Jason Mackey: Hi folks. Welcome to my Thursday chat. Let's do this.
Ericm1212: I hear rumbles letang is out for the year?
Jason Mackey: I have not heard that. I've heard he is dealing with something that keeps creeping up on him. Believe it's the neck, although I don't know if that's specifically related to what he dealt with before. I'm also not a doctor. Much of what I've heard involves optimism that this will go away and things will improve in time for the playoffs.
Michael : When do you see Malkin playing again?
Jason Mackey: My understanding is they expect him to be back for Game 1 of the first round.
jwheaney : Please provide your assessment of Ollie Maataa regarding his speed, skill, toughness, and overall hockey IQ...Thanks!!!
Jason Mackey: I like Olli's game. I don't know about speed, skill or toughness, but he's definitely smart. He cares, too. He's a good person and works at it. Olli is at his best when he's not noticeable, when he's playing positional hockey, making a good first pass and making smart plays with his stick. By nature, he isn't fancy. But he has been extremely reliable. That said, if Letang comes back, I'm sure to see if he fits because they've been better with everyone on their natural side, and I'm not sure they're ready to yank Johnson or Pettersson out. We'll see.
guest: hi jason, sid’s currently six points away from 100 with five games left. will he hit that, especially as he hasn’t made much of a mark on the scoresheet the past few games - which to me doesn’t discount the effort he makes or how much he still helps drives the game it amazed me a little to see pens fans criticising so harshly his lack of points recently, considering how he has carried this team for most of the season. what are your thoughts on these slow past few games though? is something up? and despite his lack of points, what is sid doing that the scoresheet doesn’t show?
Jason Mackey: There are people criticizing Sid right now? I think they need to chill out. My goodness. I think he'll get to 100. I think he actually has a decent shot at being a Selke/Hart finalist, too. Have zero concern these past few games.
Brian: If you could play any major sport what would it be, position & franchise.
Jason Mackey: I guess I'm going to say baseball for the Pirates, although hear me out. I swear I'm not insane. I love baseball. As fun as it is to cover hockey, there's just a different feeling I get when it comes to baseball. And, yes, the Pirates can be frustrating. But it's still home. I couldn't not give it a shot.
Big game: Both eastern and western — what are the playoff match ups?
Jason Mackey: I think there's much to be decided, Big Game. But my pick in the West could be -- as of now -- San Jose and Vegas. In the East, I'll go with Toronto and Boston. Those are probably my safest options. If Penguins-Capitals happens in the opening round, maybe that.
Joe: Should we be worried about letang? Do you think he will be back for playoffs?
Jason Mackey: Yeah, I think it's fair to be concerned at this point. ... I think he'll be back for the playoffs, but I have a tough time thinking he's going to be 100 percent ... or at least no longer dealing with this current thing. Feels like it might be kind of a lingering issue the rest of the way.
BGB: Seeing the avs are doing well.. and so is brassard.. why is he good there and wasn’t here
Jason Mackey: Haven't watched a ton, but my guess would be role. He gets top-six minutes. He's counted upon to score. He wasn't here, and he didn't know how to contribute other ways.
cracker jack: the length of time Kessel has gone without an even-strength goal is mind boggling, but is it mitigated by the fact that he still sets up plenty of goals. Going into the playoffs, do we care how many goals he scores or how many his line scores?
Jason Mackey: I hear what you're saying, and I agree with some of it. Kessel is a very good setup man, can still help the power play, etc. But, geez, he makes $6.8 million (from the Penguins) and doesn't have an even-strength goal in 27 games. That's not picking on Kessel. That just can't happen. In a cap league, you have to have your dollars producing.
Joe: What team do you think would be the best first round playoff matchup for the pens?
Jason Mackey: I'd probably go with Columbus, just based on history. But I also think the Hurricanes would be a good one. Given the Penguins playoff success -- winning nine of their past 10 series -- versus Carolina being new to the whole thing, I like the Penguins' chances.
william: Hey how far do you see the pens going into the playoffs or can they reach the finals or do you think they have a strong defence in order to make that Extremely high intencedy push to it
Jason Mackey: I think they can reach the finals. I see them realistically going to the seventh game of the second round, against Washington. From there, I think it's basically a coin flip. Whoever is getting the bounces, that sort of thing. Could go either way. I can't pick them to get past Tampa at this point.
badger bob: the reason carolina scares me more than the islanders is because they play faster and get many pucks to the net, and although he's been very good, Murray has a tendency to give up bad goals, and that risk goes up with high volume.What do u think?
