FORWARDS

Grade: C-

Sidney Crosby and Jake Guentzel hit major statistical milestones on the Penguins’ final – and possibly most important – goal of the regular season, as Guentzel took a feed from Crosby and chopped in a shot from the right side of the crease at 17:25 of the third period for the goal that forced overtime and secured the Penguins’ first-round playoff match-up with the New York Islanders. That assist was Crosby’s 100th point, making the sixth time he has reached triple-figures in his career.

The forwards, like their teammates on defense, were sloppy and lacked focus for much of the game. Fourth-line winger Garrett Wilson didn’t enhance his chances of getting ice time in the playoffs – or even of retaining his place in the lineup when Zach Aston-Reese is healthy enough to return – by giving the puck away to Brendan Smith in the neutral zone, a turnover that led directly to the first New York goal.

Advertise with us

DEFENSEMEN

Grade: C-

Brian Dumoulin missed his third game in a row because of an unspecified injury, and some of the other defensemen were close to being no-shows, too. The best evidence of that might be that the Penguins blocked only seven shots, and that only three of those were by defensemen. Jack Johnson had two and Olli Maatta one.

Justin Schultz probably saved a goal when he swept a loose puck out of the crease after Murray denied New York defenseman Neal Pionk from the slot about eight minutes into the game, but that was one of the few defensive high points for the Penguins. The good news for coach Mike Sullivan is that, after this performance if Dumoulin is healthy enough to play in Game 1 at Nassau Coliseum, Sullivan won’t have a hard time justifying sitting whichever defenseman he opts to remove from the lineup that night.

GOALIE

Advertise with us

Grade: B-

Matt Murray started for the 20th time in the final 21 games of the season and, for much of the evening, was the primary reason the Penguins looked like a reasonable bet to win the game in regulation. Ultimately, though, he gave up two goals in the final 7:26 of the third period and the game-winner at 2:09 of overtime, when Ryan Strome beat him from the left faceoff dot. Murray finished with 26 saves and was one of the few Penguins who performed well enough to win, but giving up those late-game goals certainly won’t do anything to bolster his confidence as the playoffs begin.

SPECIAL TEAMS

Grade: F+

The Penguins finally came up with a foolproof solution for their penalty-killing woes of late. After allowing a man-advantage goal in each of the previous five games, the Penguins simply didn’t take a penalty, so they never had to deal with any shorthanded issues. Killing penalties effectively is critical during the postseason, though, so that’s something the Penguins figure to focus on during their next few practices.

Advertise with us

They might also want to invest a little time on the power play, which not only failed to score on four tries but gave up a shorthanded goal that allowed New York to take a 3-2 lead with 6:10 to go in regulation. The Penguins allowed 15 of those during the regular season, and that’s a habit they’ll have to break if they want to make more than a cursory appearance in the playoffs.

COACHING

Grade: C

Sullivan presumably made his players aware of what was at stake in this game, but they performed for most of it like it was mid-September, not early April. It’s hard to pin that on the coach, though; he shouldn’t have give a Knute Rockne speech to inspire his personnel when they’re competing for home-ice advantage in a playoff series.

The Penguins lost a challenge in overtime when a Crosby goal 55 seconds into overtime was waved off – the referees ruled that Guentzel had interfered with goalie Alexandar Georgiev, while the Penguins contended that defenseman Brady Skjei had knocked Guentzel into Georgiev – but that was initiated by the NHL’s Situation Room because it happened during the final minute or regulation or overtime.

Dave Molinari: Dmolinari@Post-Gazette.com and Twitter @MolinariPG