Jason Mackey: Hi folks. Welcome to my Thursday chat. We'll get underway here shortly before I hit the road to Buffalo.
Randy B: Hi Jason, me again. Is Gudbranson here beyond the rest of this season (and playoffs, if they make it)? There's quite the logjam on the defensive corps going into next year. One of Maatta, Johnson, Gudbranson, Pettersson, and Riikola have got to go.
Jason Mackey: Hi Randy. I think it depends on a lot of things. First and foremost, how well he plays. Also Maatta's shoulder, if anyone will take him, etc. I agree with you, though. Lot of guys. I think they will need to make at least one move there this summer, but it's too hard right now to predict what that will be.
Randy B: Is it true that the Penguins tried to re-acquire Hagelin, but didn't realize they couldn't because they retained salary on him?
Jason Mackey: I have not heard that confirmed from the Penguins side. Only speculation from outside of it. It is a weird rule, though. If they didn't know -- not giving them a pass; they should -- they wouldn't be the only ones, trust me.
pauldia: Hey Jason, Any thought to the P-G Sports doing a live game blog for the Penguins? Competitors do this and as a businessman,I think it could generate interest w ancillary benefits to the P-G and a lot of us enjoy the live interaction? It doesn't have to be done by yourself,just a moderator w maybe you chiming in once in a blue moon??
Read More
Jason Mackey: Hi Pauldia, I would not be opposed to it. I believe DKPittsburghSports.com and The Athletic do it. In saying that, we do things that they don't do, too. Just different business models. But I'm all for more engagement. Let me ask around on it. ... I will say this: It's a little tougher for us because we're putting out a print product. Regardless of whether anyone thinks that's a good idea in 2019, realistically, during a game, I'm formulating a running, print story that must be filed as soon as the game ends; it would be too onerous to do that and a live blog.
Randy B: Is Bjugstad the long-term third line center here? Or does McCann fill that void? To me, McCann looks better as a winger.
Jason Mackey: I would have no problem with McCann in either role. I think we know that McCann is gonna be a part of this team for sure moving forward. Still sort of evaluating on Bjugstad.
LN: Hi Jason, thanks for attaching that line-up tweet in your 20 thoughts! Between the game Saturday and the trade deadline drama, Pens fans needed a good laugh and that was absolutely hilarious!
Jason Mackey: Agreed. That was good stuff.
Randy B: Are Hornqvist's injuries catching up to him? He's 32 and has always played a rough style. Hopefully these last few concussions (sigh) haven't done him in.
Jason Mackey: I don't subscribe to that. He's doing everything he used to do. The puck simply isn't around the net as much when he's being buried on the third line. He has never been a huge driver of his own offense. Needs others.
LN: After the Philly outdoor game I was so mad about that loss. what was the locker room like?
Jason Mackey: It was ... like it always is after a loss. They're not happy, but they do play 82 of these things. They're are going to losses. Bad ones to rivals, too. Nothing extreme, if that's what you're asking.
guest: Shout out to Jack Johnson who just came off 2 great games and really stepped up for the team. I was really disappointed to hear that his tribute at Columbus was booed. I thought Columbus fans were classier than that.
Jason Mackey: I thought it was more of a mixed reaction, but I was not in the building. Matt Vensel had that trip for us.
Hornqvist Fan: Jason, I thought GMJR had it right when he traded for Ryan Reaves. If the league wasn’t going to police itself then the team would need to. Crosby, Letang, Malkin & others have taken way too much abuse over the years from scumbags like Wilson, Simmons, Hartnell, etc. The need to go after the other team’s star player is the only deterrent and that element has been missing from this team all too often. The problem with Reaves was Sullivan’s unwillingness to play him. Funny, Reaves has more goals this year than any Penguin 4th liner. While obviously a different player, Sullivan must find a way to seamlessly fit Gudbranson into his overall team philosophy. Your thoughts? Thanks.