Jason Mackey: In his career against the Hurricanes, Murray is 6-3-1 with a 1.87 GAA and .943 SV%. I don't know if I agree with your assessment of how he plays against Carolina.
Christian: Hi Jason, what’s your advice for out of towners trying to go to a pens playoff game? Especially since the NHL is late putting the schedule out and there’s often random 2 days off in between games?
Jason Mackey: I would make sure to get into town whenever the team is here and has a game scheduled. I don't know what else advice I can provide. There's a lot of teams and a lot of possibilities and, yes, the schedules come out late. (Imagine having to book travel round-to-round as we do.) Have to be flexible.
Tanger!: What was your favorite moment from this year?
Jason Mackey: Going to Pecan Lodge with Bourque in Dallas was awesome. Also loved my trip to Haight-Ashbury in January. Saw a couple of good friends in my two trips to Raleigh. Oh, you wanted hockey ones? Ha.
Jason Mackey: Cullen's 1,500th was cool, same with 1,000 for Malkin. A lot of the wins blend together, honestly, since it doesn't matter whether the Penguins win or lose. Bjugstad and McCann's first game was neat because it provided such a unique story to tell.
william: I think this team can go along way deep into the playoffs this year
Jason Mackey: I don't disagree with you.
Clementine: When you draft long-form pieces, particularly in the offseason, who makes arrangements for player interviews, the team or you directly with the player? I recall you spent some time up at Cullen's house and was wondering how that meeting arose. I guess you don't ring the doorbell and ask if he has some time.
Jason Mackey: Ha. No, I didn't. Although with Cullen, it may work. It usually depends on the player and relationship. With Cullen, it was easy because there was a relationship there. With Murray, that was a little different because the relationship had not been established as much (it is now), and that went through the team. But yes, I definitely always talk first about what they're OK with, what their expectations are, what mine would be (but obviously deferring to them), etc.
Christian: Jason, from your 20 thoughts GM JR brought up the media’s opinions of Gudbranson and Johnson when they first arrived here. Why is he so bothered by this? He’s been in this league long enough to know that the media’s job is to be fair.
Jason Mackey: Jim is entitled to think however he wants, and I love that he speaks honestly. My argument would be that the local media has not been harsh on either signing. Maybe national guys/girls. Maybe the analytics community. But if we're talking about me, Yohe, Bombulie or Dejan ... have we been overly critical of these deals? I don't think so. Speaking only for myself, I've heard more from readers telling me I haven't been critical enough.
badger bob: do u prefer McCann on Rust with Sid and Guentzel? does it depend on which is better with Kessel?
Jason Mackey: Yeah, I think it depends who's better on that second line. I like them both, honestly. Although I think I might go Rust, at least right now, because it seems more comfortable and effective on his natural side.
JV: Jason, in your time covering the Penguins, which players and coaches have given the most insightful responses? (i.e. not the canned “taking it one game at a time” type of answer). I’d vote Ben Lovejoy as one such player. What others would you say?
Jason Mackey: Yes, Lovejoy was great. Ian Cole was good. Matt Cullen is another who will provide actual insight. Matt Murray can be tremendous -- when he wants to be. Kris Letang, too. Jared McCann and Nick Bjugstad are also very easy to deal with from a media perspective, and Zach Aston-Reese has a lot of potential. These are all guys who will think about your questions and provide honest responses. I love dealing with Crosby, too, because he's incredibly nice. But he usually doesn't want to say too much. Oh, Malkin, too. When he talks, it's usually very good.
Spring: Do you ever see yourself making a change and moving away from writing? If so, what type of job would you like to be doing?
Jason Mackey: No, I don't plan to get away from writing. I love it too much.
Clementine: With the Pens all but assured a playoff spot, would you consider sitting any players to let them rest for a couple games? If so, who?
Jason Mackey: It would depend on whether there's anything to play for. If there's absolutely nothing, sure. I'd sit whomever wants to see. Maybe Sid, Cullen, Malkin (if he's back) ... again, anybody who wants a game. But I think home ice is important, and I think they should try to finish as high as possible.
gary wallin: did anything ever happen to the Ranger who hit McCann in the head? Did the league office ever comment on it? That was super dirty, should be suspended. What about Bertuzzo's hit on Malkin? Anything come of that one?
