(After every Penguins home game, the Post-Gazette will assess how each unit performed and what it means during the playoff push.)
FORWARDS
Grade: B-.
The Penguins were opportunistic early in the game, when they scored on three of their first five shots, as Riley Sheahan, Phil Kessel and Sidney Crosby beat Lightning goalie Andrei Vasilevskiy during the first 8:21 of play. One of the most intriguing questions before the game was whether Evgeni Malkin’s plus-minus rating for the season would be lower than the wind-chill factor by the time the evening ended. He picked up a couple of assists (pushing his career total to 601) and was a plus-2 for the game, leaving him minus-18 for 2018-19. Derick Brassard didn’t play because of an unspecified injury, but Teddy Blueger made his NHL debut and acquitted himself well in the middle of the fourth line. While this is a bottom-line business and victories ultimately are all that matters, being held without a shot on goal for a span of nearly 17 minutes during the first and second periods is far from ideal and something the Penguins won’t want to repeat anytime soon.
DEFENSEMEN
Grade: B.
Read More
Kris Letang made a little history and got a goal that might have been more significant than it seemed at first blush, because Tampa Bay had been pushing hard to get back into the game before he scored, then appeared to lose some of its edge after Letang made it 4-0 during the second period. That was his 108th career goal, tying Paul Coffey’s franchise record. Letang also blocked a team-high four shots and contributed five shots and three hits. The defensemen did a reasonably good job of minimizing the number of second-chance opportunities Tampa Bay’s lethal offense generated and Jack Johnson was a physical presence, accounting for eight of the Penguins’ 39 hits.
GOALIE
Grade: B.
Matt Murray rebounded from a disappointing showing during the Penguins’ 6-3 loss to New Jersey Monday with a solid effort, keeping the Lightning off the scoreboard until the final five minutes of play. He lost his shutout bid on a J.T. Miller wrist shot that looked to be stoppable, then was beaten by a Steven Stamkos shot from inside the left circle that glanced off Murray before going under his right arm during a Lightning power play. It helped that Murray’s teammates were more interested and involved than they had been against the Devils, but Murray was sharp from the start and looked increasingly confident until the waning minutes of regulation. It will be interesting to see whether his next start looks more like the first 55 minutes or the final five of the Tampa Bay game.
Matt Murray
SPECIAL TEAMS
Grade: C-.
The Penguins’ No. 1 power-play unit could be dominant if it ever comes close to equaling the sum of its parts, but that seems about as likely as a grove of palm trees sprouting in Point State Park before the weekend. They failed to score a man-advantage goal for the sixth time in the past nine games, and didn’t manage a shot on goal during a five-on-three that lasted 94 seconds. Then again, progress tends to be incremental and they didn’t yield a shorthanded goal, so perhaps that constitutes a tiny step forward. The Lightning had scored on a league-best 29.5 percent of its opportunities during the previous 49 games, so playing a fairly disciplined game that limited Tampa Bay to two chances with the extra man was prudent. (Especially when the Lightning got a goal on the second of those.)
COACHING
Grade: B.
Mike Sullivan shouldn’t have had to do much to motivate his players, considering their miserable performance against New Jersey two nights earlier, but for whatever reason, they got the kind of start that allowed them to take advantage of Tampa Bay playing for the first time since Jan. 19. He also presumably played a role in helping the Penguins rediscover their work ethic during the first intermission, after they had been outshot, 16-5, during the opening period. Bumping Matt Cullen from the fourth line to Brassard’s spot on the No. 3 unit, then plugging Blueger into Cullen’s usual place, was a sound move.
Dave Molinari: Dmolinari@Post-Gazette.com and Twitter @MolinariPG



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.