1. Jim Rutherford remains open for business when it comes to trades, per his usual, but the Penguins general manager made it clear Monday he does not feel the same urgency as he did last year to upgrade his third-line center position.

In fact, over the past two or three weeks, Rutherford said, he’s actually been encouraged by Derick Brassard’s play, believing the player has finally started to accept a role that he’s never really had before.

“I don’t know exactly how to explain it,” Rutherford told the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette Monday while the Penguins practiced at UPMC Lemieux Sports Complex. “He’s a top-six player. Has been his whole career. There’s clearly been an adjustment here to his role.

“Is it more of an acceptance of the role? Whatever it is, I’ve seen it for a few weeks now.”

Advertise with us

If it turns out that Rutherford is content with Brassard, that nixes what could potentially be the Penguins’ biggest move of the upcoming trade deadline. Instead, they’d probably just ship out a defenseman and make another subtle tweak or two.

Standing pat would send a message to Brassard, current linemates Tanner Pearson and Phil Kessel, and coach Mike Sullivan, basically telling them, “Work it out.”

It would also chart a different path from last season — and that could be intentional. Once the Penguins found themselves during the second half, Rutherford pushing his chips to the middle of the table with that complicated Brassard deal, for myriad reasons, never really made the Penguins better.

“We had a bigger need last year than we have right now,” Rutherford said. “I don’t know where things will go on the trade front, but I don’t feel the same urgency as I felt last year to strengthen our center position, which was a big need last year.”

None of this, of course, is final. There’s still plenty of hockey to be played and decisions to be made. With that in mind, let’s examine this decision a little more because it could turn out to be a big one.

Advertise with us

2. Before the Christmas break, Rutherford said he would be monitoring the Penguins’ third-line center spot, to ensure that Brassard is the right guy for the team.

Nick Bonino was that guy, but it didn’t make sense for the Penguins, with Sidney Crosby and Evgeni Malkin on their roster, to give Bonino, then 29, $16.4 million over four years the way that Nashville did.

Filling that void took an extraordinarily long time, and some may argue the Penguins are still searching for someone to fill Bonino’s role: playing in all situations while being stout defensively, winning faceoffs and adding some offense; someone who’s completely comfortable in a non-top-six role; and someone who meshes with Phil Kessel, whom the Penguins, most nights, would prefer to keep away from Crosby and Malkin to promote scoring depth.

While Brassard has had his struggles here, including a pair of lower-body injuries that have seemingly had a pretty drastic effect, he has shown at least a few signs of life over the past couple weeks, including the best game yet for the Pearson-Brassard-Kessel line Sunday against Chicago.

“We’re hopeful that that line potentially should be, could be very dangerous with the players that are on it,” Sullivan said. “All three of them are very good offensively. They have great instincts. They’re all a little bit different in the skill sets that they bring. But they have all the makings of being a very, very good line for us.”

Advertise with us

3. The topic of Brassard and fit will be a thing around here until it’s not.

On one hand, Brassard is on pace for 16 goals and 29 points. That would actually be a better offensive year than what Bonino did for the Penguins in 2015-16 (9-20–29 in 63 games). It’s even similar to what the Capitals got out of their third-line center, Lars Eller (18-20—38 in 81 games), last season. That came on a $3.5 million contract, which is only $500,000 higher than Brassard’s cost to the Penguins.

But you could also argue that the Penguins are paying just 60 percent of Brassard’s salary — Vegas is paying the other $2 million — because they gave up a ton to get him: a 2018 first-round pick, top goaltending prospect Filip Gustavsson, Ian Cole and Ryan Reaves.

Should the Penguins keep Brassard?

One school of thought says they should; he’s played in big games, produced, and it’s only a matter of time until he does the same here. But what if he doesn’t? What if not seeing top-six time continues to be an issue Brassard struggles to overcome?

Advertise with us

4. If the Penguins do decide to move on from Brassard, there’s one player in particular I think would be very interesting: Eric Staal from Minnesota.

There’s obviously no shortage of positive feelings that exist between Staal and Rutherford dating back to the decade the two spent with the Carolina Hurricanes.