Jason Mackey: Nothing came of either one. Neither was penalized. No supplemental discipline.
gary wallin: "They'll never win a cup without Letang." I've heard (in fact, I myself said) those words before and was proven wrong. What about this year?
Jason Mackey: I think they can win a Cup without Letang. They have. I don't understand saying a team can't win a Cup without any player. How do you know? You don't.
Ryan: Jason, after our recent play, depth scoring, Murray, etc. do you feel like we are going to be a more effective postseason team than last year where those were major issues for us?
Jason Mackey: We? Are you still asking about the Penguins? ... Just kidding, Ryan. ... I think the Penguins are better positioned this year versus last. I think if they can get the fourth line figured out, they're deeper. And there's a much more upbeat sense in the room. Credit to McCann, Bjugstad and Gudbranson for that.
Austin: If pens ever get a clean bill of health how do you see the lineup shaking out?
Jason Mackey: When everyone's healthy ... two points. Should probably do this once then copy/paste it: Guentzel-Crosby-Rust ... McCann-Malkin-Hornqvist ... Simon-Bjugstad-Kessel ... Blueger-Cullen-ZAR ... Dumoulin-Letang ... Johnson-Schultz ... Pettersson-Gudbranson ... Maatta very close in case somebody gets hurt or struggles.
JohnAl: Are the Penguins planning to have Bjorkqvist turn pro after Providence is eliminated from the Frozen Four?
Jason Mackey: I'm not sure. Scott Young didn't give much in the way of a direct answer. Could be a wait-and-see kinda thing.
Kennywood: Why did the Buffalo Sabres sing the Canadian national anthem when we played there recently?
Jason Mackey: They always do, because it's so close to the border.
Joeco: Does Murry get a rest before the playoffs? Or is the workload manageable and MS rides the hot hand?
Jason Mackey: I think only if they have things locked up. If they can improve, I think HCMS will try to do that and keep playing Murray.
Tanger!: Who's the odd man out when if all the D gets healthy?
Jason Mackey: I would make Maatta reclaim his spot. Although it's easy tomorrow night because I don't think Letang will be ready, and I would go Olli > Trotman.
bill (monroeville): What do u think of the current playoff format?
Jason Mackey: I hate it. I wish they did 1-8.
kevin in Punxsy: I think that GM JR should have traded P Kessel after the great year he had last year. He won't get many offers for PK after this disasterous season. Your thoughts?
Jason Mackey: He listened. You can't crush him for not trading Phil without knowing the offers. It was my understanding that GMJR never got anything that terribly good, hence why he held on to Phil. I think he can and will lower the bar a little bit this summer.
Cosmo K: hiya pal. With only 1 Norris nomination in his career, is Letang a HOF'er?
Jason Mackey: He does have three Cups and has been a hugely successful defenseman ... when healthy. I think it's unfair to say yes or no at this point. Lotta hockey left to play.
copall: In many ways, the Pens have been a better road team this year. In addition, they won the last two times that they faced the President’s Trophy winner in the playoffs. Do you think it matters much where Pittsburgh ends up in the standings as long as they qualify for the postseason?
Jason Mackey: Yep. Just get in the dance. That's all that matters. Matchups are somewhat important, but I think they need to be playing well and keep that momentum going. That's a huge key.
Mike in Kennedy: Does an aging Malkin need to reinvent his game, into something more defensive-minded, like what Crosby, Ovechkin, and Yzerman have done? His -20 is killing the Pens, and makes him no more valuable than a replacement-level player, while making $8m/yr.
Jason Mackey: I think you're a little too hung up on the plus/minus, Mike. It sucks as a stat. If Malkin is playing the way he was before he got hurt, he's fine. They're fine. I also don't think it's as possible to change his game. You would be asking a power hitter to bunt. That's not going to end well.
copall: Feel free to ignore if you have gotten this question already: Assuming that they continue to dominate puck possession as they have, does Sullivan leave the current 3rd line as is when Geno and/or ZAR return?
Jason Mackey: He very well might. Sullivan likes that line a lot. But puck possession or not, those guys need to score.
Hobo Knows: What's the longest you've gone without changing underwear?
Jason Mackey: I change my underwear every day, thank you.
Funny Guy: Pens are going all the way and there's nothing you can do to stop them! Yeah baby! Choo-Choo!