Jason Mackey: I agree with you. They botched the Reaves deal because the coach wouldn't play him. I think Gudbranson is less of a player than Reaves ... or at least was at his future stop. But yeah, for myriad reasons I think it's important to make this thing work.
guest: Reading your recent articles that mentioned that Pens practices and the locker room are quiet and business like is troubling and seems to match their less than spirited/energetic play in some games. I am thinking that the players are just not given a chance to feel comfortable with all the roster turnover (18 trades since last cup) and the constant line shuffling. That cannot be a fun environment to be in and is wearing on the players. I know they are professionals but they are also human.
Jason Mackey: I don't disagree, but that wasn't the point I was making. I'm just saying you need all personalities -- loud, quiet, funny, stoic, smart ass, upbeat. They have most of those boxes checked, but they could use someone on the outgoing/funny/goofy side.
westCoast: Both Malkin & Kessel cant play Defense & are careless with the puck. Dont you think they should not be on the same line?
Jason Mackey: No, I'd keep them together. You need to get Phil going. Best way of doing that is with Malkin. I couldn't care less about their defense if they're scoring. Need to find out how to get Phil to start scoring. And I think they're close.
Hatrick Pornqvist: I believe it was Rupp the other night on TV that compared McCann to Rust - which I think is a good comparison, but I think he has some Guetzel to his game too. What does the team think his ceiling is?
Jason Mackey: I'm not sure they know, but they do think it's high. Dude can skate. Has a good shot. Plays with some bite. I don't know if it's a combination of Rust and Guentzel; I think he's a little different than that, but he's a combination of a few things ... with a terrific attitude to boot. I don't think the team thinks he's anywhere near reaching his ceiling.
Chance : Hi Jason is there any other forwards other then Teddy Blueger that is worthy enough to be called up when needed. It seems they are thin in Wilkes Barre.
Jason Mackey: How dare you speak out against royalty like that. Nobody is as deserving as Teddy. ... Seriously, no. I don't think any of their other guys are realistic options for this season.
Randy B: After the Pens, who are some of your favorite teams/who do you want to see win the Cup?
Jason Mackey: I don't care if the Penguins win the Cup or lose. Misconception about writers there. ... Who do I think has a chance? Tampa, obviously. I think Winnipeg doing it would make for a terrific story. Vegas, too.
New fan: What did Gudbranson mean in your article about the difference in "puck support" between Vancouver and Pitt? Don't understand what that is. And should our whole team take boxing lessons?
Jason Mackey: No on the second part. He means how close his teammates are to the puck carrier and how they work as a unit -- basically having help around on offense and defense, think of it that way.
Christian: Jason, where do you see the Pens finishing? I’m sure you can write an entire piece on this but I wanted to get your thoughts.
Jason Mackey: I see them finishing third in the Metro and playing either the Islanders or Capitals in the first round. I like the Blue Jackets to finish fourth.
Christian: Jason, no pens fan is going to want to see the caps go back to back. Where do you think they finish?
Jason Mackey: I don't see how they get past Tampa in the East.
Cosmo K: What is the estimated profit we should expect from the trade for Gudbranson? What is his Pens #? Thanks
Jason Mackey: *Estimated Prophet
Jason Mackey: Gudbranson will wear No. 44.
JoshK: Did you notice how on that last powerplay, the Pens trying to play it safe with 2 D-men, and Rikkola takes a bad gamble along the near boards on a bouncing puck, leads to odd-man break the other way and almost a shorthanded goal for Atkinson with less than 2 min to play. That was ridiculous!! Where is the hockey IQ? Where is the hockey sense not to gamble in that situation?? I lost confidence in Rikkola after that play. What is he doing? I didn't see anyone comment on that play. Was wondering if you thought the same.
Jason Mackey: I saw what you're talking about, but I don't think making a mistake -- which Riikola did -- is a total damnation of his hockey IQ. He screwed up. He wasn't alone.
Dan Mucy: Hello again, Jason! Great job by all you guys on trade day
Jason Mackey: Thanks, Dan. Appreciate that.
Cosmo K: In the eyes of the world, are the Pens regarded as a serious cup contender if all comes together health/execution wise?
Jason Mackey: I don't know. The postseason has its seasons, its evenings and songs of its own.