Staal, 34, makes just $3.5 million, the same as Eller, and will be an unrestricted free agent after the season — meaning it’s essentially a straight swap for Brassard. He’s a year removed from scoring 42 goals and had 28 the season before that.

The problems are cost and whether Staal would actually be available. Right now the Wild have won three in a row, occupy a playoff spot and would obviously not want to trade Staal. But before that they dropped 11 of 15. If this current run doesn’t stick and they fall off, who knows?

Also, Minnesota — or any acquiring team — would need to actually be interested in Brassard, although I’d imagine the Wild could probably give Brassard the regular top-six minutes that he misses.

Advertise with us

It’s a long shot, sure, but it is one of several routes the Penguins could go if they decide Brassard is not the guy.

5. What about keeping Brassard, would that make sense?

Given his pedigree, his previous history of playing with skilled players and what seemed to click for that line Sunday, I do want to see a little more. I’ve written in this space before I didn’t think it would work and was surprised by some of what we saw against the Blackhawks.

Brassard had a couple of terrific chances, and Pearson said they graded out extremely well when it came to the Penguins’ internal numbers.

“We had a lot of chances,” Pearson said. “We had seven or eight compared to just one against. Any time you do that, it’s usually a pretty good outcome for your line.”

Advertise with us

I really liked the one-timer Brassard fired from the right circle for his goal. I also like that he was at least available and in the right spot for a couple other opportunities, even if he booted them. Overall, it was probably the most cooperative play — borrowing a Sullivan term — we’ve seen from that group.

“I felt pretty good with the way we played,” Brassard said.

What I liked most, though, came in the morning.

“We’re looking forward to being a little bit more dangerous offensively,” Brassard said, making what almost sounded like a backhanded guarantee.

If he’s going to be cocky about this whole thing — confident might be a better term — I don’t think that’s the worst thing. And maybe that’s what Rutherford has seen: more ownership taken to make this work and function as the player the Penguins thought they were getting.

Advertise with us

6. I do think there’s some mental gymnastics that must be done with these three guys, as none of them are traditional third-line players.

But the Penguins, because of Crosby and Malkin and what has typically worked with them — Bryan Rust and Jake Guentzel, for instance — there are only so many top-six jobs available for players who could probably have an easier time securing those minutes in other cities.

I approached Pearson with this idea, and he agreed. That it does take some work to get over the fact that you’re on the third line, but there’s a pretty healthy reminder (perhaps the sum total of their salaries: $13.55 million) that third-line duty here is different from that in other NHL markets.

“Any time you look at the depth of our team, it’s pretty hard to take it as a third-line kind of thing,” Pearson said. “Having four lines is huge. It evens out the minutes. … It’s been a good line. We just have to keep going.”

7. Back to the negative view here, though: Brassard’s underlying numbers were a hot mess before Sunday.

Advertise with us

In the previous five games, Brassard was on the ice for just 32.1 percent of five-on-five shot attempts and 26.2 percent of scoring chances.

Those aren’t everything, I’ll agree, but they are something.

8. With the Penguins seemingly settling into some lines that afford them balance, it looks like Brassard’s role on this team will be to play with Pearson and Kessel and — they hope — produce goals and points.

There’s honestly nowhere else to go, aside from another team. Left wing with Crosby is out. And given what Rutherford said above, a trade seems like a last resort at this point.

“We were involved,” Brassard said of Sunday’s game. “We were trying to chip in. If we have four lines that can go, we’re going to be a more dangerous team. We’re just connecting. We’re on the same page.

Advertise with us

“We’ll try to build on that game.”

9. What does it say about your All-Star Game format that Kris Letang may not even be the biggest snub?

It’s entirely possible that, barring the “Last Men In” vote, that six of the top 15 scorers in the NHL will not represent their teams in San Jose, Calif.

That list includes Toronto’s Mitch Marner; Calgary’s Sean Monahan; Tampa Bay’s Brayden Point; Edmonton’s Leon Draisaitl; and two more Flames in Matthew Tkachuk and Elias Lindholm.

Perhaps even more egregious, Buffalo’s Jeff Skinner, who’s No. 2 in goals, would have to win the vote to go. Letang, Point and Draisaitl fall into the same category.

