1. It’s a perception thing.

That was all Penguins coach Mike Sullivan could figure when tackling the difficult topic of why Sidney Crosby isn’t being talked about more for the Selke Trophy, awarded annually to the NHL’s top defensive forward.

“I think he’s looked upon as an elite offensive player, which he is,” Sullivan said after Monday’s practice. “But what flies under the radar is his overall, 200-foot game.

“When you think about the definition of a Selke candidate or a Selke winner, for me, it’s hard to separate the two.”

Advertise with us

With a little more than a month left in the season, it’s baffling that Crosby hasn’t generated more attention for this award, one of the few accolades the Penguins captain has not received in his NHL career.

I wanted to spent the first half of this week’s column talking about that.

2. First, though, let’s start with this:

I made this head-to-head comparison because Bergeron is the gold standard when it comes to the Selke Trophy.

He’s one of only two four-time winners (Montreal’s Bob Gainey is the other) and occupied the top spot in the Professional Hockey Writers Association’s midseason balloting.

Advertise with us

I also think Sullivan has a pretty unique perspective, having coached both Bergeron and Crosby.

3. As far as this year’s list of Selke candidates, I think we can cross off Los Angeles Kings center Anze Kopitar, who along with Chicago’s Jonathan Toews has been the only other non-Bergeron winner since 2011.

Kopitar is on pace to see his point total drop from 92 to 61, while he’s gone from a plus-21 to minus-6 on the third-worst team in the NHL.

Some would argue that Florida’s Aleksander Barkov would make a fine choice, although the PHWA’s No. 2 midseason selection is currently minus-16 on a non-playoff team and falls well under Bergeron and Crosby when it comes to the underlying/advanced numbers cited in the tweet above.

Mark Stone, now with Vegas, was No. 3 on the midseason ballot, but he’s in the same boat as Barkov. Plus, two-thirds of his work will have been done on a terrible Ottawa team.

Advertise with us

Philadelphia’s Sean Couturier, a Selke candidate last year, has the offensive numbers and fares well with the advanced stuff, but his team might miss the playoffs. I’d also have a tough time arguing against Calgary’s Mikael Backlund (plus-28, best among NHL forwards).

4. But my point here is this: Crosby at least deserves a nomination, if not more.

I’m OK with Bergeron being up there, maybe even winning. He’s tremendous. Couturier and Backlund, too.

But with Crosby, it’s like he’s Cosmo Kramer. He’s been typecast as an elite offensive player — I suppose things could be worse — and nobody wants to see anything else.

“When you look at the complete body of work, there’s no doubt in my mind he’s having a Selke type of year,” Sullivan said. “For me, the perception is that he’s an offensive player, so he’s never in the [Selke] conversation.

Advertise with us

“When the reality is, he should be in the conversation because he’s as good of a defensive player as there is in the league.”

5. Jared McCann has been a Penguin for a little more than a month, since Feb. 1, and has similarly been amazed at reality versus perception when it comes to Crosby, his new linemate.

Everybody talks about the offense and for good reason. But there’s so much more subtlety to Crosby’s game, McCann said.

“I feel like everybody is just used to seeing him being so good offensively,” McCann said. “Everybody is used to seeing the great Sidney Crosby. Everybody is used to seeing certain things with him.

“But as a player coming in from a new organization, you learn to recognize more about him. He blows me away with everything he does. I’m looking around like, ‘What? Did you see that?’ ”

Advertise with us

6. I do think subtlety is one of the tough parts about Crosby’s game to sell to voters.

Watch him every night in person, and you see the corner battles he wins, the little plays he makes with the puck, the effort he brings on every shift, where on the ice he’s willing to go, etc.

Everybody knows Crosby is a great player. But I think you appreciate it even more — and realize there’s more than just offense — when you see it every night.

7. If Crosby doesn’t win the Selke or he’s not among the three finalists — I’d say there’s a 50/50 chance either of those things happen — I think we could point to two reasons … other than stupidity.

One, zone starts.

Advertise with us

Crosby starts just 42.2 percent of his shifts in the defensive zone. Although to compare, Bergeron isn’t much higher at 42.6. Backlund is at 47.6, Couturier 55.5. Nobody is going to weed out Bergeron, but if you’re looking for a reason to put the other two ahead of Crosby, that might be it.

Secondarily, killing penalties, which, in my opinion, is given entirely too much weight in this thing.

The other three average at least 1:36. Crosby — though he’s doing more of it and may have to with Bryan Rust out of the lineup — is a minute below that.

To me, though, that should be small potatoes compared to the bigger picture.

Crosby is on pace for 37 goals and 106 points, easily one of the best offensive seasons of his career and the first time over the 100-point threshold for Crosby since 2013-14. Meanwhile, the past 10 Selke winners have averaged 30 goals and 73 points.