Jason Mackey: Okey doke.
Clementine: Is there any tension between those who went directly into radio (Poni, perhaps) as a career and those such as yourself and Starkey, who went from print to broadcasting?
Jason Mackey: I left print and went to broadcasting? Whoa. No, no tension at all. We're all friends. They're just different mediums. I don't view any as being above or below the others. I guess you do?
Larry in KY: Has Ovechkin missed much time with injuries over the course of his career?
Jason Mackey: No, he has not. Believe Ovechkin has played in over 90 percent of his games.
Brad: The guy that says he sees Brassard is doing well ... he has 3 goals and 0 assists in 15 games. 2 were in his first 4 games. Thats 0.2 goals/game. He had 9 in 40 with the Pens, 0.225 goals/game. Also a -6 over 4 games with the Pens, -6 in 10 games with FLA, & -6 in 15 games with the Avs (weird stat line). Look, I really don't care about Brassard doing well or poorly, I mean sure I hope all the players do well. But lets not pretend he suddenly got worlds better going to the Avs. Pretty much in line with his season this year. Also ice time with the Avs hit 20 min. twice and has been around 14 last few games. 11:33 in his last game.
Jason Mackey: Thanks, Brad. I should have taken the time to vet that out, but I meant what I typed so I went with it: He struggled with his role here, and regardless of the numbers, I'm willing to bet he's a heck of a lot happier there.
JohnAl: Do you think the NFL should allow replay reviews on pass interference calls as well as non-calls?
Jason Mackey: I wish they would scale back replay, not add to it.
Clementine: Do you routinely read the work of other journalists (locally or nationally) and if so, is it sports related or other? And who?
Jason Mackey: I don't read much in-market. Sometimes I do, but I also worry too much ... sometimes if I read DK, the Athletic or the Trib I'll start second-guessing what I'm doing, how I'm doing it, if I'm doing enough. It's nothing against them. I just find I can do better work and be happier if I just stay in my lane and do the best job I can for the P-G.
guest: How has Gudbranson been as an addition to the locker room? Has he added the personality that JR was looking for when he traded for him?
Jason Mackey: Yep, every bit of it. I think he's still fitting in a little bit, but that's natural. They've loved what he's brought off the ice and on it.
guest: I am really happy for Johnson and the turnaround for his season. It seems the detractors have quieted down some. Is he the only D that the pens will play on his "off side" if needed?
Jason Mackey: I think they want to keep him on the left, and I agree. They're trying Dumoulin on his right. I'm not sure how I feel about that.
guest: Hi Jason, was listening to you on 93.7 and you had mentioned that people are hoping the Pens finish second to get NY in playoffs. I think that is crazy. You have to be careful what you wish for. NY's defensive style is built for the playoffs and Trotz knows us well. And if Pens do make it to the second round I want home ice against Caps.
Jason Mackey: Let's be truthful here: I didn't mention that. Chris and Andrew floated it as a possibility. I think it's stupid. Win as many games as you can. If you get a freebie at the end because things are locked up, rest away. But to me, it's more important to be playing well. I hate manipulating matchups.
Bob Nutting: What're your plans for Monday? Lots of good seats available and with your boyish charm, i could see you doing well in Right Field
Jason Mackey: I would love to go, Bob, although I don't know about the boyish charm. Unfortunately I'll be in Detroit.
DB: been 12 years since presidents winner won the cup, why are the lighting different than the last 12 playoff losers?
Jason Mackey: I think so. They've been so dominant, in all facets. I just don't know how you can't take them seriously. (Sorry about all the negatives. ... Bottom line, they're good, and I absolutely think you have to think about them differently for that reason.)
Jo: Going to Nashville this weekend give me some good food suggestions please and thank you!
Jason Mackey: Hattie B's is No. 1
FoolBack: Jason, long term (and I did see your lines above), is McCann a center or a wing? Does it even matter?
Jason Mackey: I honestly don't think it matters. I think they'll switch 'em around as it fits.
Dad: Hey Jason, Malkin has got to pick up the pace here and Hornqvist too. At what point does Sullivan grab their faces and shove them into the messes they constantly create on the ice/floor? This works with my dog fine
Jason Mackey: I hope you don't do that to your dog. How would you like it someone did that to you?
Jason Mackey: OK, folks. That does it for this week. Have some more copy to crank out. Thanks so much for participating. Until next Thursday ...






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.