(After every Penguins home game, the Post-Gazette will assess how each unit performed and what it means during the playoff push.)
FORWARDS
Grade: C-
Carolina goalie Curtis McElhinney is a career backup, but looked like a perennial Vezina Trophy contender while making 23 saves. He set the tone early, with a sprawling stop on Penguins center Jared McCann a few minutes into the game. While the Penguins deserve some blame for not taking advantage of the chances they generated, McElhinney had one of those nights when he could have stopped a gnat in a wind tunnel. Missing Evgeni Malkin for the third game in a row because of an undisclosed injury certainly wasn’t a plus for the Penguins, but considering that he has one goal in his past 10 games, there’s little reason to think Malkin would have been able to solve McElhinney. Especially when there were times that the Hurricanes simply seemed more willing to sweat and sacrifice for the two points.
DEFENSEMEN
Grade: C
Read More
Andrei Svechnikov scorched Juuso Riikola on the fourth Carolina goal, but the outcome had been settled long before that. Carolina’s aggressive forecheck gave the defense trouble at times — making a good first pass was a problem at various points — but all things considered, the defense did a reasonably good job against an opponent that played as if its season was at stake. Kris Letang logged a team-leading 27 minutes, 26 seconds of ice time, but was the only defenseman who wasn’t on the ice for at least one Hurricanes goal and continues to perform at both ends with a confidence that magnifies his talents.
GOALIE
Grade: C-
Matt Murray matched McElhinney save-for-save throughout the opening period — until Carolina’s Jordan Martinook threw a shot toward the net in the final minute. The puck might have glanced off Penguins winger Tanner Pearson, but definitely hit Murray’s glove before ending up in the net 44.7 seconds to go before the intermission. Murray gave up another long-distance goal midway through the second, when defenseman Brett Pesce beat him with a wrist shot from above the left circle. Murray finished with 28 saves on 31 shots (Carolina’s third goal was scored into an empty net) on a night when anything less than perfection wouldn’t have been good enough to pick up at least one point.
SPECIAL TEAMS
Grade: C
The power play was shut out for the sixth time in the past eight games, going 0 for 2. Riikola nearly scored on the Penguins’ only shot the first time they had a man-advantage, and they forced McElhinney to make two stops on their second opportunity. How a group with so much talent can be mired in such a slump remains a mystery. The Hurricanes didn’t fare any better in their two power plays, as the Penguins penalty-killers limited them to one shot. Two newcomers to the short-handed unit, Teddy Blueger and McCann, seem to be fitting in nicely.
COACHING
Grade: C
When it became clear that the Penguins were having trouble getting pucks past McElhinney, Mike Sullivan reconfigured his top line, putting Dominik Simon and Patric Hornqvist with Sidney Crosby and dropping Jake Guentzel and Bryan Rust down to McCann’s line. It was a logical move, especially reuniting Crosby and Hornqvist, but didn’t change anything. Of course, with the way McElhinney was playing, the only way Sullivan might have been able to help his team get a goal would have been to sabotage McElhinney’s equipment or tamper with the contents of his water bottle.
Dave Molinari: Dmolinari@Post-Gazette.com and Twitter @MolinariPG.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.