JoshK: When Letang and Doumolin return, why break up Shultz and Johnson. That's as good as Johnson's been. Let him play with Shultz. And other pairing should be Petterson and Rikkola/Gudbranson. Even if Maata comes back, don't force him with Shultz if that would undermine Johnson.
Jason Mackey: I agree with you ... at this point. I wrote about this for tomorrow morning -- the Riikola/Schultz pairing. They've been good. But it has been a small sample size. Dumoulin and Letang need to be together. Should have some time to figure out where Olli fits, assuming he's able to make it back.
Dan Mucy: Hi Jason! Great job by all you guys on trade day! I watch these guys and boy can they be frustrating! However, for whatever reason, they seem to come to play when their backs are to the wall. Isn't that a good omen come playoff time? Especially if Murray sets out to prove a lot of us wrong? Thanks...keep up the great work! Dan
Jason Mackey: I think it's the same as it's been, Dan. This team is wildly inconsistent. Great win the other night, but I don't think it means anything until they're able to repeat the process over and over again a few times. I don't doubt the ability is there, especially with Murray. But they haven't been very consistent with the effort and execution this season.
Cosmo K: Is a penalty shot that goes on goal and is saved counted as a shot on goal in the stats? Of course a penalty shot which misses the net and/or doesn't touch the goalie can't count as a shot on goal? I'm running out of shot on goal/off post questions...Darren says keep up the great work, and superb Potash article!
Jason Mackey: Thanks, Darren. I believe it is. Honestly, though, I'm not 100 percent positive. But I believe it is.
Guest: Is Blueger > Simon?
Jason Mackey: I think so.
JoshK: After having watched them for a few games, I suspect that McCann was GMJR target and Bjukstad was the one he had to take rather than the reverse (or am I giving GMJR too much credit?). Haven't been impressed with Bjukstad, he's noticeable bec he's big but nothing particular stands out, likes to shoot, not great along the wall, not great skater, kind of ehhhh, I think I prefer him on the wing, no?..... McCann very different, great skater, noticeable energy, above average shot..... what say you?
Jason Mackey: I think McCann has had a better start to his Penguins career. I think it's too early to make any sort of official determination on the trade.
Guest: Was moving Cole the beginning of this current slide and the problems we are seeing and the bad run of mistakes and hacked fixes? Seems like moving a ‘heart and soul’ personality that is a top 4 defenseman and who is all world at blocking shots is when we saw this reversal begin. That is 100+ more shots that the goalie now sees and that seems like a lot.
Jason Mackey: I don't see moving Cole as having any sort of cataclysmic effect. Derick Brassard was not the right fit. That hurt. But I can't sit here and crush the intent. That was the right move on paper. It should have worked. ... And also, I don't think Ian Cole's shot blocking is why Murray sees more shots. I think they're worse defensively as a group than they were in, say, 2016-17.
Ed: Any update you can provide on the injury front?
Jason Mackey: Club is off/traveling today, Ed. Next we'll know anything is tomorrow morning.
JoshK: I'm actually happy with the top 2 lines. 72 better with Sid and Guentzel. 46 has solidified the second line with Geno and Phil. Rust injury really hurts. Who will now play with Mccann and Bjukstad? Simon? maybe try bleuger there. And I thought the 4th line has been pretty decent too, with Wilson and Cullen, don't love SImon there either. What to do with Simon?
Jason Mackey: JoshK: You've officially asked me more questions than my wife has today. ... I would expect them to use Simon there tomorrow and Blueger on the fourth line. They likely need someone to play the right side on the third line, and Simon has more experience doing that. Plus, Blueger and Wilson were pretty good with Cullen, if you remember.
Pens Fan: So is it a foregone conclusion that the Pens are going to have to trade Jarry this offseason? I think he has an NHL only contract for next year and they'd loose him if they tried to put him back in the minors next year, right?
Jason Mackey: Right. I think that's the most likely scenario, yes, to trade Jarry.
Jeff: It seems the Pens miss having RIck Tocchet on their coaching staff. Less tenacious and get less out of Kessel since he left.
