PHILADELPHIA — Playing Wheel of Fortune blindfolded might be easier than predicting the next move for these Penguins.

One night, they look like they could win the Stanley Cup. The next, it looks like they may miss the postseason.

And with 20 games to go until the end of the regular season, it’s growing more difficult by the day to get a read on this group, which lost its top two defensemen, Kris Letang and Brian Dumoulin, during the same sequence Saturday.

The Penguins’ 4-3 overtime loss to the Flyers in the teams’ Stadium Series game was a lot of things. It was, in a way, a farce, as much of the third period was played in the rain, with players unable to see or do much of anything with the puck.

Advertise with us

It was also typical for these two teams, complete with a parting shot (literally) from arch-nemesis Wayne Simmonds, who figures to change teams soon.

Sidney Crosby reacts to the Penguins' 4-3 OT loss to the Flyers.

Most of all, what transpired inside Lincoln Financial Field was basically a microcosm of the Penguins’ season: Just when you thought you had them figured out … well, guess what? You don’t.

“We had the game under control,” Matt Cullen said. “Tough one to let go.”

This game had many moments to lament, most notably the loss of Dumoulin and Letang, but ranking near the top of the list was Jakub Voracek’s goal at 19:40 of the third period.

After a faceoff, the puck squirted toward the wall, and Voracek threw an innocent shot on net from outside the left circle. It went through Jack Johnson’s legs, Murray never saw it, and the goal forced overtime.

Advertise with us

“That’s on me,” Murray said. ‘I feel like [crap] for that one. We battled hard. Tough conditions. Go down two D, our D did an unbelievable job all night. It [stinks] not to get that extra point, but we played really well and should feel good about ourselves.”

Is Murray right?

In a couple ways, yes. They did do some good things.

Sidney Crosby scored another goal against the Flyers, the 41st for him in 66 career regular-season meetings against them. Evgeni Malkin stayed hot, too, with his fifth goal in five games.

The remaining four defensemen were terrific, too.

Advertise with us

Justin Schultz scored a goal and played 30:02 in his fifth game back from a fractured left leg. Target No. 1 for Penguins fans, Jack Johnson, was very good for much of the night, too, playing a game-high 31:08.

“They’re two tough guys to replace,” Schultz said of Dumoulin and Letang. “They’re two of the more important guys on this team. Losing them early like that wasn’t easy. I thought we did a good job. Our forwards helped us out a lot. Played simple. It’s unfortunate we couldn’t get the win.”

Matt Murray talks about the Penguins' loss to the Flyers

How that happened is why it’s probably tough to be a Penguins fan these days and know how to feel or what to expect. There’s simply no safe time to exhale.

That was certainly the case late in the third period, when this game turned on a dime. With the teams playing four-on-four, Matt Cullen was called for slashing.

“I did not agree with it,” Cullen fumed. “It’s a nothing play. Not a call. Not a call that should be made. One-hundred percent.”

Advertise with us

“That happens every shift,” Patric Hornqvist added.

“It was a weak call, I thought,” Justin Schultz added. “Gave them a chance to get the one there.”

And the Flyers did, as James van Riemsdyk cleaned up the rebound of Voracek’s shot.

But even then, the Penguins should’ve been OK. It was 3-2. Even though the conditions stunk, all they had to do was keep the puck at the other end and not do anything too, too bad.

Yet the Penguins did, allowing Voracek’s goal, the second frustrating one for Murray in his past two starts.

Advertise with us

And in overtime, the Penguins lost yet again in a situation they should dominate … but don’t. Thirteen of their games have advanced past regulation. The Penguins have won just five of them, one in a shootout.

“You have to move by it,” Crosby said. “We have to learn from it.

“This is kind of a playoff feel from here on in for us. Sometimes things like this happen. You learn. You move on. You become that much more desperate and urgent. We have to figure out why it happened, too.”

One reason is certainly the penalty kill, which entered this one having snuffed out just 30 of its previous 44.

Blowing a late lead is not something the Penguins have made a habit of doing this season — they were 26-0-1 when leading after two periods — but this sort of loss, this late, will obviously force them to revaluate some things.

Advertise with us

It’s also tough to escape the prospect of missing Letang and Dumoulin for any length of time.

The Penguins fumed over Simmonds’ hit — “That was straight to the head,” Hornqvist said — but they were equally as mad at allowing what could be a key point slip through their fingers, on a wet night where they were seemingly in control.

Now, as the trade deadline looms and the Penguins must continue to try and figure out who they are, they’re down to 20 games to regain a playoff spot and figure out how to remove the blindfold.

“We just have to embrace this challenge and take each game as it comes,” Sullivan said. “We aren't going to dwell on any one. We have to learn by each experience, move by it and get ready for the next one.”

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.