Advertise with us

Isn’t the idea to showcase offense and your best players?

"The new All-Star format has worked in many ways, but the one way it hasn’t worked is it takes away from a situation like this, where you have more than one player who has earned the right to go there,” Rutherford said. “As we know, the host team gets extra players and the Stanley Cup team, which is totally understandable. I agree with it. But it does hurt certain teams.”

10. One of those could easily be the Penguins — if Capitals center Nicklas Backstrom winds up going ahead of Letang, who ranks third in goals (10) by a defenseman and sixth in points (37) while playing perhaps the best hockey of his career.

However, the back end of this is Letang could probably use the rest.

And even if Letang does go, Rutherford thinks that the Penguins’ bye week — the five days immediately preceding the All-Star break — could help Crosby and potentially Letang.

Advertise with us

“The good thing this year is our bye week leads up to the All-Star Game,” Rutherford said. “So for a guy like Sid or Kris, they still get their break, then get back into the All-Star Game. I don’t think that the rest is as necessary as it would be in other years.”

11. As good as Letang was during Sullivan’s first year in 2015-16, I honestly think he may be even better now.

There’s the 20-goal pace. Several shutdown defensive performances (Dec. 19 in Washington stands out). A seven-game point streak. Key roles on special-teams units that both rank in the top-six. Advanced numbers that rank among the best at his position.

I asked Rutherford whether this is the best he’s seen Letang.

“I don’t know because he’s played a lot of good hockey for us,” Rutherford said. “Clearly he’s at the top of his game now.”

Advertise with us

12. There’s an interesting trend occurring with the Penguins this season, and it seemingly takes conventional wisdom and chucks it out the window: They’ve actually fared better when they give up more shots on goal than they take.

They’re 6-7-3 when they have more shots than their opponent but 15-6-1 when they get outshot.

On the surface, it might look strange — don’t more shots lead to more scoring opportunities? — but I spent some time this week drilling deeper into what this trend is all about.

13. For one, it’s not just the Penguins. The emphasis on shot attempts and shots on goal has been happening for a while now, and Matt Cullen has a pretty good idea how and when it started.

“The game has gone that way since the Corsi stat came into the forefront years ago,” Cullen said. “All of a sudden teams started throwing shots. I’ve played on teams where shot attempts are talked about a lot in the room. It’s a priority to get pucks toward the net.”

Advertise with us

Corsi, for those who might not know, is another way of saying five-on-five shot attempts. Since hockey doesn’t have time of possession like, say, football, this is the best we can do, flawed as it may be.

But Cullen is right; there are teams that prioritize winning the possession game. Shot attempts also get glamorized by agents looking to prove their clients’ value and coaches trying to play a certain way.

14. The Penguins want to shoot the puck, of course, but not in the same way that teams such as the Carolina Hurricanes do. They take shots from pretty much everywhere. Even if the first attempt is only so-so, their hope is that it’ll create a next-play opportunity.

As a result, Carolina is averaging 36.6 shots on goal per game, which is the highest mark of the post-lockout era. The Hurricanes are also just 19-17-5, so the effectiveness of that particular strategy remains to be seen.

League-wide, teams are averaging about two more shots on goal per game than they did in 2015-16.

Advertise with us

“It seems like teams just want to shoot it from everywhere and put pucks on net, even at bad angles and drive the net,” Olli Maatta said. “Sometimes we want to do it as well. That’s a smart play when you have guys going to the net. You just want to put it on net, try to get a rebound out of it in a scramble. That’s the way the game is now.”

15. Where the Penguins fit here is interesting to me.

They pride themselves on being a possession team, but that doesn’t necessarily manifest itself in having a good Corsi or anything like that.

In the last three full seasons, the Penguins have attempted 11,553 shots during five-on-five play, which is the eighth-most in the NHL. Their Corsi For percentage — I often refer to this as shot share because I think it’s easier to understand — is 51.7, which ranks fifth during that time.

So, yes, the Penguins definitely want to attempt shots, but they also want to attempt shots that will result in shots on goal and, hopefully, scoring chances.

In that same stretch, the Penguins lead the NHL in shots on goal at 6,504 and scoring chances — both five-on-five — at 5,585.

