(After every Penguins home game, the Post-Gazette will assess how each unit performed and what it means during the playoff push.)

FORWARDS

Grade: C+.

Sidney Crosby wasn’t named the No. 1 star of this game – linemate Jake Guentzel earned that honor with two goals, including the overtime game-winner – but no one had more of an impact. He scored the Penguins’ second goal and set up both of Guentzel’s, including an assist that put Guentzel in alone on Panthers goalie Roberto Luongo for the shot that ended the game. Crosby, who cracked the 1,200-point plateau, has a goal in each of the past five games and probably wishes the Penguins would play Florida a little more often, since he has 12 goals in his past 12 games against the Panthers and has put up two or more points in each of the past five against them. Although Phil Kessel failed to score for the 16th consecutive game, he had a few quality chances and continued his recent trend of putting pucks on goal. He finished with five shots, just one off the team lead. Kessel even got a nice round of applause after one failed attempt during the second period. Another winger suffering through a slump – Dominik Simon, who has gone 15 games without a goal – wasn’t embraced by the crowd that way, but did lead the Penguins with six shots. And while it was easy to overlook, fourth-line winger Garrett Wilson recorded four hits in just 4:50 of ice time.

Advertise with us

DEFENSEMEN

Grade: B.

The Penguins got half of their top pairing back when Brian Dumoulin returned after missing three games because of a concussion. With his usual partner, Kris Letang, still sidelined by an unspecified injury, Dumoulin was paired with Zach Trotman and acquitted himself well. He logged 21 minutes, 42 seconds of ice time and blocked a couple of shots. Justin Schultz continued to anchor the defense corps in Letang’s absence, playing a team-leading 24 minutes, 46 seconds and blocking three shots, most of any Penguins player.

GOALIE

Grade: C+.

Advertise with us

There is an adage that a goalie should be judged not by the shots that he stops, but by the ones he lets in. If so, Matt Murray wouldn’t fare particularly well in the evaluation, because the goal he gave up to Vincent Trocheck late in the second period came on a shot that has to be stopped; Trocheck beat him from the bottom of the left circle to tie the game, 2-2, late in the second period. Murray, who has started five consecutive games for the first time this season, also was beaten on first shot he faced, as Henrik Borgstrom’s shot during a man-advantage appeared to deflect off Penguins defenseman Erik Gudbranson before eluding him. Ultimately, though, Murray made 32 saves, including several quality ones when the outcome was in doubt, to raise his record to 21-10-3.

SPECIAL TEAMS

Grade: B.

Evgeni Malkin took an undisciplined offensive-zone tripping penalty 37 seconds into the game, and Borgstrom scored 68 seconds later to put Florida up, 1-0. Considering that the Penguins had allowed six goals in their previous 16 shorthanded situations, taking totally unnecessary penalties like that one is something they might want to avoid. The Penguins survived two subsequent Panthers’ chances with the extra man, the second of which was set up by another Malkin tripping minor in the offensive end. The Penguins scored on the first of their two opportunities with the extra man, as Crosby threw a Kessel rebound past Luongo to give the Penguins a 2-1 lead midway through the second period.

COACHING

Advertise with us

Grade: C.

Sullivan made a couple of personnel decisions that could have gone either way – sticking with Murray in goal and deciding that Dumoulin was ready to resume contributing – and was rewarded with pretty solid, if not flawless, performances on both counts. Whether Sullivan should be held accountable for the Penguins’ sluggish start is conjecture – it’s not as if his players aren’t aware of the stakes in games at this time of year – but either the Penguins are making a habit of playing down to the level of some lackluster opponents or those teams consistently elevate their games against the Penguins. Regardless of which it is, the Penguins can’t afford to donate many more points to teams looking up at them in the standings.

Dave Molinari: Dmolinari@Post-Gazette.com and Twitter @MolinariPG