Olli Maatta returned to the lineup in Friday’s 3-1 loss to Nashville Predators. And after missing 21 games with a separated shoulder, he was admittedly a little rusty before settling in as the game went on. He was smart with the puck, threw three hits and even got a couple of good looks on Pekka Rinne.

It was pretty standard stuff for Maatta, a steady blue-liner the Penguins trust in many situations.

What was more interesting Friday was whom Maatta was skating with, where that other defenseman was usually – but not always – lined up and what it might mean for the Penguins going forward.

With Kris Letang out with an upper-body injury that may or may not be the same upper-body injury that recently sidelined him for four weeks, the Penguins had to pick between Zach Trotman, a right-hander who has played just 15 games in the NHL over the past three years, and the left-handed Maatta.

Advertise with us

That part was pretty easy. Maatta is a better all-around player, one with a couple of Cups on his resume. But that meant one of the four lefties who suited up Friday had to move over to his weak side.

“It’s not ideal. It’s not what our preference is. But it is what it is,” Penguins coach Mike Sullivan said after the loss. “So we ask ourselves: ‘Who would be the best guy in that circumstance? Which lefty?’”

That lefty ended up being Brian Dumoulin, the rock-solid Mainer who leads the team in plus-minus.

“I thought Dumo was decent on that right side,” Sullivan said. “It’s obviously an adjustment for him.”

It showed. There were a handful of shifts when Dumoulin drifted back to his natural left side as the play went up the ice, leaving Maatta to man the right side when the Predators came the other way.

Advertise with us

Despite that, they defended together reasonably well for having hardly been partnered over the years. They were out for Craig Smith’s fluky first goal on a deflection. It's hard to fault them for that one.

“I think he’s pretty solid. He’s really good to play with. He talks a lot out there. He’s always in a good position,” Maatta said. “I think it’s easy to read off of him, which is a good thing when you’re playing with your D partner. You know what he’s going to do so you can position yourself a little better.”

It’s fair to wonder why Sullivan opted to try Dumoulin on the right instead of Maatta or going back to Jack Johnson, who is better on the left but has played a lot of minutes on the right this season.

Might the Penguins be trying to figure out a contingency plan in case Letang will again be out for a while? After all, this is an odd time to tinker.

Letang’s path back to the lineup was meandering after he was initially hurt during the outdoor game in Philadelphia on Feb. 23. He finally got cleared to return March 19, played three games – and looked a lot like his All-Star self in the process – and then was surprisingly scratched Monday in New York.

Advertise with us

Letang didn’t get back on skates until Friday morning, when he got in a workout before the team took the ice at PPG Paints Arena for the morning skate. He did not stick around for that and Sullivan did not share anything new about Letang’s status when he was asked about Letang before the game.

When asked after the game about the decision to play Dumoulin on the right side, Sullivan said, “Given the circumstance, we’re trying to figure those combinations out so that we’ve got three pairs that can help us.”

He elaborated on Dumoulin specifically, explaining that he has “decent puck skills,” is pretty good in tight spaces and can make a play under pressure. Plus, he gets around OK for someone who is 6-foot-4.

“The biggest thing … is he’s a good skater, so he pivots well, he’s good in traffic and he’s mobile,” he said. “He’s a good skater, and we felt that might help him on that right side more so than other guys.”

As for Maatta, he was happy to get back into the lineup Friday and felt physically fine after, though he wasn’t thrilled about the score. The 24-year-old Finn believed it was a good thing to get it over with a few games left in the regular season instead of returning during the pressure-packed playoffs.

Advertise with us

“Conditioning wasn’t an issue. [The challenge was] just getting your head into the game,” he said. “It’s tough in practice to simulate game situations, so that took a couple of shifts but then I was OK.”

Matt Vensel: mvensel@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mattvensel