(After every Penguins home game, the Post-Gazette will assess how each unit performed and what it means during the playoff push.)
FORWARDS
Grade: D+.
Credit Derick Brassard with the play of the game by a Penguins forward. No, not the goal he scored in the second period to briefly give the illusion of the Penguins being back in contention; rather, it was the elbowing major and game misconduct Brassard picked up midway through the third period that allowed him to escape this mess before any of his teammates were able to do so. After winning 13 of 20 faceoffs during the first period, the Penguins went 16-for-45 on draws the rest of the way. Of course, that probably wasn’t as significant as it might seem, since they rarely were able to do anything productive with the puck once they had it, anyway.
DEFENSEMEN
Grade: D.
Read More
Even if he hadn’t been traded to Dallas a few hours before the game, Jamie Oleksiak likely wouldn’t have been in the lineup Monday night, although his physicality might have come in handy against the Devils. As it was, Penguins defensemen routinely failed to prevent New Jersey forwards from operating around – and occasionally, on – goalie Matt Murray. Bad play was compounded more than once by bad decision-making, like when an ill-conceived clearing attempt by Brian Dumoulin was picked off by New Jersey defenseman Andy Greene, who promptly set up Pavel Zacha for the Devils’ final goal.
GOALIE
Grade: D.
Matt Murray, who was 10-1 in his previous 11 starts, looked sharp early in the game, as he was anticipating shots and moving laterally well. And while he couldn’t be faulted on New Jersey’s first goal – Blake Coleman of the Devils and Penguins center Matt Cullen had him completely screened when Travis Zajac wristed a shot into the net from the top of the left circle – he bore sole responsibility for the one that followed. Murray had a clear look at defenseman Damon Severson’s wrist shot from about 45 feet out in the slot, but the puck glanced off his glove and fluttered into the net. Although Murray is 6 feet 4, he looked a whole lot smaller at numerous points in the game.
SPECIAL TEAMS
Grade: D-.
The Penguins failed to score on five tries with the extra man, and that wasn’t even the low point of the evening for their power play. Not even close, really. Rather, it reached its nadir 3 ½ minutes into the second period, when Pavel Zacha of the Devils bulled past Evgeni Malkin and fed a pass to Brian Boyle, who had gotten behind Phil Kessel and deposited the puck behind Murray for a shorthanded goal and 3-0 lead. Giving up a league-worst 11th shorthanded goal had to be deflating for the Penguins; the lack of effort several of them put into preventing the most recent one should have been even more discouraging. The Penguins’ penalty-killers gave up a goal, but they also scored one, even though the outcome had pretty well been determined by the time Cullen beat Devils goalie Keith Kincaid with 7:30 to go in regulation.
COACHING
Grade: D.
It wouldn’t be entirely accurate to say that Mike Sullivan didn’t have his team ready to play for the first time in nine days, because the Penguins actually looked fairly focused and involved through the early part of the opening period. They seemed to get that out of their systems by around the middle of the first, however, and were consistently outworked throughout the evening. Sullivan has accomplished an awful lot during his three-plus years behind the Penguins’ bench, but figuring out how to beat New Jersey isn’t on the list. The Penguins are 1-5-1 in their past seven against the Devils, who have won just six road games – the fewest of any NHL club – all season but are 2-0 at PPG Paints Arena. If the Penguins get an unfavorable matchup during Round 1 of the playoffs – or simply fail to qualify for the postseason – their inability to take points from teams like New Jersey will be a big part of the reason.
Dave Molinari: Dmolinari@Post-Gazette.com and Twitter @MolinariPG.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.