Advertise with us

“When you look at that combination of what he’s accomplished, he’s having one of the best five-on-five seasons of his career,” Sullivan said. “It’s the combination of his ability to defend hard and create offense and score at the other end of the rink. It’s remarkable.”

8. Sullivan isn’t wrong, and it feeds into what might be the most important stat here, which is Crosby’s goals-against per 60 minutes of five-on-five ice time.

It’s 2.0, which is indeed the best of his career.

The past 10 Selke winners have averaged 1.9 in that category; four are above that number, five are below, and one’s right on. This season, among forwards who’ve logged at least 800 five-on-five minutes, Crosby is 16th — better than Couturier (2.76) and tied with Backlund (2.0). (Bergeron has only played 606:49 and sits at 2.47.)

When you also consider that Crosby leads the league in goals for per 60 (4.4) by a pretty wide margin, I don’t know how he’s not considered a legitimate Selke candidate.

Advertise with us

“Because not only is he good defensively and can play against any of the top players in the league, but he can also make them pay at the other end of the rink,” Sullivan said. “I think that’s what separates Sid from the rest of the candidates.

“I don’t think there’s another player in the league that has that combination.”

9. Moving on … sort of.

Crosby might be killing his own candidacy for the Selke, though in a very good way.

Seriously, how do you not consider him for the Hart Trophy if this sort of thing continues?

Advertise with us

Right now, Tampa Bay’s Nikita Kucherov leads the NHL with 106 points and obviously will get some much-deserved recognition.

I think Patrick Kane — who’s third with 40 goals and second with 94 points — has made an interesting case, although I would have a tough time voting a guy for MVP if his team doesn’t make the playoffs (how valuable have you been?). That also should disqualify Edmonton’s Connor McDavid.

Which brings us to Calgary’s Johnny Gaudreau (84 points, fourth) and Crosby (83, tied for the fifth).

Given the poor performances around him — defensively; prolonged slumps for Evgeni Malkin, Phil Kessel and Patric Hornqvist; and inconsistency in goal — if Crosby drags this team into the postseason, I think you have to consider him, don’t you?

10. OK … really moving on

Advertise with us

Had a good chat Monday with Matt Murray, who I thought provided a fairly honest assessment of his season thus far.

“It’s tough to be on your game each and every night,” Murray said. “That’s what I’ve struggled with is finding my consistency. I have to keep working.”

He’s dead-on. Murray has been very good at times. He’s struggled during other stretches. He’s capable, but he needs to be much more consistent for this team to go anywhere.

I give Murray a lot of credit: I don’t know if I’ve ever dealt with a professional athlete more focused on staying in the moment.

In the right setting, most guys will reflect back on a time when they were scuffling or maybe entertain a question about how important, say, the stretch run will be.

Advertise with us

Not Murray.

“It’s a long season,” Murray said. “There’s a lot of ups and downs. That’s part of the game. Just try to learn from everything. That’s the biggest thing. If you can learn from it, you’re going to be better off in the long run.”

11. I thought Sullivan made a pretty big statement when he started Murray in back-to-back games over the weekend.

I think Murray realized what that meant, too — basically that it’s go time — and responded exactly how a coach would want his goaltender to respond.

When I brought that up to Murray, though, he said that’s not where his head’s at.

Advertise with us

“I try not to think about that stuff too much,” Murray said. “It’s not my decision whether I play or not. I just try to be ready for each and every time my name may be called. If it’s not called, I try to have a good practice and get better that way. I try not to think about it.”

12. One funny nugget from our talk …

I brought up to Murray — admitting this probably wouldn’t be possible — that it would be tremendous to watch a game with him or another NHL goaltender and have him pick apart the performance of the guy in net.

There’s so much nuance to the position, and he can be one of the Penguins’ best talkers, when he wants to be. I think it would be fascinating to get inside a goaltender’s head to see what he sees relative to the position.

“I don’t know if you want to get inside my brain,” Murray said with a laugh.

Advertise with us

13. I think we all misjudged the Nick Bjugstad-Jared McCann trade. We might want to start calling it the Jared McCann-Nick Bjugstad trade.

Nothing against Bjugstad, who’s fitting in fine, but what a player McCann has been during his short time here.

More than anything he does well on the ice — and there’s some stiff competition for that — I like his attitude the most. It’s terrific.

He’s incredibly approachable and couldn’t possibly be more excited to be here … which probably isn’t how you’d describe Derick Brassard’s mindset.

McCann, who has six goals in 15 games since the trade, is especially in awe of Crosby.

Advertise with us

“I’m just trying to learn as much from the guy as I possibly can,” McCann said. “He’s a good mentor to have. He’s always talking. He’s open to communicate. I have to listen.”

14. It’s not uncommon for a player’s wife to work. Yes, NHL players make a lot of money, but if you want to keep doing something you’re passionate about, why the heck not, right?

One profession I’ve never heard before, and it kind of made me laugh: Erik Gudbranson’s girlfriend of five years, Sarah Sweetnam, is a dentist.

