(After every Penguins home game, the Post-Gazette will assess how each unit performed and what it means during the playoff push.)

FORWARDS

Grade: D.

It’s not unusual for Sidney Crosby to stand out in a given game, but he did it early against the Blues mostly because he seemed far more interested than many of his teammates. Not that Crosby’s effort was reflected on the stat sheet, though, since he and his linemates Jared McCann and Jake Guentzel all finished with a team-worst plus-minus rating of minus-3.

Advertise with us

The forwards were guilty of poor decisions and sloppy execution all over the ice, especially when there was any legitimate suspense about whether the Penguins would be able to earn at least one point for the 10th time in 11 games. Guentzel had a rare off-game, including a failed clearing attempt that led to the second St. Louis goal.

Phil Kessel, whose scoring touch has returned – he had three goals in the previous five games – had a chance to give the Penguins a sliver of hope early in the third period, but missed the net on a breakaway when he had a chance to make it 4-2. Winger Dominik Simon scored his first goal in 21 games, as he beat Blues rookie goalie Jordan Binnington from the inner edge of the right circle, but that goal served only to end Simon’s drought and spoil Binnington’s shutout bid.

DEFENSEMEN

Grade: D.

The defensemen weren’t any better than the centers and wingers, especially early in the game, when few players on the home team seemed to have their legs. Justin Schultz has been outstanding since returning from a broken leg, but didn’t tie up St. Louis winger Pat Maroon in front of the net on the Blues’ third goal, which aborted momentum the Penguins had generated with a strong start to the second period. The defense accounted for just four of the team’s seven blocked shots, with Brian Dumoulin their only player to record two.

Advertise with us

GOALIES

Grade: C.

Coach Mike Sullivan used both of his goalies against the Blues; with the way their teammate performed in front of them at times, he probably wishes he could have played them at the same time. Matt Muray, making his tenth start in 11 games, gave up four goals on 13 shots before giving way to Casey DeSmith at 2:41 of the second period.

While Murray’s personal highlights video for 2018-19 isn’t going to include much footage from this game, he hardly is the biggest reason this game got away from the Penguins. By the time DeSmith got into the game, the only real question was how large St. Louis’ margin of victory would be. DeSmith, coming off a shutout in Buffalo Thursday, stopped 12 of 13 shots. It was a solid showing that might tempt Sullivan to start him again when Philadelphia visits Sunday evening, but going back to Murray, on whom the Penguins will count if they make it into the playoffs, is the most likely (and logical) course of action.

Matt Murray talks after Saturday's 5-1 loss to the Blues

SPECIAL TEAMS

Advertise with us

Grade: C-.

The power play, which was 5-for-8 in the previous two games and generated at least one goal in seven of the previous eight, went 0-for-4. The two most costly failure came during the first half of the opening period, when the Penguins had a chance to counter an Oskar Sundqvist goal that had given St. Louis a 1-0 lead. The Penguins weren’t as bad with the man-advantage as the numbers might suggest, though, as they had good puck movement and pressure on their final three tries. That bodes well for avoiding a slump like the one they endured recently, when the power play was shut out in 12 of 16 games. St. Louis scored on one of its two power plays, getting a rub-it-in goal from defenseman Vince Dunn to close out the scoring at 13:57 of the final period. The Penguins have allowed at least one man-advantage goal in eight of their past 12 games, a trend that could be a serious problem in the playoffs if it persists.

COACHING

Grade: C.

Sullivan has had the Penguins playing some pretty good, consistent hockey lately, but every club has games when it simply comes out flat (and, for the most part, stays that way). History suggested both were a real danger Saturday for the Penguins, who now have given up the first goal in five of their past six afternoon games and are just 1-3-3 in their past seven at home against St. Louis. Sullivan made a good move replacing Murray when he did, sparing him unnecessary exertion in a game that had gotten out of hand and giving him an opportunity to be fairly fresh if he gets the start against Philadelphia.

Dave Molinari: Dmolinari@Post-Gazette.com and Twitter @MolinariPG