“We focus more on hanging onto pucks and possessing the puck,” Cullen said. “I think it’s two different thought processes.

“The more we hang onto the puck in the offensive zone, the better opportunities we’re going to get as the game goes along.”

16. But that only covers half the stat. The Penguins have still given up more shots than they’ve taken in 22 of 42 games thus far (52.4 percent), yet they’ve managed to fare extremely well when that happens.

One of the reasons, at least lately, has been goaltending, with the strong play of Matt Murray since he came back from injury and Casey DeSmith before that.

“Our goalies have been great lately,” Maatta said.

The success rate when winning while getting outshot is also somewhat new. The Penguins were 14-14-1 when that happened in 2017-18, 18-13-3 in 2016-17 and 13-9-1 when it occurred 2015-16.

But the shot disparity has still been crazy, and it’s showing no signs of stopping.

Teams are averaging 31.5 shots on goal per game this season through Sunday’s games, which is up from 29.7 in 2015-16, the year Sullivan took over.

That season, just 13 teams averaged 30 or more shots on goal per game. In 2018-19, that number was 22 after Sunday’s games.

17. But again, it’s not all about quantity. For the Penguins, it’s about quality — and that has enabled them to stay competitive where they don’t win the battle on the shot clock.

I really liked Sullivan’s answer on the topic and wanted to convey that in its entirety. I had asked Sullivan how the Penguins have managed to fare so well despite getting outshot so much:

“I think you’ve got to drill down a little bit deeper than just look at the shot clock,” Sullivan said. “The shot clock is one statistic, but it can be deceiving. It doesn’t always tell the story.

“I will say that our team tends to be selective on when they shoot. We try to encourage our guys to shoot the puck more than we do. I wish we would, quite honestly. We have a team that it’s part of its DNA; we have a lot of playmakers who are looking for that next play or that play that might be better than what they see.

“As a coaching staff, coaching the offense, we always try to be very cautious that we don’t over-coach it or we try not to get in the way because we believe we have some guys who are difference-makers and see the game differently than most. That’s what makes them what they are.

“We try to tread softly with how we coach the offense. We want to give them strategies and concepts so that we can work cooperatively and we can be somewhat predictable for one another. But part of what makes our team unique is our ability to go off the grid a little bit and act on their instincts.”

18. I tweeted this the other night, but Pascal Dupuis did not skip the honoring of the 2008-09 Stanley Cup team because of some issue with the organization.

Things have been (mostly) smoothed over, but Dupuis did have a medical issue in his family and chose to stay home instead.

Nothing more, nothing less.

And from what I hear, the issue — which he wants to remain private — is trending upward.

19. One area where I think the Penguins have been a little more cautious with Murray since he returned from injury is letting him play with a clear head versus working on anything overly technical in his game.

They’re not forgoing coaching, by any stretch; that would be impossible. But there seemingly has been a greater emphasis placed on just playing, getting back to the read-and-react stuff that made Murray so good earlier in his career.

“Mike Buckley is as good as any goalie coach in the league,” Rutherford said. “He understands these players inside and out. I do think sometimes when there’s an area that any player, but especially a goalie, is working on, there’s a fine line to walk. How hard do you focus on it and push on it, where you’re focusing too much on that area and other areas are slipping? They always work through that.”

20. As more people have taken note of Crosby’s two-way play and (legitimate) candidacy for the Selke Trophy, there’s been more talk about the captain’s work on the penalty kill.

His response to that line of questioning Monday made me laugh.

I asked Crosby, who hasn’t consistently killed penalties since early in his career, whether there was any sort of adjustment required to get back on the PK.

“It took probably a few shifts,” Crosby said. “It depends. The in-zone is different depending on who you play, trying to be aware of passing lanes and things like that. That’s still not completely comfortable yet. But as far as teams’ breakouts and things like that, there’s a lot of anticipation and reading plays and things, so that comes a little bit quicker.”

Crosby, of course, said he would attend penalty kill meetings not because he was required but because “you learn a lot as far as what you can do on the power play when you’re involved in the PK and how teams try to defend certain things.”

Sounds a little different than James Harrison and his recliner, no?

And then making the necessary adjustments … oh, in a couple shifts.

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.