Yes, a hockey player’s girlfriend is a dentist.

“I know, I know,” Gudbranson said with a laugh when I brought it up Monday.

15. This might be funny in the dressing room, but it’s no laughing matter at home, Gudbranson said.

“We laugh about [getting dental work done] as hockey players, to a certain extent,” Gudbranson said. “She sees it completely differently. She gets heartbroken when guys lose teeth.”

Which is why it’s not optional for Gudbranson to wear a mouth guard … and for him to actually have it in his mouth, as opposed to, say, Teddy Blueger, who chews on his like a piece of gum.

“I’ve been pretty lucky not to lose any [teeth],” Gudbranson said. “I keep knocking on wood when we talk about it.”

16. Gudbranson and Dr. Sweetnam — she’s been practicing for two years — actually met when he was playing for the Florida Panthers and she was in dental school at Nova Southestern in Fort Lauderdale, Fla.

Although Dr. Sweetnam is licensed to practice in the United States and Canada, transferring everything to Pittsburgh might take a little longer because she’s a Canadian citizen.

In the meantime, if you see Gudbranson without his mouth guard in, be sure to make a note of it and point it out on social media. I’m sure his girlfriend will appreciate it.

17. Hopefully you got a chance to read my feature on AT&T SportsNet’s Dan Potash, who’s great at his job and truly one of the best people you could ever meet; seriously, it’s impossible not to love Potash.

Had a few things I couldn’t fit that I thought I would share here.

Did you know that Potash nearly started out calling play-by-play for the Tallahassee Tiger Sharks of the ECHL?

Back when he had a full head of hair — sorry Dan — Potash sent his resume tape to a bunch of TV stations and pro sports teams, figuring whichever hit first, that was the route he should go.

After getting hired at WDTV in Clarksburg, W.Va., Potash got a message from the Tiger Sharks, expressing interest.

“Sometimes I’ll reflect on that and go, ‘What if the TV job didn’t come first and the play-by-play radio job did?’ ” Potash said. “I’ve sort of lived vicariously through Steve Mears, who out of college took a job in Louisiana doing minor league hockey … broadcasting, sales, promotions, the whole deal.”

18. I’ve always loved Potash’s interactions with head coaches … well, OK, Dan Bylsma and Sullivan. Can’t say there was much remarkable about Mike Johnston’s on-camera presence.

With Sullivan, it’s a little different from Bylsma. He’s super intense before games, but he’ll often lighten up a little around Potash, either making fun of Potash’s makeup or something else, perhaps Potash’s readiness (or lack of it) for Sullivan’s media scrum to start.

This started with the Dan and Dan Show, which remains one of the best things ever associated with a professional sports TV broadcast. In our interview, I asked Potash why that was so appealing.

“I think it started with the name,” Potash said. “We also had similar looks, glasses, thinning hair. He just had such a great personality. He really did. I couldn’t be more happy for the success that he had during his time here.

“When we started having bloopers, I asked him, ‘What would you think about us collecting some of the best stuff and showing it on TV?’

“He said, ‘Really?’ I said, ‘Why not? People get kick out of the relationship that we have on camera. Let’s take it to another level.’ He loved it. We still stay in touch. Glad that he’s back in coaching. He’s just a really good dude.”

The pregame interview with the head coach remains one of Potash’s favorite parts of his job.

“I’ve been fortunate that they’ve all wanted to do the interview. Not a lot of coaches will do that,” Potash said. “I don’t see other pregame shows with sit-downs with the head coach before a game. It’s hard to get them to do that, I would think, but they’ve always been open to it.”

19. Number of the week: 2.41

That’s Murray’s goals-against average since Dec. 15, when he returned from his lower-body injury, and it’s eighth in the NHL among goaltenders with 20 or more starts during that stretch.

But here’s why I bring that up: When Murray struggles — and he has — I don’t understand the shoulda-kept-Marc-Andre-Fleury vitriol.

Especially now, when, since that same date, Fleury has fewer wins (16 to 14), a higher goals-against average (2.46) and a worse save percentage (.914 compared to Murray’s .928).

Yes, we’re pulling one (somewhat) arbitrary sample size. But if you’re going to criticize Murray for his inconsistency — which, again, is fair — how does that involve Fleury?

20. Non-hockey Thought of the week: So Pirates pitcher Keone Kela isn’t talking to the media this season.

That’s certainly his prerogative, and it shouldn’t change the way any media member does his or her job.

But for a team with attendance dropping and the gulf between them and the other two pro teams in town only widening, that doesn’t seem like the best strategy.

Fans are already going to have feelings about Jung Ho Kang and his off-field issues. You go into it knowing that, right? There’s also some language-barrier situations, as there would be on any baseball team.

Factor into that middle relievers and bench players — guys fans probably aren’t going to gush over — and how many legitimate impact players do fans have left to really care about, get to know and invest their energy and emotions in?

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.