NEW YORK — Sidney Crosby has won plenty of hockey hardware.

There’s the three Stanley Cups, the same number of times the NHLPA has voted him winner of the Lester B. Pearson/Ted Lindsay Award as the league’s most outstanding player. Don’t forget about the Art Ross, Hart and Conn Smythe trophies (all twice) and those Olympic gold medals. Even the Rocket Richard, in 2010.

Yet as crowded as Crosby’s literal and figurative mantle may be, there’s one accolade that has eluded the Penguins captain: The Selke Trophy, awarded annually to the NHL’s best defensive forward.

While Crosby is on pace for 107 points — his most since that last scoring title in 2013-14 — and the third-best offensive season of his career, Crosby has taken his two-way play to another level.

Advertise with us

To a place that, if enough people start paying attention, it should burnish his candidacy for an award that has been dominated recently by Boston’s Patrice Bergeron and Los Angeles’ Anze Kopitar, who’ve snagged the past five and six of the past seven.

Compare Crosby’s numbers to the Selke Trophy winners of the past 10 years, and he’s right there with all of them. In some cases, such as pure offense, he’s worlds ahead.

“Nobody talks about [Crosby’s Selke candidacy] because he’s so dynamic offensively,” Matt Cullen said. “But his defensive play is so underrated, partly because he has the puck a lot. He matches up against the other team’s best line almost every night. He often takes faceoffs in his own end.

“The way he’s playing and has been for quite some time, it’s pretty unreal.”

Crosby should get more attention for the Selke Trophy, but for whatever reason, he doesn’t. The closest he ever came was 2015-16, when he finished seventh.

Advertise with us

Much like one of his idols, longtime Red Wings pivot Steve Yzerman, Crosby’s two-way game has enjoyed marked improvement as he’s gotten older.

While he’s still more than capable of scoring, as evidenced by offensive work this season, Crosby has also been good down low, in the battle areas, on faceoffs, against opponents’ top lines and, in a relatively new development of late, on the penalty kill.

“As you get older, you learn and understand that can help you the other way, too, if you spend less time in your end and you’re good defensively,” Crosby said back in April. “Being good defensively doesn’t have to take away from your offense. Sometimes you might think that. It doesn’t always work that way.”

What has Crosby done that has been so special? Let’s take a look and compare it to what has become the standard for those Selke winners:

• Through 37 games — he missed three with an upper-body injury — Crosby has won 56.5 percent of his faceoffs, while the past 10 Selke winners have averaged a 56.8-percent success rate on draws.

Advertise with us

Furthermore, Crosby is winning 53.0 percent of his defensive-zone draws, which shows a fairly drastic improvement from his past three years: 48.7 percent in 2017-18, 45.2 in 2016-17 and 49.0 in 2015-16, according to Penguins historian Bob Grove.

Although he’s been below 50 percent in the past two games, before that Crosby enjoyed a career-best stretch of 13 consecutive winning nights in the faceoff circle.

• If you want to look at shot attempts or scoring chances, Crosby has fared extremely well there, too.

He’s accounting for 56.2 percent of five-on-five shot attempts and 55.8 percent of scoring chances. The past 10 Selke winners have accounted for 56.8 and 56.5 percent in those categories.

Conclusion: Crosby’s right there, especially if you take into account the next category.

Advertise with us

• Again, five-on-five, Crosby has buttressed his team’s goals-for percentage in a big way.

Crosby’s goals-for percentage this season is 70.2, which ranks second among all NHL skaters who have played at least 500 minutes. Aside from injury-shortened campaigns in 2011-12 (70.5) and 2012-13 (71.2), Crosby has never before been over 63.5 percent (2010-11).

When you look at the Selke Trophy winners over the past 10 years, those guys had a goals-for percentage of 60.6.

How much Crosby has dominated this aspect of play is even more impressive when you consider that Crosby has accounted for more than 70 percent of the goals scored while routinely playing against other teams’ top lines. The Penguins have already played the Capitals three times, the Maple Leafs and Avalanche twice, along with the Flames, Jets and Blue Jackets once; all are in the top 10 in offense. (Crosby missed the Lightning game on Nov. 15.)

“He’s facing the best forwards on each team,” Kris Letang said. “He’s really good on both sides of the puck. Defensively he’s always low, he’s always battling. He definitely should be there [among Selke candidates].”

Advertise with us

• It’s also instructive to look at offense allowed, not just in proportion to how much Crosby has created.

Crosby right now is playing to a mark of 23.7 scoring chances allowed per 60 minutes of five-on-five ice time. Ignore the number if it confuses you and know this: The past 10 Selke winners have been somewhere between 18.1 and 25.3 in that category. Kopitar last year was the 25.3 mark, so Crosby is absolutely in range.

The same goes for high-danger chances per 60. Crosby is at 10.4, the same as Kopitar a season ago. With a ton more offense created, too — the potential for five more goals and 15 more points, if this pace holds.

If Kopitar won last season, why not Crosby?

• But seriously. Forget the offense. The past 10 Selke winners have averaged 30 goals and 73 points per season. With another two-point night Wednesday — his career-long-tying fifth in a row— Crosby is now on pace for 41 goals and 107 points.

Advertise with us

The closest point total among Selke winners studied was Detroit’s Pavel Datsyuk’s 97 in 2008-09, while Ryan Kesler (then with Vancouver) had 41 goals in 2010-11. On the whole, Crosby wins this in spades.

There are two categories that could determine Crosby’s candidacy, in addition to whether voters — the Professional Hockey Writers Association — take seriously the best offensive player of his generation transforming himself into a legitimate two-way force.

Selke Trophy winners over the past 10 years have never missed more than three games, the same number that Crosby has already missed. If he gets hurt again, that could, well, hurt.

There’s also time spent on the penalty kill. While Crosby has seen a minute or more of PK time eight times in the Penguins’ past 19 games, he’s still only averaging 25 seconds per game on the PK.

The past 10 Selke winners have averaged 1:50 of short-handed ice time per game.

Advertise with us

But with that number likely to grow — coach Mike Sullivan has been thrilled with Crosby’s work there — is that enough to ruin what is otherwise an extremely solid body of work?

Those who watch him play every night certainly don’t think so.

And with the look of the field this season — Bergeron has been hurt; Kopitar and the Kings have struggled — it may be Crosby’s best chance yet to win the Selke.

“It’s surprising he’s never won it when you look at what he’s been able to do with his two-way game,” Jake Guentzel said. “He’s a 200-foot player. That’s why he plays against top lines. He’s so good at it. Definitely shocking that he hasn’t won one.”

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.