Jason Mackey: I think that's obvious. Tocchet was really good at his job, hence why he was hired as a head coach and has done an excellent job in Arizona. I definitely think they've felt that with Kessel and just with one-on-one conversations with players. That's not a slight toward the current guys, either. I'm just saying that Tocchet was well-liked and respected by pretty much everyone.
Hornqvist Fan: Jason how would you explain this team’s poor defensive play for most of the entire season? Is it simply desire? The team’s overall defense has been horrible. Thanks.
Jason Mackey: I don't think they've been poor defensively "for most of the entire season." I think they've been inconsistent, which means ups AND downs. ... When they struggle, it's often defensemen pinching at the wrong times, allowing odd-man rushes the other way. Of course, goaltending. And also puck management issues that generally occur at their own blue line -- risks not at all worth taking.
Shaun: To me this team's biggest problem right now is a lack of consistent goaltending. Murray just hasn't been good enough this year whether it's injuries, technique, etc. Four defensemen play their guts out in philly only to have Murray blow it with two incredibly weak goals at the end of the game. Do you think there's any hope that he plays better than this or is this what he is at this point in his career?
Jason Mackey: I think he absolutely he can be more consistent he has been lately. He was that way from December-January. Hot take: I don't think he's that far away from rediscovering that form, either.
Mike S: Am I becoming as unpopular among yinzers as that other coach in town? Do I need to remind people that I won two Cups recently? And Sprong still stinks....
Jason Mackey: Hello, Mike. ... I don't think you're becoming unpopular, but I think when your team struggles, it seems to be en vogue to play you. Yet when you win, it has nothing to do with anything you've done. It's a weird dynamic, I'll say. Of the problems your team has, I don't see you ranking very high on the list.
JoshK: Speaking of penalty shots, what do you think of tweaking the rule, that if the player does not score on the penalty shot, then his team gets the 2 min powerplay? but if he scores, then no powerplay.
Jason Mackey: I would not want to see that.
guest: Alot of talk about the inconsistent Pens play. Are most hockey teams outside of a few like Tampa like this? Or are the Pens more inconsistent than most given their level of talent?
Jason Mackey: I think teams are inconsistent in general; they all have bad stretches. I think the concern with the Penguins is that it's gone on this long. They're consistently inconsistent, if that makes sense. And for their talent level, I think it's fair to expect more from them than simple squeaking into the playoffs.
Shaun: Why does Simon still get ice time? Blueger showed more in the few games he played than Simon has shown in several years. I think Blueger is the next surprise Guentzel type and he sits while Simon plays. I don't get it. What gives?
Jason Mackey: The coach likes Simon a lot and thinks he does a lot of things to help them -- that obviously don't involve scoring goals, because he hasn't done much of that. Expecting Blueger to be the next Guentzel is wrong. He's not that type of player. But he should be getting more of a shot than he has thus far.
Joeco: Welcome back Malkin....looked energized last few games. does MS plug Blueger in on that line with Kessel? this weekend?
Jason Mackey: No. That doesn't fit Blueger's game. Plus, ZAR has been very good in that spot.
Mike: Could we see letang this weekend?
Jason Mackey: Doubtful, Mike. With no practice today -- and with the fact that he's not skating -- it would be rare to join the team for Friday's morning skate then play. Not ruling him out, mind you. Just saying it would be a special case.
DanMusic: Please rank who you'd prefer to play in first round - Wash, NYI, CLB. I say 1) NYI 2) CLB 3) WASH. Even though Pens have CLBs and Bobrovsky's number, they have some really good players, scarier than the islanders, IMO.
Jason Mackey: 1. CBJ
2. NYI
3. WSH
DanMusic: Was watching highlights of the Stanley Cup runs. What a player 81 was. Is that the same Phil Kessel we are watching today? If he wasn't wearing the same number, I wouldn't believe it. Oh Phil, what has happened? It's not even just the lack of scoring, it's that he's never even dangerous anymore. Is that Phil gone forever?
Jason Mackey: I don't think so. The Phil Kessel I've watched -- and have actually talked to, if you can believe that -- is struggling mightily with his confidence right now. I think it has gotten better lately, though. He's been more decisive in shooting the puck, which is what they need from him.
