties that had the cumulative effect of preventing the team from finding consistent momentum offensively. (Though Gudbranson did account for the team’s only scoring with his first playoff goal in the second period.)
Matt Murray starts strong, fades: Unlike Game 1, when he gave up an early goal plus one that was called back in the first two minutes, the Penguins goalie was sharp from the start Friday. Good thing, because the parade to the penalty box almost required him to be. The game easily could have gotten out of hand without his steady play on the back end so give him credit for bailing his guys out. The downside? He gave up a fat rebound that led directly to Anthony Beauvillier’s equalizer in the second period. That gave the Islanders life after their power play struggles. It’s hard to fault him too much on either of the subsequent goals. Eberle’s was simply a slick play, and Bailey’s came off an unfortunate bounce. Still, you’d like to see him come up with at least one of those plays to keep his team in striking distance — even if the offense wasn’t doing much to give him some margin for error.
Top line quiet — again: The dynamic duo of Crosby and Jakes Guentzel generated just four shots on the evening. They weren’t undisciplined like Malkin was, but the trend is clear through two games: the Islanders’ heavy forecheck is causing problems for this group. It will be interesting to see if they can get better matchups with the last change as the series shifts to Pittsburgh for the next two games.
What they’re saying
Jack Johnson has been....atrocious. 2 penalties and a give away directly in front of Murray
— Andrew (@steelcity320) April 13, 2019
@ Jack Johnson right now pic.twitter.com/4pJojPQ8Q8
— ♡amanda linn♡ (@amandolinn_) April 13, 2019
Undisciplined Malkin as always. He’s so lazy and doesn’t get in trouble for it that’s why he keeps it up. So sad.
— Mike (@miker8771) April 13, 2019
.@penguins pic.twitter.com/FhDdeRaiLt
— Jack Parrish 🌸 (@jparr331) April 13, 2019
Everything the #Penguins are doing just looks hard. Nothing coming easy. #LetsGoPens
— Pens Talk (@PensTalkNHL) April 13, 2019
Next: The series shifts to PPG Paints Arena for Game 3 on Sunday. Faceoff is at high noon.
Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.