Jerry G: I want to say to my sisters and brothers, keep the faith.
Jason Mackey: Thanks, Jer.
Cosmo K: I hope the Pens playoff chances do not fade away as a result of the recent rash of injuries, I was almost expecting a forward or two (maybe 7) logging some D man shifts. Would that ever happen? Kudos to the four who stepped up big in the rain!
Jason Mackey: Things haven't gotten that bad, although I think it could be Cullen if it happens. Hopefully he wouldn't be old and in the way.
Randy B: Have you heard anything from the Pens brass regarding Bellerive or Angello? And how up-to-date are you on the WBS Pens?
Jason Mackey: Pretty up to date. They really like Angello. Lafferty, too. As I understand it, they're both gonna get a solid shot to make the NHL club next season. Have heard less on Bellerive, just because I think he's a little further down, but they certainly like him.
Albert: Hey Jason, don't know if you've got this question yet, but do you think ZAR is a good fit on Geno's line? LOVE these chats btw, thanks for doing them.
Jason Mackey: Thanks, Albert. My pleasure. I've loved the ZAR fit on that line. I think he does a lot of the Hagelin-type stuff -- outside of the skating, of course -- on that line that has helped Malkin and Kessel.
Mrs blueger : Jason. Be a good boy and help a mother out. Where are Simons pics and who are in them ?
Jason Mackey: A question from Teddy Blueger's mom. Never thought I'd see the day.
Mike in MD: Do you think the Pens are really pleased with what McCann has? I am not sure pleasantly surprised is the right word, as they did trade for him, but do you think he is even more than they hoped?
Jason Mackey: They're really pleased, Mike. More than they had hoped? Tough to say because they really, really wanted him. He was likely prioritized over Bjugstad, if you can believe. But they've been incredibly happy with how he's played.
ToddHH : Jason. Would it have been possible to unload Pearson for a pick and just move up Trotman? Wouldn’t that have been a better long term move that taking on another bad contract ?
Jason Mackey: My guess is no, because if they could, I think GMJR would've done it. I think people are overestimating Tanner Pearson's value here. Nothing against him, but opposing teams aren't foreign to the idea that he wasn't doing a blessed thing. Why are they gonna take on that contract for a couple more years for a draft pick?
ToddHH : Jason. Where are u going to be tomorrow around lunch time ? I have an egg to throw at you for that positive JJ tweet
Jason Mackey: Ha. I'll be writing at KeyBank Center. Thankfully protected by security. I'm an idiot, though, I'm aware.
Larry in KY: It seems the Pens are always on the wrong end of the dirty hits these days. The most recent four injuries are all questionable hits. Why won't the league protect the players?
Jason Mackey: This is the NHL, Larry. That ship sailed a long, long time ago.
Cosmo K: Do you think 44 will see PK time? Or is he too slow, kind of like a terrapin (station)? Thanks for the great chats and coverage!
Jason Mackey: Thanks, Cosmo. He might see some, just because of the bodies they have (or don't) back there. Could wind up a Saint of Circumstance.
ToddHH : Jason. U didn’t want to answer this last week and I get that , but what would the ramifications be if the Pens miss the playoffs ? Would moving kessel out be the only likely move ? Does JR get his seat warmed?
Jason Mackey: I don't think I ever got to that question, Todd. I would not have actively ignored it. Or shied away from it. Yes, I think if they don't make the playoffs Kessel will be traded. Heck, I think there's a good chance he will be traded even if they make it. ... I think they'll probably try to move a D, extend Murray ... the rest is kinda tough to say at this point.
guest: Kudos to you Jason for getting that Kessel interview after the game. Did it seem like he needed someone to talk to and get stuff off of his chest? Kessel came across like talking about his struggles would help him get over it.
Jason Mackey: Not even gonna try to get inside Phil's head. He was just sitting there, the crowd swarmed Crosby and I figured what the heck. Kessel generally isn't a fan of talking after games, but he couldn't have been more gracious about the whole thing. I think he knows he hasn't been playing well, it bothers him, and I think he probably figures the fans deserve an explanation. He handled it extremely well. Kudos to him.
Normie: Hi Jason. Excellent piece on Dan Potash. It's nice every once in a while to hear about the periphery surrounding the on ice product. Do you have a feel for which Penguin team we will see over the run up to the Stanley Cup Tournament? The .500 Penguins of the 1st and 3rd quarters or some version of the .762 Penguins we saw in the 2cnd quarter? .762 is going to be tough, but I mean a team that
Jason Mackey: Thanks, Normie. Honestly, people might think I'm nuts, but I think this team has a very good chance of getting hot, kicking it into gear and making a pretty nice little run here.
Cosmo K: You're very clever Jason, and nobody wants to be old and in the way - headed toward the Promised Land...
Jason Mackey: Thanks, Cosmo.
Jimmie: Hey Jason. What do you think of McCann's possibilities? Those two goals were not flukey or gimmies.
Jason Mackey: I think he's been terrific. I think he could be a Nick Bonino-like center who takes what he's given here and turns it into big money. Maybe even like a Pageau type. Skating. Decent offense. Pain the butt to play against. Good in a few different situations.
Shaun: Not to beat a dead horse here, but how do we know what type of player Blueger is yet? Did anyone really see Guentzel becoming a 30 goal guy when he first cracked the lineup? I don't like deciding what type a player a guy is before he's gotten real ice time. I've seen a guy who plays fast, has a good shot, and seems to have good instincts. He scored 3 goals in his first NHL stint on the 4th line. Let's see him play for awhile before we decide he can't be a Guentzel type.
Jason Mackey: Because Guentzel played with top-six guys. He concentrating on scoring. He put up a ton of goals in the minors. Blueger was used differently. He's not as skilled. He projects as a center and excels on the PK. I get your over-arching point, but I think it's tough to put Blueger in the same lane as Guentzel. That's what I was trying to say.
Clark from Virginia : I notice that you and the other sportswriters post articles at all times of the day. Do you have deadlines like newspapers used to or do you post when you finish an article? I imagine the digital age has changed the way things are done.
Jason Mackey: Yeah, we have nightly deadlines. Or I do, anyway. But as far as tweeting things, we do it all the time. In-season, I work off and on pretty much the entire day. The job is a huge part of my life, and thankfully I have a supportive wife who's cool with that. She pushes me as much as my bosses, sometimes more. But in-season, again, we go around the clock ... then have to make sure we file by deadline at night, off of games.
Guest: Why does a team who has 13 players with a ring and a core group that has won 3 cups need a guy because he is "good on the room"? If they need someone to bring some laughs, couldn't you hire a jester or something who doesn't count for $4M against the cap for the next 2+ years?
Jason Mackey: Because these guys are human. Have you ever played a team sport? There are certain elements of putting a group of athletes together, male or female, that are important. You don't just throw a bunch of people in a room, say "Here go do it" and expect no issues. The Penguins are trying to find the right mix.
guest: what poor brave soul moved to the locker on crosby's right?
Jason Mackey: Great question. Honestly, I didn't take note last time at UPMC Lemieux Sports Complex. Do me a favor and ask this again next week.
james: Realistically do they have the cap space to fix the defense for next season? I see this as the #1 issue (if you assume they are sticking with Murray)
Jason Mackey: Yes, they'll be fine cap-wise on D. I wouldn't worry about. However, there's not a ton that needs fixing. Other than, right now, getting healthy.
Cosmo K: Was the Kessel interview referenced earlier on the pg site? Didn't catch that one, sounds interesting...
Jason Mackey: Yes, here's the link: https://www.post-gazette.com/sports/penguins/2019/02/21/Phil-Kessel-ga...
Ed: Jason - Has a player/coach ever taken any of your advice and implement it in some way or fashion?
Jason Mackey: About hockey? How big do you think my ego is that I would go around giving professional hockey players and coaches advice?
Jason Mackey: OK, folks. That's it for this week. Gonna head up to Buffalo now. Thanks for doing this. Talk to you next Thursday!






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.